1stdibs.com review: Pair of earrings that claimed to be authenticity but wasn't
In April 2026 I bought/received a pair of Tiffany & Co. Earrings. 1837 T and CO Hoops Sterling Silver 925 Earrings. I bought that through the 1stDIBS which was from a third party known as VOX MARKET. In Oct 2026 I was cleaning the earrings and the silver rubbed off and there was brass underneath the silver. That is not Sterling Silver. I contacted 1stDIBS and they told me since it was passed the 7 days to return the earring, no refunds is allowed. They also told me to have Tiffany to verify that it is not real sterling silver. To which they do not do verification of items not sold directly from them. I send pictures of the earrings but 1stDIBS said that they can't say if it is brass under the rubbed off silver.
Since 1stDIBS does not want to resolve this problem, I will go the the third party where all I got was a cardboard card "CERTIFICATE OF AUTHENTICITY Vox Market Expert Authenticators have examined this item. It is authenticity has been confirmed and guaranteed, or your money back."
With the silver rubbed off, it looks like silver coded over brass. 1tsDIBS thinks that was all that was needed to say it was authentic and sold as is without testing from the "experts" I had to make an account to the BBB just to put in a review first before I have to put in a complaint. Which I did both but the response from 1stDIBS made it sound like the problem was solved. Then the BBB sent me an email also claiming the problem was solved. It was still not solved.
Desired outcome: A refund would be good to get. Credited to my charge card.
Confidential Information Hidden: This section contains confidential information visible to verified 1stdibs.com representatives only. If you are affiliated with 1stdibs.com, please claim your business to access these details.
0 comments