After checking my statement tonight, found $11.99 charge from MERCHANT PURCHASE TLG*GREATFN. I called my bank and was given the phone number for TLG (800-242-7771). After repeatedly saying "Cancel my account", I was finally given a canellation number and told to expect a refund in the next 1-2 billing cycles.
The agent told me this account was created after making a purchase from ShoeBuy.com. It seems they have a little checkbox on checkout asking if you want more deals and offers. The box is checked by default, so you'll be charged no matter what!