The complaint has been investigated and
resolved to the customer's satisfaction
American Home Shieldfraudulant practices

This is my nightmare with america home shield

Take them to court!!!
You can do all the paperwork online!!!

I filed a claim with ahs in oct. 2008 for a spa heater that was worn out and finally broke. The first person they sent out said that the spa was not to code and ahs denied the claim. The spa was almost 20 yrs old. I called the manufacturer, who inspected the unit and they confirmed that the spa was properly built to code. They also provided a replacement cost for the unit.

I called ahs back and requested that they sent someone else out to inspect the spa heater. This person stated that the spa broke due to age and wear & tear. Ahs denied the claim because they said the damage was caused by chemicals. There was no bases for this determination except that their policy does not cover damage caused by chemicals. I informed them that the spa cannot work without chemicals. How can they cover a system that requires chemicals to work properly and then deny the claim for using the chemicals. Duh!!! The heater gave out due to wear and tear (Which is what they do cover). This was also the diagnosis from the manufacturer. Ahs denied the claim again.

I did not contact the california department of insurance because they cannot make ahs pay anything, they only look for infractions in the claims handling and do not care about the consumer.

The cost to replace the system was approx. $3, 000 and i sent them a demand to pay. They denied the demand. I then filed a claim in small claims court against ahs and they played the "name game". Just fyi, they are not actually "america home shield" each state is governed under a separate entity. I had to contact the president's office of ahs to determine the proper entity of ahs that my contract was written under. America home shield of californial. I had to make the necessary corrections to the small claims court because america home shield is not a company in california without the "california" behind it.

All of this took time, which i don't have much of, but this was an injustice. Read the numerous complaints on the interest. I refused to be jerked around and am very aware of how to read a policy. I am a claims adjuster! My company would never think to act so irresponsibly. We try to cover claims, not look for excuses to deny.

I filed the complaint and was looking forward to taking my turn in the court. Four days prior to the court date, ahs of california, contacted me and wanted to settle the claim with a policyholder's release. They asked me how much i wanted. I included the cost for each time i was charged for their service call, my postage, copying costs, court costs, and provided them with the actual cost of the spa heater and labor to install it. I signed that release and they paid every penny.

They also sent me a letter that they refused to cover the spa until the new one was replaced. I sent them a letter and said that i no longer needed coverage on the spa now and would like a refund of my premium. They refused and said i needed to pay for the coverage until the end of the policy period. I may still pursue that portion even though it is minimal.

Then last week, i received a letter from ahs that they are going to cancel my policy at the end of the policy period. Wow, what a surprise!!

I am writing this for all those individuals who just give up. Read the ahs policy. They hire contractors who do not like dealing with them because they know what they do to their policyholders. Sometimes, it is not the contractor who is at fault. The second contractor said that he recommended that they replace the spa heater. Then the claims adjuster said that he told them it was the chemicals. I got them both on a conference call and they both hemmed and hawed. Finally, the claims adjuster said that it had to be reviewed by a higher power. I then got a letter saying that the damage was caused by chemicals. So it is not always the contractor.

Btw, i recorded every conversation and transcribed everything they told me. The recording is not admissable in court, but what they told me, is.

I no longer have ahs and am saving $50. Per mo. I want you to know that if you want something covered by there policy, find your own contractor to assess the problem and fight them. Take them to court. You can do all the paperwork online!!! It is more cost effective for them to settle with you than to go to court and get another judgement againt them.

Don't just take no...
Best of luck


  • Op
    Opiuse Dec 12, 2011
    This comment was posted by
    a verified customer
    Verified customer

    On August 13th our Air Conditioning Unit failed. We called AHS to report the issue. We were told a contractor would be to us within 48 hours. Bear in mind that 3 boys sleep in this area and the thermostat has read over 90 degrees every day/night. After 3 days someone came and did not diagnose the issue but told us to add more amps to the circuit breaker. This was done and the issue occured again. Once again we called and someone was dispatched within 48 hours. 3 days later someone arrived and told us lightening hit the AC unit. We called AHS and our insurance carrier and we were told that this was not covered by AHS and our insurance carrier would have to handle. We contacted AHS and said we wanted a third opinion. We were told we would have to pay. This now September 17th, one month later and my children cannot sleep in their rooms with 90 + degree temperatures. Dave Crawford, President of AHS was contacted for help and his assistant stated he would help. My wife called again and we finally have someone coming out to replace our compressor tomorrow, 37 days after the first call! After paying our monthly fees we will still need to pay out of pocket for the replacement. The performance of AHS has been negligent and beyond unacceptable. I strongly urge anyone considering using them to stop.

    0 Votes
  • Ad
    Advice_Question Dec 22, 2009

    I had a similar experience with AHS and now have a broken spa that has not been fixed. Any suggestions of where to take my case?

    0 Votes

Post your comment

    By clicking Submit you are agreeing to the Complaints Board’s Terms and Conditions



    Unhappy consumers gather online at and have already logged thousands of complaints.
    If you see dozens of complaints about a certain company on ComplaintsBoard, walk away.
    One of the largest consumer sites online. Posting here your concerns means good exposure for your issues.
    A consumer site aimed at exposing unethical companies and business practices.
    ComplaintsBoard is a good source for product and company gripes from especially dissatisfied people.
    You'll definitely get some directions on how customer service can best solve your problem.
    Do a little research on the seller. Visit consumer complaint websites like ComplaintsBoard.