InTheMoneyStocks.com’s earns a 1.3-star rating from 2 reviews and 24 complaints, showing that the majority of traders are dissatisfied with investment strategies and guidance.
- All
- Reviews only
- Complaints only
- Resolved
- Unresolved
- Replied by the business
- Unreplied
- With attachments
Do not be scammed by gareth and the daily recap video
In the daily recap video:
1) gareth will brag about trades that he did not make in the chatroom!
2) gareth will not take responsibility for bad trades that he called out in the chatroom.
Do not be scammed by gareth and the daily recap video.
Not worth your time and money
I was with them for over 2 years, and was one of the first services I used when I was trying to learn this trade. Not knowing a whole lot at that time, I was immediately suckered into the "hype" of a "no-hype" pro trading service.
Looking back now, they have taught me many valuable lessons. That is, what a truly successful trader is NOT. I'm now able to distinguish snake oil salesmen quicker than than you can say "In The Money Stocks Dot Com".
In short, they make themselves look like a very legitimate service that is trying to teach a highly proprietary methodology known only to a select few. The reality is, it's just a very basic trading system put together with bits and pieces of very common technical trading ideas like moving averages, gap fills, Fibonacci retracements, pivot points, classical chart patterns (H&S, double bottoms etc..) and candle stick analysis. Of course, to give it their special touch, they throw in a very secret and proprietary "time count" system which is nothing more than an actual count of the number of bars you see. Voodoo trading? That's what you'll get here. All this for a cool 600 bucks to learn.
All right, my actual results with that. I tried both the professional chat room (200 bucks/mth) and their Research Centre (50/mth). Chat room was absolutely a joke, as most here already said. Gareth will take no responsibility for trades UNTIL they play out. Nick will make only 2 trading calls a MONTH. I did very poorly with them in terms of scalping. e..g making 35 cents on scalping a hundred dollar stock like GS... (it's a joke).
The swing trading aspect, Research Center, is half decent. 60^% of the trades actually do work well... but if you dig a little bit deeper, you'll notice very big flaws in their swing trades. Very wide stops, that absolutely do not seem to agree with that they preach during their trading Webinars. Why huge stops? Of course, keeps you in a bad trade longer in hopes that it'll turn out a winner.
In short, 20% actual technical analyais, 80% ego in there. Not worth your time and money...
lol totally correct, he gets excited about taking $1.50 move on aapl, mean while the stock just ran up 45 points. Garath is a pig with a big ego, bragging about his massive gains, not realizing 95% of the potential members have small accounts. His system is junk, t-3live is a much better service.
Stay away from this website
I agree with most of the people here. While I like Nick for being humble and honest, Nick is most times too careful and you don't get many trading ideas from him. Gareth Soloway, as one person describe here, is just like a used car salesman. On the nightly videos, you'll be primarily listening to Gareth tell you how many winning trades he did during the day and what the market did. I am primarily a swing trader and do not day trade, and I have lost more money with them than trading on my own. Yes, I'm a bad trader, but following them, I lost more...
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.
I had been communicating with Gareth via Twitter when I reached out respectfully in frustration as the unrealized losses were mounting well beyond the realized gains and his reply speaks for itself, via the screenshot. Absolutely disgusting. Needless to say, I will never do business with someone who would treat a client like this.
There is a lot of "smoke and mirrors" on this trading site. I was a member first of "Verified Investing Crypto" for about 8 or 9 months, then swtiched to "In the Money Stocks". The crypto service is pretty new, so the track record is pretty transparent. However, on the stock service, I would say that the "open trades" do not represent past "losers"... they either just stay in active trades or they disappear. I tried to ascertain how much of his portfolio had "disappeared" this way by following open trades in 2021 that never became "closed trades" and somehow just slid off the books... it was a huge amount, maybe over 65% of his portfolio disappeared. Which was pretty alarming. Don't believe me, look for yourself. ALSO the other problem is that his "method" is to invest minuscule amounts of his portfolio at a time, like 1%. I call these the "one off's" where if he's called it correctly, and to be fair, he does call things well most of the time, the problem is that if you make 10% on 1% of your portfolio, that's a POINT ONE percent return on your portfolio, not a 10 percent return. You would need fifty 10% return trades on a 1% investment to make a 5% on your portfolio. He justifies this by saying "we enter small and add". Well what that means is he has NO STOPS and he just keeps throwing money at loosers, sometimes to the tune of 10% of your portfolio or more. Then they can languish for weeks or months with you stressing out about it. When they do turn around, IF they turn around, he will be happy with a 5-7% return just to get out. Which means that you risked 10% of your portfolio to make a POINT FIVE to POINT SEVEN percent return on your entire portfolio. So if your portfolio is $100K, then that 10% follow the looser return will yield you only POINT 5-7% on your $100K. It all sounds good until you really sit down and look at how insane this is. I followed his advice, made a few hundred bucks here and there and all my profits were wiped out in one lousy trade he kept telling us to follow down the sewer. If you don't follow him and keep throwing money at it, you definitely will always lose because you're stuck with shares that he has "cost price averaged" down the drain. So you aren't getting a HUGE return for the stress you have to endure. I do think he has some good trading advice, I think that if you can just use it for a daily review of the market, and be EXTREMELY cautious about his trades, then go for it. I learned about charting and I would say that I was "schooled" in looking at trading ETF's, shorting, etc. So for that, I feel he was worth it. But I'm getting out because it's wearing thin and I don't like listening to the BS anymore.
You are wrong. I have followed him for THE PAST TEAR both stocks and crypto and he has been spot on. Made thousands from his advice.
I have been using their service for a year and I have learnt a lot and made money on several trades. The ones I have lost have been where I didn't follow their advice to size the trade properly. Not all their trades are perfect but majority of them work out for me. I would recommend them over other services I have had.
WBD Gareth still holding in live trading room. 1st August 2022 average is either $30 or $33. stock hit $13 and he had 18,000 shares. account wiped out for anyone following him. Also holding RCON at huge loss, BABA at a loss, are the ones i know about. not sure how anyone has money in there accounts to trade with if you follow the trades. i looked at verified investing alerts 12 months ago and account was loaded with losing trades. by all means learn from what the do but make it your own, and your responsibility. i use there day trading service to alert me too potential trades only.
Was making little profits on my own.
Portfolio size was 10k to start.
Rolled through 10k trades 3.3x and up +5.5%
Which is +16.5% on the 10k
I signed up month and half ago. (Swing trade alerts $99/mo)
He's been 100% accurate with +13% gain average (since I've been on).
I've not noticed any removing losses because it's been good thus far,..
... I will be keep track if I catch an L and he erases it.
I've profited $1,753.45 in month and a half.
I went bigger than suggested 1% on CVNA and MARA.
..and when he suggested FCX mining I went in on 3x mining ETF [MNM]..
that was heavy in FCX. Was nice move.
You will lose all your money . Don't believe me go and try .I Just saves you all your hard money . Everything all this people are saying is 200% the thru..
Everyone needs to understand what you will get out of their services as a whole. Gareth and Nick know what they're doing, there is no denying it. They are some of the best analytical chart traders in the industry and know how to spot trends. A novice could learn a heck of lot from these guys' concepts and approach to trading. The educational videos are fantastic and I've learned a ton from them.
The reality is however, you CANNOT blindly follow their Verified Investing alerts or day trades in the chat room. The day trades require way too much capital to turn a decent profit and to their credit they constantly preach trading small. You can't day trade small, it's a waste of time. One time Gareth put up 1.1M on the SPY around $450 and rode it out for maybe one minute to turn a $1, 000 profit. That is just not a reality for most people. As mentioned above, the day trades gone sour turn into swing trades. Nick won't chase losers, but Gareth will 5-6 times he will buy into a position. CHGG for example a month or so ago was bought at $35 all the way down to $28 and has just turned in to holding swing trade. Swing trades are generally recommended by Nick and Gareth to be around ~1-2% max portfolio. If you would have bought CHGG at 1% of your portfolio at $35, what kind of profit would you have made on 50 cent target move up? My advice for 99% of people is to listen to the day trading room for market insight but DO NOT follow their day trades unless you have their multi million dollar account size.
Most people will also lose money following the Verified Investing Alerts which are the Swing Trades. If you go to "Closed Positions" tab, you'll see a massive Gain % every single year for the last 10 years. This is misleading however, for two main reasons 1)not all positions are equal % sizes especially when they re-buy the stocks moving against them, and 2)they are holding a number of losers in Open Positions. And these are LARGE open losses if you're still in them, for example here are some currently open positions as of 12/13/21:
- Short AAPL $133.42 for 10% of portfolio (today's price ~$180)
- Short NVDA $201.94 for 12% of portfolio (today's price ~$300)
- Short TSLA $732 for 6% of portfolio (today's price ~$1000)
- Short HD $284 for 8% of portfolio (today's price ~$410)
- Short ASML $455 for 4% of portfolio (today's price ~$780)
- Short MSFT $303 for 9% of portfolio (today's price ~$343)
- Long VXX $42.30 for 6% of portfolio (today's price ~$21)
Several of these positions above have exceeded their stop price and someone else in the comments mentioned this as well. If you're going to follow their trades, there are rules you MUST follow. 1% or less for each position and stick with it. DO NOT chase stocks moving against you and set a stop loss (example 10%) that you actually stick with no matter what. By doing this you will severely limit your downside risk and also your upside, so don't expect to have 1000% returns like Gareth. There's no way to determine what your actual profitability would be since Gareth buys back almost every trade that moves against him, some of these work out and as you can see above, several do not and they can be painful.
While I do not recommend following the Daily Investing alerts blindly and/or 100% of the time, I still purchase the service for a few reasons. First off, it's cheap. Honestly. And I believe in their system and knack for reading charts and identifying trends. I follow a handful of services to obtain trade ideas and often times, Gareth and Nick are spotting the same market trends. That's what I want to be aware of. At the end of the day, it's a business and the better they can make these numbers look the more subscribers they'll obtain. If you understand all these facts, there is still usefulness to be found on their website and services.
I have been a member for almost 1 1/2 years now and I would call it a quite sophisticated scam.
It's a sophisticated gambling approach to trading. This might work in some markets but the last two years were basically the biggest bull market in history and I lost a substantial amount of money with the investing alerts.
These guys are short big tech for over 1 1/2 years and long china stocks for a good while. Both went in the complete opposite direction. And when it goes against you they don't adhere to their own stop losses.
There will be money added to losing trades and winning trades will just be closed after 1-10%.
No consideration of what's important (fundamentals) and it's all about charts (because it's easy to learn and easy understandable).
I would recommend to invest in a program with fundamental analysis. This is crazy and irresponsible trading and the complete opposite of what serious hedge fund managers do.
Best,
Someone in the comments mentioned that when their day trade goes wrong it becomes a Swing trade - That is true. Doesn't mean it will go bad, they might have got their timing wrong.
What doesn't add up is the conflict of Risk to Reward. Most dedicated traders will operate a 2XR so 2 times the reward to risk (or more). If you look through their open trades going back the last 12 months. You will see the risk is extremely high, in fact sometimes the stock has even passed their Stop Loss. Then, many swing trades don't even make the open list, but if they work then you bet they are in the winning closed trades and increase the percentage.
Lastly. The percentage you see is not on the whole account. it's on a tiny percentage of the account. If you sit down and do the maths you might come to say 20-35% growth. That's not bad, but after deductions of monthly fee, you might do just as well or better sticking your money on an index tracker.
Advice. If you stay in their room. Learn pattern trading (youtube), and always know why you are getting in a trade.
The site promotes &no hype& but he hypes more than any trader I have ever said
Educationally this site has some merits as Nick Santiago is a good teacher although he is not aggressive enough in trading so the site offers few swing trades. Gareth Soloway comes across as a used car salesman. The site promotes "no hype" but he hypes more than any trader I have ever said. Recently he posted the worse day trade of all time, ROSG, which stopped out so quickly it was embarrassing. He touts 8 or 9 winners out of 10 for swing trading but the site does not keep this in one place so one has to guess; my guess it is 6 out of 10 which a monkey can do as well.
Overview of InTheMoneyStocks.com complaint handling
-
InTheMoneyStocks.com Contacts
-
InTheMoneyStocks.com phone numbers+1 (212) 380-1578+1 (212) 380-1578Click up if you have successfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +1 (212) 380-1578 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +1 (212) 380-1578 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +1 (212) 380-1578 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +1 (212) 380-1578 phone number+49 7368 42105+49 7368 42105Click up if you have successfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +49 7368 42105 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +49 7368 42105 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +49 7368 42105 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached InTheMoneyStocks.com by calling +49 7368 42105 phone number
-
InTheMoneyStocks.com emailssupport@inthemoneystocks.com100%Confidence score: 100%Support
-
InTheMoneyStocks.com address401 N Ashley Dr. Suite 172013, Tampa, Florida, 33672, United States
-
InTheMoneyStocks.com social media
-
Checked and verified by Michael This contact information is personally checked and verified by the ComplaintsBoard representative. Learn moreJun 30, 2025
- View all InTheMoneyStocks.com contacts
Recent comments about InTheMoneyStocks.com company
Do not be scammed by gareth and the daily recap video


Our Commitment
We make sure all complaints and reviews are from real people sharing genuine experiences.
We offer easy tools for businesses and reviewers to solve issues together. Learn how it works.
We support and promote the right for reviewers to express their opinions and ideas freely without censorship or restrictions, as long as it's respectful and within our Terms and Conditions, of course ;)
Our rating system is open and honest, ensuring unbiased evaluations for all businesses on the platform. Learn more.
Personal details of reviewers are strictly confidential and hidden from everyone.
Our website is designed to be user-friendly, accessible, and absolutely free for everyone to use.
I agree. I've been paying for the crypto calls for the last few months and I could tell right away the calls were going to be good because he trades how the banks trade while retail loses all their money, nearly every time because they trade completely opposite. The banks and institutions either have people (and bots) out on message boards, youtube, google etc bad mouthing his service to keep retail from trading WITH them which takes away from the liquidity pool that they MUST have to fill orders worth tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars (building positions and distributing) or the people bad mouthing him are retail traders who are more like gamblers who probably put 10-30% of their entire portfolio into single trades then go haywire if they don't work out or they have to sit on the position for a while. Gareth knows that markets expand on all time frames so price will most likely retrace to fill his order at some point hence only using 2-6% of your portfolio per trade. I know for a fact that central bank traders and market makers buy below support and are still selling their position above resistance this is why Gareth has you build positions as well instead of triggering a stop loss if your long trade breaks support or vice versa for shorting the tops of moves. The entire system from global media to top ranked trading sites like investopedia to exchanges like Binance and their "Binance learn" program are designed to ensure that you trade the OPPOSITE of how the banks trade. This is why 90% of retail lose their money. Gareth understands this and it really shows with his patience in taking trades and non retail trading methodologies such as time counts. Anyway, don't listen to all these fake reviews guys. For 75$ (no contract, his signal group is month to month) you can sign up for one single month and see for yourself that the knowledge he teaches you in his videos are beyond worth it even if the signals did not exist! I put him up there with the greats like Steve (crypto crew university) and Benjamin Cowan (Into the cryptoverse). Cheers!
I could not DISAGREE with your post more. Clearly you do not have much knowledge on the subject, however, I do, and I can assure you that you are 100% lying in your review or lacking major knowledge on the subject. If you are referring to the member videos Gareth and Nick release for paying members, then it is even more clear that you are lying. In those videos they give out everything, and all details on every trade, from both services. I have been a member of both the intra day chat room and the research center, there is no grey area with Nick or gareth. These review sites are a breading ground for bashers, that is all, nothing useful can ever be found here.
exactly!