The complaint has been investigated and
resolved to the customer's satisfaction
Max Super Speciality Hospital (MSSH)Doctor' Negligence

I, Nisha Mangal, visited Max Super Speciality Hospital, Saket, New Delhi to consult Dr. Neena Bahl (Obstetrics & gynaecology) during my preegnancy. I was 6 week pregnant when i visited first time to her. Next time I visited her clinic when I was 10 weeks pregnant. I visited her with all the tests done as prescribed by her. She adviced me for an ultra sound between 11 to 14 weeks as per the procedure. She did my check up as she wanted to do. when my baby was already dead in my tommy, i had an missed abortion, then what did she checked in her check up, when even she can not come to know that baby is no more...

I really want to know the answer?

I got very disappointed when I gopt to know abt this after her 2 rounds of check up !!!



  • De
    Deepika Jun 15, 2009

    I am facing every possible hurdle that you were talking about in your post. That does discourage me at times however thankfully that does not stop me from going further with it. This may not sound good but my objective is to screw the happiness of the ppl who have given us this irreparable loss
    Pls write to me at [email protected] Would talk to you in detail abt my POA

    0 Votes
  • Is
    Ishi Jun 15, 2009
    This comment was posted by
    a verified customer
    Verified customer

    Deepika, Firstly, honestly speaking, on a personal front I am so broke by papa's sudden disappearance from our lives that I do not even have enough strength (both mental & physical), to take this up. Can't say when will I be able to gather myself and the bits and pieces of our lives which papa has left us with. Secondly, with papa leaving us, we've been left with no physical support to stand with us, against any such attrocity, even though that involves our lives this time. My mother, who like us, just could'nt help, but be a mute spectator to all that 'drama' we saw in the hospital, says that she has no more courage left to see any more in life, and losing out of any more from our already small close-knit family.

    And finally, coming to the most important of it all, in a historically 'corrupt' country like India, where 'goondaraj' prevails, since time infinity, where some people have got used to bearing all the suffering and the others have eaten out of inflicting that suffering, I am in no hope of getting any justice from any system; be it legal, social or medical.

    The fire with which I lit my father's pyre, the fire which reduced the existence of papa to ashes, also burns me down to ashes. I know that I will never be at peace with myself, till I sought out justice...But justice from whom?I will not find a single doctor to stand up for me and testify against those 'killers'. There is a whole 'lobby' of such people, who will ensure that we do not get anything out of this. And what can I expect from 'killers' who killed innocent people, while they were making a booty out of them. Will these 'bandits' come out in the open, when I were to challenge them? They have killed us when we were paying and 'worshipping' them, what would they do when we go out to question them? How will we prove that they r guilty and should be "hanged unto death"?

    I, too could've probably found some mental solace to see justice be given, and these killers be "hanged". But do we have a fair judiciary? Our judiciary gives a death penalty to the guilty (that also if found guilty, may be after decades of struggle, after generations come n go) in the 'rarest of the rare' cases. So, this is also something which these 'white-collared killers' will escape, as they have made these 'murders' so rampant and so common that it is now become an everyday day affair for them. This moves them out of the 'rarest of rare' bracket as well.

    The only thing now left would be to strip these people off their degrees and medical practicing licences and label them as "quacks" such that they are not even left able enough to fend for themselves and their families. Let all those 'murderers' and their families suffer and know the real meaning of life, and be forced to live, just the way they have compelled us to do. Let them not make their 'empire' on the graves dead of people and with walls made of their 'loot'.

    So, I thought to choose this medium to vent out my anger against all this, and not file any complaint, coz of the aformentioned reasons. But by saying all this, by no means am I dissuading u againt ur tirade. Someone definitely has to take a first step, but maybe you have people to fallback on. Be rest assured that I am with you in everything that you take up, for this cause. I am even ready to testify against anything and anybody u want to, in this concern. Please do let me know for any help or info that you may want from my end. Be assured, I am always there with you, by u...


    0 Votes
  • De
    Deepika Jun 13, 2009

    Ishi, I can completely feel and understand your pain. I am sorry to hear about your loss.

    Just wanted to check if you filed a police complaint for the same. If yes, what is the status. I strongly feel you should diver the anger and pain for a cause. This cause can be to punish the guilty to make sure this doesnot happen with anybody anytime.

    I am fighting Max and will make sure they will have sleepless nights

    0 Votes
  • Is
    Ishi Jun 12, 2009
    This comment was posted by
    a verified customer
    Verified customer

    I hate MAX, Saket...

    They killed my father (53), in a similar way as they killed Nitika. When papa complained of abdominal pain, they kept on spraying "Volini" spray..After my father's repeated complaints, of the pain not being muscular, no heed was paid, and papa stopped complaining as he said there was'nt a point in doing so. Finally, one 'fine' night after pushing me out of the ICU, I don't know what all did they do, that papa never woke up after that. I was called in the morning and told that they had put him on ventilator, as his BP had suddenly started falling (something for which they neither did they have a reason nor could diagnose it). And when i asked the reason for his unconciousness, they said that as a 'protocol' the person had to be sedated before putting him on ventilator, and he would wake up. after the effect of the sedative wears off. I trusted the doctor, and that cost me the biggest mistake of my life.

    After a 24hr-wait, when I questioned again the reason for his unconciousness, they declared that he has slipped into coma. Then on secretly checking the attending nurse's records I found that the 'killer doctors' had lied to me. Papa had been administered sedatives, even on the previous night (when they had turned me out of the ICU). He had been administerd I.V of morphine. Repeated dosages of sedatives ensured that papa never woke up, and those killers had succeeded in their job. They had justified their 'noble' profession. And one another day, papa gave up on his fight against coma.

    If this is what hospital and its treatment means, then I would perfer to die between my loved ones, and die untreated, rather be killed at the behest of these killers, who come in white collars, white coats, and go back with their hands colored red; a color which makes the lives of so many others colorless (including a life, which had wanted to live longer, enjoying the colors of life, and filling others life with their colors), and lets the bloodied hands of those kilers, unexposed and censored.

    Papa's zest to live life to its fullest was cut short by people who didn'nt have any right to govern the way he wanted to lead his life. For a person who never had any complaint in life, from life, has left behind his loved ones, who have nothing, but only complaints, left in life.

    I now pray (rather curse), that those killers get a bloodied and a brutal life (and not death, as that may ease out their sins); a life which would be worse than the pain of death.

    These 'killers' called doctors have no right to practice; practice taking one life after another.

    0 Votes
  • De
    Deepika Jun 03, 2009

    I have another story to share about Max, Pitam Pura

    lost my sister to negligence and deficiency of services at MAX which they call a complication after C-section leaving behind a 2 day old baby.

    We got hold of Case sheet from the hosptal after the police complaint which clearly shows that she was complaining pain right from 10 pm on 4th and was given different pain killer and sedatives one after the another without diagnosing the problem...

    By morning, she was critical. The killers declared her clinically dead at 12.30 pm. If this is the kind of treatment and diagnosis they do to the in-patients in their custody, they have no right to EXIST.

    To add on, they say " We are as perplexed as you are about the cause of the death" COMLETELY UNACCEPTABLE

    Child birth is not a disease of which a precious life with no medical history or abnormality would be lost.

    Need support and advice for fighting this with MAX.

    I can be contacted at [email protected]

    0 Votes

Post your comment

    By clicking Submit you are agreeing to the Complaints Board’s Terms and Conditions


    Unhappy consumers gather online at and have already logged thousands of complaints.
    If you see dozens of complaints about a certain company on ComplaintsBoard, walk away.
    One of the largest consumer sites online. Posting here your concerns means good exposure for your issues.
    A consumer site aimed at exposing unethical companies and business practices.
    ComplaintsBoard is a good source for product and company gripes from especially dissatisfied people.
    You'll definitely get some directions on how customer service can best solve your problem.
    Do a little research on the seller. Visit consumer complaint websites like ComplaintsBoard.