Menu
Write a review
File a complaint
Safe Auto Insurance

Safe Auto Insurance review: Claims

S
Author of the review
10:05 am UTC
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

Hello,

I writing about the service and the way I have been treated by your claims reps. I was involed in an accident with one of your policy holders. On 8/26/2021. I spoke with the claims rep Roberto Plascencia. In sept 6 I believe, I Informed him that I was trying to get my car in the shop but unable to get it fixed before October. At that time I explained to him about my vehicle I drive an suv to transport my kids to and from school. I need a some comparable to hold the same amount of people. He said no problem we will set it up when you get ready to drop off. Two wks later I get a check in mail for damages, tried call him back no response. I have left messages every weeks and still have not gotten a response. I called on Thursday to make sure rental was set for Monday drop off of my car and was told I had to call the sam day I drop off the car. Big inconvenience, asked for a supervisor was told that they wouldn't call me back and the claims reps were trained to handle the calls. called Monday 10/25 spoke with Rico or Rick asked for a supervisor because I clearly stated I needed a vehicle to accommodate my family. Was told supervisor would call back I asked for time was told he doesn't have a time. Supervisor has to approve the rental. Meanwhile I have to work. Called to get rental it's set up in my husbands name and not my name I'm the owner of the car and I'm the one driving. Called back after waiting on hold for 30 mins to speak with Ale. Asked for supervisor explained the name change and the car issue. I repeatedly asked for a supervisor. The rep states they will call back in 24-48 hrs. Explained that was unacceptable I need to get a rental car. I have a job and I have a family. On the phone holding back and forth being told the same thing for over an hour and a half. Waiting on the rep to talk with a supervisor then to me instead of putting the supervisor on the phone. The rep would rather go back and forth with me then to try and resolve the situation. Supervisor still not on phone. Reps says I can upgrade to. Nissan Versa or Toyota Yaris. I drive a Chevy traverse. That can seat all four of my kids not a small compact car. Still no supervisor. Still waiting. I'm on hold while I type this complaint. She then tell me she can put in the order then have a supervisor call me back. Again inconvenience, no I wanna speak with a supervisor I'm told it's Monday over and over agin. Ok it's Monday your hours of operation are Mon-Fri. It's Monday and I'm missing work trying to resolve the issue of not having a car and dealing with someone else insurance company. The lack of empathy for my inconvenience I didn't cause the accident. I have kids that were in the accident my family has been through this whole ordeal and to call and have an insurance company employees have no empathy. No sense of customer service to assist in taken care of serious life issues. To have someone on the phone to hold when it can be taken care of without getting the client upset. I've never had service like this before. Never had a rep go back and forth instead of listening to what the issue is and solving. I work for the government and I deal with people daily and never would give this level of service to anyone. Just down right it is what it is. No sense of trying to help or fix the issue. Lack of follow up, lack of training. No consideration for time and people. Really a big inconvenience. I've missed a whole day of work trying to get this issue resolved. Still waiting. Is this the type of service one should expect from safe auto as normal. If I was the policy holder would I have been treated like this as well. The policy is in place to take care of accidents why is this a big problem. When it comes to the accident. Put on hold with music no warning.

Desired outcome: I would like a rep to call me back and get it taken care of

0 comments
Add a comment

More Safe Auto Insurance reviews & complaints

View all Safe Auto Insurance reviews and complaints
  1. Safe Auto Insurance Contacts

  2. Safe Auto Insurance phone numbers
    Click up if you have successfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (614) 231-0200 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (614) 231-0200 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (614) 231-0200 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (614) 231-0200 phone number
    Click up if you have successfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (800) 723-3288 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (800) 723-3288 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (800) 723-3288 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached Safe Auto Insurance by calling +1 (800) 723-3288 phone number
    SafeAuto General
  3. Safe Auto Insurance emails
  4. Safe Auto Insurance address
    4 Easton Oval, Columbus, Ohio, OH43219, United States
  5. Safe Auto Insurance social media
  6. Michael
    Checked and verified by Michael This contact information is personally checked and verified by the ComplaintsBoard representative. Learn more
    Jul 29, 2026
  7. View all Safe Auto Insurance contacts