Bay Fuel Oil Company Homeowners And Businesses Reviews and Complaints

Latest Reviews and Complaints

R. Kemmer

Verified customer

I'm a customer of Bay Fuel Oil Company

I'm a customer of Bay Fuel Oil Company. I called them on 09/15 to order oil and asked them to use my remaining heap payment of *** for the delivery. But they put more oil in my tank and charged me *** dollars extra. *** told me this is not allowed. This company has a reputation for doing shady things, like adding extra surcharges on credit cards and having to return them to customers through the attorney general.

Read full complaint

Hide full review

How responsive is Bay Fuel Oil Company's customer service?

0 Resolved

1 Unresolved

Total complaints: 1

Resolved complaints: 0 (0%)

Unresolved complaints: 1 (100%)

Sort by:

Looks like Bay Fuel Oil Company has no reviews or complaints yet, which is great!

However, if you have something to share with the others, you can write a complaint or review

Write a review Leave a complaint

Subscribe to receive notifications of all new customer feedback

Bay Fuel Oil Company has received 1 complaints on ComplaintsBoard. The first reported case, I'm a customer of Bay Fuel Oil Company, was published on Jun 18, 2023, and the most recent complaint, I'm a customer of Bay Fuel Oil Company, was posted on Jun 18, 2023.

Out of all reported cases, 0 complaints (0%) have been marked as resolved, while 1 complaints (100%) remain unresolved.

Customer feedback spans multiple years and reflects a range of user experiences. A majority of complaints remain unresolved, which may be important to consider when evaluating the company.

👉 Submit a complaint about Bay Fuel Oil Company

Is Bay Fuel Oil Company Legit?

Bay Fuel Oil Company earns a trustworthiness rating of 91%

Highly recommended, but caution will not hurt.

Our conclusion: After a detailed review, ComplaintsBoard finds Bay Fuel Oil Company to be a trustworthy company. Although there's a 0% resolution rate for customer complaints, which deserves attention, Bay Fuel Oil Company is known for their high standards and safety. If you're thinking about dealing with Bay Fuel Oil Company, it's wise to check how they handle complaints.

Bayfueloil.com has a valid SSL certificate, which indicates that the website is secure and trustworthy. Look for the padlock icon in the browser and the "https" prefix in the URL to confirm that the website is using SSL.

Bayfueloil.com has been deemed safe to visit, as it is protected by a cloud-based cybersecurity solution that uses the Domain Name System (DNS) to help protect networks from online threats.

However ComplaintsBoard has detected that:

The website belonging to Bay Fuel Oil Company has a low number of visitors, which could be a red flag for users. However, it's important to conduct additional research to fully evaluate the website's legitimacy and trustworthiness.

Collect Your Trust Badge

Be recognized for outstanding customer service

Bay Fuel Oil Company Contacts

Bay Fuel Oil Company phone numbers

+1 (631) 475-1459

Click up if you have successfully reached Bay Fuel Oil Company by calling +1 (631) 475-1459 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached Bay Fuel Oil Company by calling +1 (631) 475-1459 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached Bay Fuel Oil Company by calling +1 (631) 475-1459 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached Bay Fuel Oil Company by calling +1 (631) 475-1459 phone number

Bay Fuel Oil Company address

224 Long Island Avenue, Holtsville, New York, 11742-1815, United States

Bay Fuel Oil Company social media

It looks like we haven't found Bay Fuel Oil Company's social media accounts :(
Checked and verified by Laura This contact information is personally checked and verified by the ComplaintsBoard representative. Learn more

Sep 13, 2026