Menu
Write a review
File a complaint
Advance Auto Parts

Advance Auto Parts review: recycle used oil

R
Author of the review
3:58 pm UTC
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

Good Day, pursuant to a situation I en-counted at the Island Park Store on Austin Blvd in Nassau County NY, I feel compelled to report this to the Corporate Office.
At approximately 11:30 today (Wednesday, October 2, 2019) I set out to my local Advance Auto Parts store to recycle approximately 5 gallons of used motor oil... I have done this countless times over the years using the same yellow Polyethylene 5 gallon container. on occasion I have been told the tank is full and the customer service individual will provide another location, that is perfect. As a precautionary measure, I always enter the store without the container to ask if I can deposit my used oil, today was no different, upon entering the store, I asked a gentleman at the register if I could deposit my oil, he said yes, but asked if it was contaminated with other fluids, my response was no, it was exclusively oil, he said bring it in.
upon re-entering the store, I was stopped by a different employee by the name of Kevin, who also told me he was the store manager, he told me he cannot except my oil because it was not in an approved container. my response was"your kidding right? I continued to say, Bro, I have been coming here for years with this same yellow 5 gallon container". He said "first of all, I aint your Bro! (this is true, but just speaking in terms of todays accepted dialog) he then proceeded to tell me that the container was yellow which signified diesel fuel and we cant except that", we only except approved containers". I asked him what was an approved container? it seemed like he said a red container, well red is for gas, regardless, Kevin talked to me like I was a subordinate and not a customer, the exchange became very heated between both of us because he did not speak with respect nor give any reasonable explanation...in the end of the encounter, he wound up telling me to get off the premises as if I was some kind of criminal. I am not a criminal, in fact I am a retired law enforcement officer who is 57 years old. I had a friend with me who is as-well a retired detective whom visited me that morning for breakfast who witnessed this whole exchange and was shocked!

Well, I came home and immediately pulled up the advance auto parts oil recycling procedures and read right from your website that I did in fact follow the procedure... all it said was it had to be in an appropriate polyethylene container as is all fuel type containers and not in water jugs (please see link below). I would also like to mention, that I don't own a diesel vehicle and never did, and never used this container for any type of fuel, just for used oil which I could easily be verified by just looking in the container and smelling it... clearly it smells like used motor oil.
I certainly recommend with great urgency that this store manager be trained or retrained on corporate policy and more importantly, how to speak to customers... I was appalled, and embarrassed that this demeaning conversation took place in the presence of 2 other customers in the store.

Completely uncalled for reaction by Kevin, store manager at the Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY store. My opinion is, he should have said OK, the cashier said it was fine, but in the future you must use... whatever kind of container he was eluding too.

Awful, it ruined my whole day! Someone must talk to him about this. Also, when I told him I was going to contact the Corporate office, his response was" go ahead, my name is Kevin, I'm the store manager".

Please see attached pics of my used oil container and the marking at the bottom indicating HDPE which is polyethylene as an approved container material indicated on your website. see below for link...

https://shop.advanceautoparts.com/r/advice/car-maintenance/why-recycle-motor-oil

Thankyou, John Landi.

View 0 more photos
0 comments
Add a comment

More Advance Auto Parts reviews & complaints

Advance Auto Parts - warranty fraud 10
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Advance Auto Parts - denied warranty for defective muffler 17
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Advance Auto Parts - Refund delayed for days after return and manager rude and unhelpful 7
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Advance Auto Parts - not qualified to install battery 15
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Advance Auto Parts - fraud and cheating 2
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
View all Advance Auto Parts reviews and complaints
  1. Advance Auto Parts Contacts

  2. Advance Auto Parts phone numbers
    Click up if you have successfully reached Advance Auto Parts by calling +1 (877) 238-2623 phone number 1 1 users reported that they have successfully reached Advance Auto Parts by calling +1 (877) 238-2623 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached Advance Auto Parts by calling +1 (877) 238-2623 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached Advance Auto Parts by calling +1 (877) 238-2623 phone number
  3. Advance Auto Parts emails
  4. Advance Auto Parts address
    Store Support Center, 5008 Airport Road, Roanoke, Kentucky, 24012, United States
  5. Advance Auto Parts social media
  6. Nick
    Checked and verified by Nick This contact information is personally checked and verified by the ComplaintsBoard representative. Learn more
    Sep 15, 2026
  7. View all Advance Auto Parts contacts
Advance Auto Parts Category
Advance Auto Parts is ranked 13 among 324 companies in the Auto Parts and Repair Stores category