Menu
First Chicago Insurance Customer Service Phone, Email, Contacts

First Chicago Insurance
reviews and complaints

First Chicago Insurance's customer service contact info has been verified by the ComplaintsBoard team. We made sure it's all legit and accurate, so you can trust it! 👌
www.firstchicagoinsurance.com
www.firstchicagoinsurance.com

Learn how the rating is calculated

2.9 28 Reviews 14 Complaints
Claim Your Business
Take control of your profile: address complaints and engage with reviews
Write a review File a complaint

First Chicago Insurance reviews 28

ComplaintsBoard
E
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance I was involved in an accident that was clearly a person who was insured by this insurance company's fault

I was involved in an accident that was clearly a person who was insured by this insurance company's fault. The person ran a stop sign and ran into the side of my vehicle after I had already passed the street. First Chicago concluded that I could have avoided the accident and agreed to only pay for 80% of the repair costs. The person who hit my even received a citation from the Lynwood Police. This was clearly a case where an insurance company was trying to get out of its obligation to pay for all of the repairs for my vehicle I ended up having to go through my own insurance company, and paying a $500 dollar deductible. I expect to get my deductible back from First Chicago, and if not will definitely take them to small claims court. This insurance company is trying to lowball individuals and does not live up to their obligations.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 2 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
2 comments
Add a comment
R
R
R. Padberg
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I filed a claim on May 31, 2022 and got hardly no response from anybody without having to call aggressively wasting a whole hour of my lunchtime every day for a week. Just to hear from someone that Im going we said they will call me back on Friday, June 10 and never did. A pay my insurance on time have full coverage and filled out the witness report yet sent me. Very frustrating and difficult and disrespectful to be treated this way. Its almost like a joke or slap in the face. Because nobody seems to want to help. They just answer the call and forward you to a voicemail that nobodys going to respond to. Getting this insurance was the worst decision that Ive ever made in my life. *** is hideous and they just dont care. No human being deserves to be treated this way.

J
J
J. Leuschke
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I filed a claim after giving me complaint number I tried calling them on given numbers but nobody picks up left several voice messages got a call back somehow from an agent the agent took statement about the accident and location where the car is for appraisal I also gave that over the phone only two days ago I received a letter from them asking for same details and gave me the same numbers which no one picks up. No where in the world will you find an insurance company like this. My car is seriously damaged it was a major crash I am also under treatment why the state of *** allow such companies to operate business which are playing with consumers in a serious manner any insurance company with no agent on phone anytime of the day is a scam state of *** has a responsibility also to stop such companies to operate

ComplaintsBoard
K
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance I was hit by one of their policy holders while parked in a parking lot

I was hit by one of their policy holders while parked in a parking lot. The adjuster never calls back. Their phone system takes 10 minutes to get to a person and then they throw you on hold and never get to the person you want except for after multiple attempts. They are still dragging their feet on paying to have my truck repaired which is a 2020 ***. They cant seem to get the policy holder to give her recorded statement because the other statement is apparently not good enough. During this whole time my truck is damaged. The supervisor I was finally able to reach says well you can send it through to your insurance and they can come after us. So then I risk my rates jumping and who knows how long it will take to get my deductible back. I dont know many people who have an extra $500 lying around to maybe get it back because the insurance company wants to drag their feet.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 3 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
3 comments
Add a comment
T
T
T. Huels
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

One of their insured drivers rear ended my vehicle and was ticketed as a result and police report was on file. In ***, if you rear ended someone you are automatically at fault. This insurance company DENIED the claim because the insured driver (responsible for rear ending me) was not cooperating. This is unheard of. Thank goodness I can take this to the *** insurance Commission.

J
J
J. Kunde
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

This is without a doubt the worst insurance company there is. It's what's called a "Bad Faith Insurance Company". Was rear ended by their client 4 months ago and they are still dragging the claim out. They WON'T return calls and If they do there is always some sham of an excuse. In the mean time your driving a damaged vehicle. Your best bet is to file a complaint with the *** of Insurance.

M
M
M. Morissette
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

If you get your car hit by one of their customers they will not pay. I recently got hit by their customer and they have yet to pay me. I even went to the body shop they told me to go to and they still did not pay. I have called and complained and have yet to get any results. I have accepted that I will have to take this lost. First time this has happened to me with a insurance company.

ComplaintsBoard
C
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance My car was stolen in ***, the police recovered my car in ***

My car was stolen in ***, the police recovered my car in ***. I paid $350 to get my car released from the impound. The car was not drivable because the thieves had messed up the internal power functions of the car with the device which they used to gain entry and start the car. This insurance company offered to take my car to another storage facility while they investigated my claim. The adjuster in charge never returned my calls. I finally got a call back today to inform me that my claimed was denied because they have a clause that if your car was not forcibly broken into they would not cover your claim. I just found out that the facility that they took my car to wants me to pay almost $400 for the release. I would advise people to steer clear of this insurance company, they are scammers. I don't know why the government is allowing a company like this to scam people.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 3 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
3 comments
Add a comment
P
P
P. Padberg
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

So far the worst company in the market. It's been almost a month since the accident and I haven't received a resolution. I had an accident on Dec 12th 2021, called in the company Dec 13th and so far the car still sitting at the shop, nothing has been done to the car. I haven't been able to work because the car on the policy is my work vehicle. At this point I still do not know if the car will be repaired or not. Very sad because we pay for a full coverage policy yet at the time of claim no one in this company seems to care. I call almost everyday for updates and not getting anything. help! If it helps I can pull all the calls I've made from my cell phone *** as proof.

E
E
E. Blick
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

The worst company dont respond or ever call back dont use them you get what you pay for

Y
Y
Y. Jacobson
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

Beyond Horrible! I was in a car wreck with one of there insured. They gave me h*** Took me 3 months to get my car fixed. They make you pay for your own rental car then they will reimburse you. They send adjustors out to your house instead of taking a quote from a dealership. *** is awful. They never return calls. Even left messages on the supervisors line.

ComplaintsBoard
G
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance They are a joke!

They are a joke! They send out cancellation letters almost immediately after you pay, for the next month like its due tomorrow. Failed to send proof of insurance a couple of times to the *** which resulted in my license being suspended. The police pulled me over for it almost got arrested & car towed with my child in the car one of the times. I logged in showing the officer I was current and had to park my vehicle to wait for couple hours until We got picked up from family. I worked a lot so that was a mommy & daughter day ruined. My daughter still talks about it almost 2 years later. It was current both times I was pulled over. When I called to complain I was told she couldnt help me until I paid my ***, that wasnt due for 10 days and she hung up. They act like they are top dollar insurance when in fact their as valuable as merchandise in ***. I have no idea how they can call themselves a company! Sketchy and definitely dont put their customers first!

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 3 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
3 comments
Add a comment
U
U
U. Gorczany
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

This place is not legit and scams people out of money they are owed.

E
E
E. Hane
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I was in an accident with a person who is insured by this company on 12/13 it is now 12/29 and no one at this company has responded to any of my calls. Every phone number that I call goes straight to voicemail I even sent on hold for their main phone line for hour and 15 minutes before the call was just hung up with no one answering the call. My car is damaged I'm injured and this company will not respond to any means of communication. I have repeatedly called the claims adjuster who's supposedly assigned to this claim and have never spoke to her in almost 2 weeks. No one has called to take a statement or to find out if I'm okay or giving me instructions on anything to do with my car. My next step will be to file a complaint with the insurance authority that governs this company.

D
D
D. West
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

This insurance company is by far the worst company that Ive every dealt with. I was in a car accident in October and here we are in January 2022 and I am still waiting on information about my car. I call and never receive a answer. Ive been hung up on and my adjuster *** is terrible . I never receive any call backs . I wouldnt recommend this company to anyone. Save yourself the time and hassle. Pay a few extra dollars and get a real insurance company because this one isnt it.

ComplaintsBoard
B
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance This company is the worst one of their customers hit my car on July 31 and still no help

This company is the worst one of their customers hit my car on July 31 and still no help. We have their client license, insurance information, and the paint from Jannatul Jesy car all over the right back of my car. The claim specialist called one time and said she needed to know exactly what happened. I called *** right back and 5 other times left voicemails and no call back. Only a call back once I reach out to her mgr which never returned my call. In the mean while sent a letter pretty much saying call my insurance company to cover the damage since she doesnt know what happen and this is the person that doesnt return phone calls to find out what happen. This a scheming company to get insurers money and never pay out claims. The next step I guess is to get a attorney involved and especially to get my son doctors bills covered since his wrist has been hurting since the accident and this may effect his baseball college chances! Thanks for nothing

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
D
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance I would give half a star, but cant

I would give half a star, but cant. Horrible customer service and horrible ongoing experience. It has now been 4 weeks and almost nothing has been done. I was told last Tuesday (9/6) that a decision if the car is a total loss would be made and payment would be made in "A day or 2". It has been a week and have heard nothing from anyone. I was told 3 different times in the last 4 weeks that the car would be removed from the tow company lot it has been sitting at since the day of the accident (4 weeks) and it is still there. Nobody ever calls me back, never e-mail me back. Anytime i call i can do nothing but leave messages which does no good because i never get a return call. If i am lucky to get a live person, they just send me to another department where nobody answers and i have to leave another voicemail which NEVER gets returned. No communication at all. Total garbage customer service. i spoke with the adjuster 1 time- 3 weeks ago and cannot get a hold of him or get any information ever since. All i have ever asked for is some information !

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
C
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance I was hit 2 months ago, the lady that hit me did not want me to file it on her insurance as she had had so many accidents she was afraid they

I was hit 2 months ago, the lady that hit me did not want me to file it on her insurance as she had had so many accidents she was afraid they would cancel her. She stated she would pay me cash after i got a quote from a repair shop. When we set a meeting to exchange the money, she never showed and has not answered any phone calls since forcing me to file a claim. I have a police report clearly stating faut, I emailed the copy given to me by the officer on the scene but the company told me this wasnt an "offical" report so they would not accept it, then they stated they were unable to get the offical report from the PD after it was requested, i will get a copy and send to them but they informed me after they recieve it, It really doesn't matter whose fault the report states it is, if they are unable to get a statement from their insured party within 10 days they would be forced to deny the claim. I cannot wrap my mind around the fact that if the police report clearly states fault all a person has to do is not answer their phone for 10 days and they get out of paying. This is absoluty outrageous!

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
T
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance UN RUN RUN!

UN RUN RUN! If I could give them a 0 star I would. I made the mistake of using this cut rate insurance. I was fully covered and a semi truck hit ME! It was the truck drivers fault. 1st when I called to report the accident not one time did they ask if I was alright or care at all. They are rude and so unprofessional when you call. I called 3 time before I finally got someone to not hang up on me because it was almost closing time and they didn't want to deal with it. I stayed on hold for 38 mins before someone answered. When the claim adjustor *** called he was just as rude and did not offer me any information. I asked where do I get a rental car from and he said you get 30 dollars a day, you pay and we pay you back. It had now been 7 weeks later and he will not return my call to reimburse me for the rental. My car was totaled and they have to send the check to my car loan and they still have not done it. I had to call they 6 times before they finally gave me the certificate of compliance so showing that I had insurance to the *** I cant imagine if it was my fault how you would be treated. I have since dropped them and went to state farm. THEY ONLY WANT YOUR MONEY. I will file a complaint with the Complaintsboard.com if I do not get this handled in full by the end of the week.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
A
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance On May 9th, one of this companys insurees supposedly had their vehicle stolen

On May 9th, one of this companys insurees supposedly had their vehicle stolen. Her vehicle (and the supposed thief) then hit me and left the scene. I was able to find out the owner of the vehicle as the bumper fell off in the road and a Good Samaritan picked it up and brought it to me while we waiting for low enforcement. I reported the hit and run to First Chicago, on May 10th, immediately after reporting it to my own insurance. First Chicago stated they didnt even have a claim from their insuree but would look into it. I never heard back. My insurance provider has attempted to contact first Chicago multiple times to find out a claim number and have been told we are so short staffed claims are very delayed in being created. On July 14th, my rep was told she would hear back in 1-3 business days but no calls have been returned. I called and left a voicemail to which was never returned. I called yesterday and was placed on a 30 minute hold and then hung up on. At this point, first Chicago has had the worst customer service Ive ever seen in my life. The insuree they insure. Has lost her license more times than anyone should have a chance, was caught driving with a suspended license exactly one week after her car was supposedly stolen while left running. Great work keeping other motorists safe! The lack of care, customer service, and work ethic in this company is atrocious.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
E
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

First Chicago Insurance This company does not pay claims

This company does not pay claims. It will look at any possible way to get out of paying a claim. I am a insirance broker that sales 1st Chicago and have had 3 claims in a row not paid out due to minor issues that the good companies i sale would not have a issue with. Client #1 was denied because he was in accident on a bad weather night and didn't get out to look at damage to his vehicle until next day. Since no police report was filed. denied Client #2 was denied because they stated that she didn't provide accurate information on her application. There was a accident a few years prior she didn't tell agent about. This company does a clue report before providing insurance so it was basically the were taking payments from this lady until something happened and they come back with a excuse not to cover it. Client #3 The Client come in and paid what the program stated she needed to to get poliy reactivated. She then had a accident a few weeks later and they denied it because they stated it didn't completely catch her up. She was 29.00 short. SO she was canceled after making a 400 payment for 29.00. These all occurred in jan-feb 2021. We have stopped placing clients with this company and looking to transfer Clients to other companies that are with they at this time. Beware of this company. They are priced good however they do everything possible not to pay claims and if they do it usually a very lowball estimate.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
B
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance I started doing claims with a private car rental company and I will tell you it really looks awful when you're told one thing and turns out to

I started doing claims with a private car rental company and I will tell you it really looks awful when you're told one thing and turns out to be another. For example, their adjuster do notify the caller that they are out sick or just out of the office. They do not return emails with updates. The claims supervisor lied to me said he would help with any of my claims. I am sure the people are not bad. One adjuster told me that they are understaffed and overworked meaning they have seen 3x the number of cases than in previous years. This is unacceptable. Their turn around time is so horrible and communication is outrageously delayed. I can not believe this company works the way it does. The company I work for has invested over $100K into FCI in less than two years, and another supervisor said to me very rudely that we are not special. We have over 40 cars insured with them and yes we are not special but we are different type of client and need to be handled differently. I have to speak to 4-5 adjuster almost every day. I requested for our companies cases to be handled by one adjuster and I asked one of the adjusters and said that they would do it. When I wrote the Supervisor a letter requesting he denied our request. I am trying my best at my job but I feel like they make it harder by delaying the process and being treated like any other customer does not help. My boss has invested too much in there company. We need to move on.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
L
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance Unfortunately my husband was a victim of car theft but was thankfully not harmed

Unfortunately my husband was a victim of car theft but was thankfully not harmed. Having left his car in a gated driveway, his car was stolen. We imagine they had an antilock system/software or found his keys lying nearby as there was no 'evidence' of forcible entry and/or tampered with the gates when trespassing on private property. Doing the right thing, he called the police and his insurance company immediately upon realization and handed over the *** footage once he obtained this. First insurance DENIED this claim. First Chigaco admitted/agreed that the car was stolen, absolutely there was no speculation surrounding this- its on the *** footage. You can clearly see the thief robbing surrounding cars and then managing to enter his car (still unknown as to how). However, First Chicago decided that the car was not stolen 'aggressively enough' to warrant a claim. We were sent a denial letter stating that they will only cover forcible entry of a stolen car, not just simply a stolen car. The car basically has to be stolen in an aggressive manner only, not just stolen...Now, you can only imagine the devastation this can cause to a human life. Not only did that car still have a balance owed (which the gap insurance would cover if First Chiago would pay out something- $100 even but of course they didn't), but my husband would not have to buy another car. A sudden shock of looming debt, inability to travel 'aggressively' changes the course of his next 5 years perhaps. Thank goodness the Lord himself witnessed your FOUL play and the car was recovered by CPD. Now, CPD did not notify my husband nor the insurance company that the car was found...yep the bad luck continues. A *** of 2K from the tow company, and some physical damage we thought to call Chicago First with the GREAT news to adjust/start a new claim to be DENIED again,There is more to this on trust pilot (word count here is limited)- but thats the jist of the nightmare.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
E
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance You're welcome these people they are not into it to help people at all, their automated system is very horrible and they're holding system is

You're welcome these people they are not into it to help people at all, their automated system is very horrible and they're holding system is even worse you will be on hold for 20 to 25 minutes and then when you do get a receptionist they may just hang up on you or be very rude and disrespectful to you. In my area they have no agents but they tell you to go talk to your agent where you signed up for your insurance All buildings are temporarily closed so there's no one to speak with. The agent that I signed up with and a few representatives at First Chicago informed me that you have a 5-day grace period from the day of your *** being due what they will not tell you is that if you cannot get through to them to pay your *** they will actually cut it off in that 5-day grace period does not exist now I'm in the position of being in an accident and label that's having a last insurance which will cause me a suspension. But on there in they won't cover you or anything of that nature. I called and called and called to figure out why this 5-day grace period isn't being honored and I always get the same excuse oh we're sorry we're sorry for the mishaps I've been a loyal customer for well over 3 years and get treated like ***. Do not trust this company they will take all day to pay your claim whether you're paying the $500 deductible with them or you are trying to receive from them as well from one of their customers or their carriers. Most places I go to even a car rental place does not trust this company because they do not report any incidents or anything of that nature to the *** so it doesn't help your case when you're trying to go to a different insurance company and get a quote to start off with a fresh relationship or a better relationship with a better insurance company I've got nothing but rudeness and disrespect from this company completely so I will not be remaining with them and I don't believe anyone else should because the adjusters themselves they will go days without answering the phone and then they will not call you back they will mail everything to you which is snail mail. I have yet to get a complete answer to why my 5 day grace period wasn't honored and the automated system even states I had until the 27th to make a payment or the policy would close "

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
A
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance replied to this review.

First Chicago Insurance First Chicago Insurance is not reimbursing me for the damages to my car caused by one of their clients!

First Chicago Insurance is not reimbursing me for the damages to my car caused by one of their clients! I had to follow-up with them leaving calls, voicemails, emails to the claim handler Jessica ***. NO HELP WHATSOEVER! I had to do all the Read My Full Story: Beginning from Christmas Eve, December 24, I was hit around 3:15 pm at the parking lot of Planet Fitness on 86th street. We were directed first Chicago insurance company, to file the claim with them and they will pay it. A day later we called and began to file the claim with them. After we filed the claim a man named Eduardo was supposedly handling our claim and gave us the claim number of #59648. He called us to talk to us about what happened on the day of the incident and recorded what we said for future references. Then on December 29,2019, we received a call from a man named Brett who was sent by Chicago insurance to come out that following Monday to look at the damages of the car. He took pictures of the car and sent them to the insurance company. Then on January 10 we called Chicago and we were directed to a woman named Valentina who told us the man originally handling our claim (Eduardo) is no longer working at the company; however, she told us that Jessica *** would be handing our claim from now on. Before we were handed over to Jessica she asked us to send any pictures we took from the accident with the date and time located somewhere on the picture. That was the last we heard from Valentina up until this past week. But from that day till now, Jessica has been slow on answering our emails and gave very little information about the update on our claim. She never made contact or gave updates to us unless we made contact with her. Eventually, after March, Jessica stopped responding to our emails so we started to call her in hope of receiving any update we can get. The on a phone call, Jessica then said that Darian has sent all documentation needed except one more document. This document is proof that she is part of a co-insurance. They needed this document since we filled in late December. We tried to make contact with Darian by sending her texts saying to please contact ur insurance and send in the last documentation so the claim can get processed. Darian said she'll be closely working with her insurance as I should with mine (Even though I am not filing the claim with my insurance, so my insurance has nothing to do with this) and this is last I heard from Darian before she blocked me from sending her any texts/calls. Through these six months especially from march through now where the last document was asked from her, Darian has not been picking up her calls or answering her emails from the insurance company. She has little to no contact with me when I text/call her, and eventually she blocked me from any contact towards the beginning of May. I texted her one last time on May 4th saying she has until May 15th to send in the document, and then I would file a police report. We contacted Jessica and told her about it and she said the last correspondence with Darian was May 5th. On that day Darian asked what document was needed from her (even though the insurance contacted her multiple times telling her about the specific document they need) Jessica said she sent her an email saying to send in the document of co-insurance and until this day she still has not sent it. Through these past 6 months the insurance company has been no help to me, the never answer my email, they purposely ignore me and never give me updates unless I make the contact. Darian has been REFUSING to send one last document either because she is afraid to show proof that she was (or still is) a permit driver at the time with no one driving with her, or the person she is sharing her insurance with is not cooperating and refusing to share the document with us. First Chicago Insurance is encouraging its clients to get away with hitting people's cars! I did my part and they failed to do theirs and now I have 1,500 in damages!

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer's satisfaction.

Hide full review

First Chicago Insurance complaints 14

ComplaintsBoard
D
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance Claim #**INA82405 I filed a claim for my 2010 Pontiac G6 being stolen on: 09/02**, I have had nothing but problems with First Chicago since,

Claim #INA82405 I filed a claim for my 2010 Pontiac G6 being stolen on: 09/02, I have had nothing but problems with First Chicago since, they kept telling me they were mailing paperwork and I never received it. Then I told them to email it to me and I got more excuses. Once I got it to a body shop, they advised the Converter was stolen, which caused damage to the Manifold along with some other issues caused by the theft; The body shop advised me that due to my vehicle/Pontiac is no longer being made, the parts would have to be aftermarket as the parts that need replacing cannot be replaced with used parts as it isn't safe to use; I certainly didn't expect them to use OEM parts on a 2010, if they were even available, that wouldn't make sense. The body shop stated the total cost of the repairs is $23.75, First Chicago sent them a check for $989.69 and advised them and me that I have to pay $1139.16-$500 Deductible I am also responsible for $639.16. I was told by the claim adjuster handling my claim that I have to pay this due to them not covering new parts. I told her it's not my fault that my car was stolen and damaged, she stated you are driving a 2010 Pontiac, they don't even make that car anymore, why would we put brand new parts on it. The body shop even advised them that it's not safe to put used parts and that the owner shouldn't be responsible to pay for the parts and the claim adjuster told them that's just the way we do it; There is now way I should be responsible for the damages to my vehicle and I had full coverage, I should only be responsible for my deductible; The body shop hasn't even started on my vehicle as they are also trying to figure out why I have to pay this and why the insurance didn't send enough to cover the cost of repairs minus my deductible. I want the insurance to pay the full amount minus my deductible and cover the repairs to my vehicle, as it is only right.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 4 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
4 comments
Add a comment
F
F
F. Bartoletti
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I have full coverage through first chicago insurance Policy # ***-00 I was in an auto accident on 10-29-22 I made a claim on 10-30-22 Not once has this company called me about my claim. I have made every phone call to them. Im going on over a month with no communication on their part. My last update they said its in total loss waiting to be approved.I dontnknow how long this process usually takes but I have been without a car since oct. 29th I would like to be paid out on my car immediately.

W
W
w. smith
Pleasant Grove, US

Claim #TXM77848 A client of First Chicago Insurance Company hit my truck while it was parked. The guy tried to leave the scene but his car was entangled with my truck. We called the police and made a crash report on November 17, 20. I made a claim on that same day to First Chicago Insurance Company. They told me an adjuster would contact me. I haven't heard from anyone at all. I've called countless times and left countless voice messages and no one has returned my calls. I've been without a vehicle all this time, it seems like I'm intentionally being ignored. My property damage needs to be fixed ASAP.

D
D
D. Sporer
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I was involved in an auto accident with someone insured by this company on Nov. 21st, 2022. After waiting to collect the insured's information I immediately filed a claim and was told I would be contacted by an adjuster within *** hours. It has now been a week since the 48 hour *** ended and have had no contact with my adjuster. I have called daily and left messages to my adjuster as well as her supervisor and have not received any response from the insurance. They owe money for the tow, for my vehicle being fixed, for the rental I am having to use, medical expenses, my time I've spent calling and leaving messages every day, and now an attorney.

E
E
E. Green
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

This is about the insurance claim #*** with First Chicago Insurance.The company is not possible to be reached. Their number is always busy.*** that figures as *** receives phone messages at ***, yet has been non-responsive for a month now.

ComplaintsBoard
A
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance Some guy plowed into the right back side of my car on 12/26

Some guy plowed into the right back side of my car on 12/26. The at-fault driver is insured by First Chicago Insurance. They contacted me at the end of January and sent someone out from third-party appraiser for the supplement within a few days, but we could not get into a body shop until 4/11. Insurance company told me they would cover a rental starting when my car entered the shop. On 4/13 the body shop submitted a supplement to the third party claims website (as instructed - they use the company SCA). On 4/21 - I emailed the contact at First Chicago (***) because no update 4/22 - she calls acknowledging claim and says shell push through management review by EOD 4/25 - still hearing nothing I email again for an update. Shes out of office until 5/2 Meanwhile body shop guy gets ahold of someone different they go back and forth on claim and as of 5/13 were still fighting on a remaining $2k. So I email again and ask why they cant send a physical person to look at car and talk to to body shop. Which at that point they did. Came to an agreement last week and got that approved. It has been 5 days since they approved and body shop still doesn't have the final money. Nor has he been able to order the parts because he can't until it's approved. I tried to do the right thing and turned the rental car in on 5/13 because I was on vacation for a week. Now that Im back and the car isnt done, I need another one. But theyre trying to claim theyre only covering 16 days of a rental car because thats the reasonable estimate to fix. And the lady is trying to claim the second supplement was submitted last week when I have emails in April where she acknowledged the second supplement. The fact that the car sat for 3 extra weeks is their negligence. The initial 30 day rental was $900 and they claimed they will only cover ~$400. The body shop can not give me a remaining estimate of time to fix until the final supplement clears.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 3 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
3 comments
Add a comment
J
J
J. Waelchi
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I purchased my car and insurance on Sept 26, 2022. I had the accident on September 27,2022. I have not ever given a quote to repair my 2022 *** Spark. I've called *** times within the last 3 months. No one calls or responses to the voicemails as promised. Spoke to manager and giving the runaround. I will be 3 months as of December 28, 2022. I regrated I bought this insurance. DO NOT PURCHSE this insurance with these SCAMMERS. I've even have gone to office and was not let in. A security guard toke the message to the organization. A few minutes later, a manger called and said they are waiting for police to confirm date. WHAT! They have the accident report with ALL the information it. I have feels like I will NEVER get a quote. I even got the brokers involved! I'm disgusted and horrified with service. One star. They deserve a ZERO rating. SCAMMERS. I will never drive my car again. Thanks, FIRST CHICAGO. You are awful people First Chicago!

H
H
H. Boehm
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

The insured hit my vehicle on 02/24/2022. I contacted the insured insurance company. They sent me to ***, ***. My car damages was inspected. A quote was sent to First Chicago Insurance Company. First Chicago Insurance never reached out to me. I reached out to them a week later. They said the case was still processing. I called a week later they said they are waiting for the insured to add the driver to the insurance. I said thats not my problem that i needed my car damages fixed if the insured car is covered. They said there was nothing they could do until the driver was added.

K
K
K. Nader
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

My neighbor who is insured with this company First Chicago Insurance hit my car while my car was parked on 11/01/2022 a police report was made i have made many attempts to contact the insurance agent on 11/09/22 called 3 times i was told the insurance adjustor Name was *** and was transferred to her extention left message no return call so on 11/10/22 i finally spoke with *** she gave me an address to take my vehicle to get an estimate on the damage at the location ***. ( Lans-city auto rebuilders) and since 11/10/2022 *** have not contacted me as far as when i will get my car fixed each time i call im sent to voicemail told to leave a message she will return a call the next day, i spoke with *** on like 3 occasions 1 i was told my estimate werent approved (11/15/2022) called back 11/28/2022 and was told they will contact me when i was approved and if i didnt like how they handle the situtation go thru my insurance and my insurance will collect from them. honestly i dont feel its right its not my fault the young lady hit my car parked and i dont feel i need to pay a $500 deductible just for my car to be repaired

ComplaintsBoard
C
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance My daughter was involved in an accident in 9/19/22, as their insured party crossed the double yellow line and stopped abruptly in front of

My daughter was involved in an accident in 9/19/22, as their insured party crossed the double yellow line and stopped abruptly in front of daughter. She then had to slam on he brakes which then made her run into the back of the First Chicago insured party. Police was called and a report was giving and the First Chicago insured party was issued a ticket due has he was at fault. I have filed an injury claim as well. We contacted First Chicago on/around 9/21 related to this issue to get the process rolling of filing on their behalf. The 1st statement she asked was, "Oh, he/we thought you were going to file on your insurance". I told her why would file on our behalf on our insurance when we did not cause the accident/damaged. She took some information and stated, an appraiser will be assigned as well as an injury adjustor.On 9/30, I received a text message from ***, that I could track the process and obtain the appraiser information. On 10/2, I was contacted my the appraiser and on 10/3 he came out and appraised her vehicle. He stated the car is totaled and he is going to send his information to the insurance company and they will follow-up with me. I hadn't heard from the insurance company, as I keep calling multiple times and leaving messages. On 10/11, I left a message on the appraiser voicemail and he respond that he has sent First Chicago a message. I kept calling to obtain a follow-up on the report and someone finally answers...the same person every time. She then goes and states, "there is something wrong with the police report and someone should be contacting you on Monday". I know for a fact there's nothing wrong with the police report. At this point, I feel they don't want to pay for the damages. As of today, 11/28 when you call the claim line, it states the number you dialed is not in service at this time. This insurance company is not responding to calls or claim, as I am trying to get my daughter's car taken care of.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 3 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
3 comments
Add a comment
A
A
A. Zulauf
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

My car was stolen, police found it and it was towed to a *** city ***. The car is considered total loss. I sent all of the documentation to First Chicago Insurance. The person assigned to my case is ***. I recently found out the tow lot still has the car and they are auctioning off due to insurance company not being picked up. I already signed the vehicle over to First Chicago. I have not made pavements since I signed the car over to the insurance company. The vehicle has a lein with *** had a very difficult time reaching *** and so did I. I canceled my policy with them since I no longer have the vehicle and I changed to Progressive because of poor communication. *** denied my claim due to non cooperation from me. I still owe $17k to Tidewater. First chicago is totally ripping me off. I paid for insurance for a reason. I don't understand how an insurance company can deny a claim that is a total loss. I can not afford to pay for a car that has been totaled. Thank you

M
M
M. Brown
, US

On 10/18/22 my car was used by a driver insured by First Chicago Insurance. He was involved in a wreck with another car. My insurance paid for the damage to the other vehicle. I contacted the driver of my cars insurance First Chicago Insurance and received a claim number. The claim was assigned to an adjuster who I have been calling since 10/25. I leave voicemails, but never get a call back. I also have the supervisors number and have called him with the same lack of results. The claim number is 22TXM77161. I have called 11 times with no response. I would like to speak with someone from First Chicago Insurance and have this claim processed under the laws and regulations regarding these types of insurance claims.

D
D
D. Brakus
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I was hit buy an insured of First Chicago insurance back in June 2022. I was parked and hit in the front of my car. They have given me the run arounds. I was promised a check would be mailed to me(THAT week)3 weeks ago. Now I am unable to reach someone. Who else do I contact about this because their Claims guy is very unprofessional and not very forthcoming about information. I dont understand what their problem is!

Is First Chicago Insurance legit?

Our conclusion: ComplaintsBoard’s research finds First Chicago Insurance trustworthy, but it’s still important to be cautious. If you are considering dealing with First Chicago Insurance, ensure you understand the risks involved before deciding.

First Chicago Insurance earns a trustworthiness rating of 57%

Think twice and be always careful when sharing sensitive information.

We found clear and detailed contact information for First Chicago Insurance. The company provides a physical address, phone number, and email, as well as social media account. This demonstrates a commitment to customer service and transparency, which is a positive sign for building trust with customers.

By resolving 92% of 14 negative reviews, First Chicago Insurance is demonstrating its dedication to customer satisfaction and effectively addressing customer issues. While there may still be some practical problems that need to be addressed, such as long wait times or unhelpful responses.

The age of First Chicago Insurance's domain suggests that they have had sufficient time to establish a reputation as a reliable source of information and services. This can provide reassurance to potential customers seeking quality products or services.

Firstchicagoinsurance.com has a valid SSL certificate, which indicates that the website is secure and trustworthy. Look for the padlock icon in the browser and the "https" prefix in the URL to confirm that the website is using SSL.

However ComplaintsBoard has detected that:

  • There was some difficulty in evaluating or examining the information or data present on the firstchicagoinsurance.com. This could be due to technical issues, limited access, or website may be temporarily down for maintenance or experiencing technical difficulties.
  • First Chicago Insurance protects their ownership data, a common and legal practice. However, from our perspective, this lack of transparency can impede trust and accountability, which are essential for establishing a credible and respected business entity.
  • We conducted a search on social media and found several negative reviews related to First Chicago Insurance. These reviews may indicate issues with the company's products, services, or customer support. It is important to thoroughly research the company and its offerings before making any purchases to avoid any potential risks.
ComplaintsBoard
C
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance The insuranfe company recovered my car

The insuranfe company recovered my car. I have waited 3 weeks for them to give me an estimate and send my car to the facility of my choice in order for my car to get fixed after it was stolen and damaged. They will not return any of my calls or even answer the phone. Then they leave me a voicemail that my quote is ready and to call them to tell them where i want my car sent to be fixed, but nobody will answer the phone. When they do pick up, I get transfered then hung up on. I have spent 900 dollars on a rental because they have took so long handling this issue, and wont even call me to update me on anything. They are only going to reimbirse me 420 of the 900 I have had to spend, and its not fair that they wont contact me and let me know whats going on because i just keep spending money on a rental to get back and forth to wotk and get my son to school, and noe U dont even have the money to pay my deductible when my car gets sent to the shop. Timothy Ferguson, the manager promised to call me back 2 weeks ago and still has not. My claims agent is Veronica Topez, and she wont return my calls either. My claim was filed on 8/12. I have never received a call from this woman, but once. She has never tried to reach out to me ever. I got one message from her saying to call her so shr can tell me the amount my claim was approved and where to send my car to get fixed. Ive keft this woman 2 messages since then, and she has never gotten back with me. Ive left her 3 messages before that, and she has never got back with me. Ive left 2 messages for timothy ferguson ,and no reply from him either. I feel taken advantage of. Ive been with them and paying on time for a long time, and they just dont care. They are really making me go broke anf ruining my life right now. I just want my car, and my reantal monry back. I turned in all my paperwork. They dont wait to take my money, so I dont know why Im now on week 4 of not getting any responses about my vehicle that I need.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance and 4 comments
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
4 comments
Add a comment
R
R
R. Kirlin
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

This company actually was paid to cover my car for insurance coverage and when my vehicle was hit they took it upon themselves to record my complaint very thoroughly to be treated like an outcast and to be refused coverage was told that the other insurance company would cover it and they did not and would like for this insurance company to give me a full refund of my money overall I do know that I was parked when I was hit by a driver that backed into me and my car is still in need of repair would like for this company to give me my money back due to them refusing to cover the damages and also I paid funds to this company which was an adjustment because I draw for Uber I would like a full refund of the amount that I paid to this company to cover my vehicle! If the company has information that they would like to receive they can reach me at the phone number or by email to discuss this account!

A
A
A. Bins
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

First of all, this insurance company has been the worst to deal with. Their insured rear-ended me and this has cost me the worst time ever. First they were unable to assist in letting me take my vehicle anywhere; I had to specifically take it to ONE body shop over 25 minutes away from my home but with a 1 HOUR window! First of all many people work between 3-4 PM. so did not work already. so i put claim through State Farm (my insurance) completed all work, So then i went after First chicago for diminished value because we were going to trade my vehicle in for a SUV but now they are offering me less because I have an accident on this vehicle. They dont want to give it to me because they state the accident wasnt that bad and no structural damage. WHAT!? I have been chasing them for my deductible back and still waiting for this. *** stated also that if i submit my declarations page they would up front the deductible. it has been over a week and still have not received response. I just want this resolved as this has put a financial strain on me. I just wish this never happened in the first place. I would just like monies back for my deductible and a compensation back for my diminished value of my car now that there is an accident on there from their insured.

H
H
H. Rath
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

My son was in a car accident with a driver insured by this company. My insurance company and I have been trying to reach a claim representative for a month. I have left messages with my claim number #*** and no one calls you back. You can all this company as soon as they open and the wait time are outrageous. You use the automated system to hold you place in line and non one call you back. My son has been without a call for over a month. You can some how get in touch with a sales agent but no other department from this company.

G
G
G. Skiles
,
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I'm was in car accident 11/10/2022 I'm pay my insurance on time every month im made a claim on 11/11/2022 and no one have call me on my claim they didn't wanna go pick my car up from pound and now they don't know who pick my car up. I'm have call and the phone going straight to voicemail no one reach out to me concerning my claim. I'm do believe I'm need to know something I'm been with First chicago insurance for 2 years first accident and they keep give me the run around. Claim number 22ilv99144

ComplaintsBoard
C
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance My vehicle was hit on 08/11/2022 (Thur) in front of my house by my neighbor (First Chicago policy holder)

My vehicle was hit on 08/11/2022 (Thur) in front of my house by my neighbor (First Chicago policy holder). It was recorded on my home security. On 08/12 (Fri) @ 7am, upon finding out about the accident, I filed the police report. The police were unable to find *** (neighbor) at that time. I was able to locate him later that night to obtain his insurance information. On 8/13 (Sat), I made the call to First Chicago and was given a reference number and told that someone would contact me immediately. On 08/15 (Mon), after 2 days with no contact from First Chicago, I called and spoke with *** at First Chicago. I informed her of the situation and emailed her the video of the hit and run. *** had given me the claim # of 22KSB95284.*** informed me that until the appraisal was completed they could not authorize a rental vehicle. She said that I could rent a vehicle from *** and that I would be reimbursed after the appraisal. On 8/16 (Tues), I received a text message from *** stating that they would be out to conduct the appraisal on my vehicle. The apprasial did not happen until 8/18 (Thursday at 10:45am). *** was the appraiser. She acknowledge that my vehicle was undriveable. She stated she would get all of the information submitted and I should hear back from First Chicago by the end of the day. Since my appraisal, I have left 5 messages for *** at First Chicago and emailed him with no return response. I have tried to call the First Chicago office number, but was unsuccessful in getting to a live person. On 08/20, I called *** Chicago's claim number from their website ***. A representative informed me that she was only an "after hours" claims person. She was very nice and checked my claim. Unfortunately, she could only make note of my call and send the information to the First Chicago office for help. I am getting the run around. I need help getting my car repaired.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
W
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

First Chicago Insurance We pay for full coverage on our 2016 Kia Sorento

We pay for full coverage on our 2016 Kia Sorento. On January 19th we had an accident where I got a deer. I do not have any accidents on my driving record. My wife and our 3yr old daughter were in the vehicle with me. I did not take pictures that night as it was a desolate country road/highway and it was dark. My two fears were that as easily as I got the deer someone could hit me on the side of the road taking pictures and that the quality would not render good or great due to it being pitch black. I would like to note immediately after impact the vehicle starting smoking and is not drive able then or at this time. I immediately called sheriff's department in that county (we were passing through as I was working in that area at the time). I was asked if we had any injuries by the deputy who answered my call. Aside from our daughter being shaken up, we had no injuries. The deputy said typically deer accidents are covered under comprehensive insurance and usually do not require a police report. If by chance we needed one to call back and let them know and they would file one. The next day I called and filed a claim and took the rest of the day off from work to go take pictures of the vehicle in daylight and get it towed to our home. Our agent got a definitive answer for us from the insurance company if the report was needed as the customer service reps could not tell us for certain (they stated photos, witnesses that do not know you, or a police report would help in making the decision on the claim). We called and got the report made and submitted it to the adjuster along with photos. The adjuster also came to our home to see the vehicle in person to assess damages. We never received nothing more than our insurance cards when getting insurance with First Chicago. They have now denied the claim sighting a text from policy stating we did not make the report within 24 hours. The policy wording they sighted does not state it that way nor in the surrounding wording.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
E
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance I filed claim # **iLV86762 on December 23, 20** with this company

I filed claim # iLV86762 on December 23, 20*** with this company. I attempted to follow up on my claim using the status claim check line, and no one would ever answer, and I was hung up on after waiting on the claim status line for several minutes once. Someone had picked up the line and hung up. I would leave voicemails after voicemails to get the status of my claim, and no one ever called me back. I had to go through the website and fill out a contact form to receive a call back. They called the main policy holders number to reach me claiming that they did not have my phone number even after I left messages with my phone number and claim number for reference. When the person called me after filling out the contact form asking for an supervisor to call me back, I was finally able to let someone know that my car was in a tow yard incurring charges of $150.00 per day. My car had been in the tow yard for *** I had even called the *** number on the website, and the woman said that the reason no one answered or got back to me was because they maybe had two people in the office. Someone finally reached out, and The woman took the info of where my car was located, and said that the adjuster was going to call the tow yard to work out payment to release my vehicle. Someone from their office named *** began texting me. She informed me that the storage fees came out to be over $7,000 which I was told by *** was excessive and that they wouldnt pay that much. I was told that if the charges had been $700-1500, my insurance would cover an amount in that range. She made me call the tow yard several times and speak to the owner to try and get him to lower the charges. She told me to pretend that I did not have insurance coverage so that I could pay the owner. Now Im told that I have to pay $1500 in excessive fees to get my car out of another tow yard. I was also told that I owe money for having a co-owner, but my car is paid off.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
B
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance I had my car accident on June 14

I had my car accident on June 14. I filed my claim on June 15th. The adjuster went to look at my car a week later. After 4 days, I called to get an update since the person over my claim never contacted me. I was told theyre waiting for the adjuster to attach the estimate, which was already attached. I was told it takes 3-5 days after the estimate is attached for someone to contact me. On Monday, I called and left a voicemail. No call back. Tuesday my brother called and was able to get in contact with the person over my claim. Later that day, *** finally called me. I was told that shes waiting for the police report before my claim can be approved. She asked me if I could provide the police report. The next day, I contacted the Police station and they said the report was uploaded days ago. I emailed her informing her that my car needs to be off the streets soon because it was residential parking. I also asked if I could just have it towed to the shop and send in the receipt. It was two different shops, 1 for underbody and the other was body work. Later the same day, *** calls me and said they finally received the report and that its hard to split the payment for two different shops. She said they have a shop for the car to be towed to. She said it wouldnt be in the shop that long because its not that much they have to do. This was on June 28th. June 30th, I contacted her because my car was still on the street and I didnt receive the email. I kept calling and couldnt get in contact with her. I called again on July 5th and she asked me was my car towed yet and Im thinking she should already know that. She said its probably because of the holiday. She will contact them and call me back. I never received a called back. Its July 9th and I still havent heard from her or the company. I had to arrange the tow myself to a shop on July 8th and pay out of pocket. This is ridiculous and highly unprofessional. Whats the point of full coverage?!

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
A
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance On June 3 or June 5 the rem exact date a client of first Chicago insurance hit me and my car in a parking lot I was out of the car when he hit

On June 3 or June 5 the rem exact date a client of first Chicago insurance hit me and my car in a parking lot I was out of the car when he hit me and my car I was parked so of course my insurance company Allstate you know they were on top of all the problems got me in to get an estimate for the body shop first of all they are the party that hit me we both went to the police station followed you know reports so a week and a half before my car was going into the shop I was trying to seek loss of wages first of all from my insurance company Allstate they say we dont do that we would have to see it from the other insurance company so I tried calling the other insurance company started on Tuesday, July 5 since money was July 4 I figured Id be close I was on hold from July 5 to July 8 I believe which is a Friday I called them and called them and called them was on hold for a total of 6 1/half hours throughout those all those days never answer the phone so I am driving to their actual business which they would even allow me to go into the office they have a security guard and a buzzer at the front main door so they sent for somebody upstairs to come down I met with the *** lack *** is the correct spelling of her last name she came down and says you know most likely Im not gonna get the loss of wages that they will fight me in court for that right off the bat she was very defensive against me pretty much asking any questions about money she says yeah once the insurance once my insurance gets a hold of them for the The deductible of $500 that they will you know submit that my insurance company cant get a hold of them either I keep trying to call this *** lady who gave me her direct line to her office she said shell call me back as soon as you know she gets the message Ive called her four times now still no callbacks I feel theyre gonna try to email not answer their calls so they dont have to pay out money because my insurance cover cant get a hold

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
J
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance On June 9, 2022 my vehicle was rear ended by a taxi driver who is insured by First Chicago Insurance Company

On June 9, 2022 my vehicle was rear ended by a taxi driver who is insured by First Chicago Insurance Company. I called 911 and was instructed since both cars were still drivable and there were no injuries, to simply exchange information with the driver of the taxi and to report the accident to the nearest police station. We did as the 911 operator instructed us to so. I drove to the nearest *** station and reported the accident. I filed a claim with First Chicago and also contacted them via phone on June 15, 2022. I spoke with *** who filed for me to go get a quote on the repair to my vehicle. I proceeded to go get the quote for the repair on June 17. Following the quote by the body shop recommended by First Chicago, I did receive a letter dated June 24, 2022, confirming that First Chicago had received a report indicating that a vehicle owned or operated my me was involved in a captioned loss. The letter also stated that First Chicago needed to consult with their insured in order to confirm coverage and determine liability. After not hearing from First Chicago for several weeks, I began calling them to inquire as to the status of my claim. My first call following the letter was on 7/13/2022. I did speak on that call with ***. She informed me that they were having difficulty getting a hold of their insured who worked for the taxi cab company. I continued to call First Chicago five more times in order to have them pay for this claim that they are liable for. In early October they sent me a check for 70% of the liability stating that they have accepted 70% liability for the loss. Their insured ran into the back of me so I don't know how they are only responsible for 70%. They also stated they have video claiming to show the accident but they have not shown it to me. In a phone call with me they described the actions of my car in the video. It was grossly incorrect and did not match the details of the accident. I am confident it is an incorrect video.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
I
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance Beware, I contacted First Chicago to seek information on what I need to do to file a claim as I had just been rear-ended in a parking lot and

Beware!, I contacted First Chicago to seek information on what I need to do to file a claim as I had just been rear-ended in a parking lot and the person who hit me had agreed to repair the scratches so I did not file a police report due to it was just minor scratches, but then later blocked my phone number and disappeared. I was told by the *** or the *** that I would need to first file a police report which I never did because it would not be worth all the time and energy for something would cost probably a little over $300. Fast forward, time to renew insurance as it ended in July and I decided that I was not going to pay the amount for that company as it to me is not a major insurance comp so I decided to pursue others and in doing so I was shocked to find out that I have a no fault accident on my report so my premium was almost doubled, I was told to try and contact First Chicago to see about amending this as I never received any form or retribution for this claim, I called, 1st was told by the claims *** that they could not omit it and that it was closed due lack of information on my behalf and that it should not be affecting my rates, Yes it is! and then told that I should talk to underwriting *** who had already told me to talk to them, then told to contact Insurance King to see if they can help! WHY! I'm talking to claims now for a claim that was never opened but told just due to the phone call it generated a claim? Well how when I never had the police report that I need to move forward? Ok at this point can you send me some info on the claim a letter that I can present showing that it was closed and not pursued? No we don't have letters of that nature? What well I don't even have a claim #, the adjustors name the incident report I literally have nothing to show this ever existed. Transfers me to the adjustor guess what? VM Even when you pass you get something in writing its called a death certificate wonder who got the money I didnt!

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
T
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance Accident date 4/24/22 *** report filed 4/24/22 On 4/24 , First Chicago insured driver backed up at a red light and struck my vehicle

Accident date 4/24/22 *** report filed 4/24/22 On 4/24 , First Chicago insured driver backed up at a red light and struck my vehicle causing minor damage. Insured driver left the scene when light changed to green. I immediately filed a police report. I was able to get insureds licensed plate . Officer who took report stated they would contact other driver. Do to First Chicago insured driver leaving the scene there was a delay in the report getting done and the claim being filed. II filed a claim with First Chicago as soon as I received the insureds insurance information. I was advised that an adjuster would contact me within 3-5 business days-I never received any call from adjuster. I called into First Chicago multiple times and was eventually given the adjusters name and extension. I left her messages directly. On 6/2 I was connected to the adjuster Moniques superviser *** as I still had not been contacted by the assigned adjuster at all. *** claimed that first Chicago was still waiting for police report from police department. I had the police report and emailed to ***. She acknowledged receipt on 6/2. She said she would have *** call me. Adjuster did finally call me on 6/3. She did not even ask me about the incident at all. She simply stated as did the supervisor that they were still trying to contact their insured driver and that the insured driver was not returning f their calls. They did eventually get in contact with driver. They then assigned an appraiser to come look at my vehicle. So on 6/6/22 a third party appraiser came and spent about 5 minutes looking at my car and left. I had already submitted pictures. According to third party appraiser, she submitted estimate to First Chicago on 6/6. First Chicago stated estimate was received but not submitted for approval by *** same day per policy but it was not. Claim has been denied due to errors and misinformation. Claim number 22ILV91753. Please contact me

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
V
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance My daughter was involved in a car accident on 10/21** policy #INA635805-04- Claim #**INA98277

My daughter was involved in a car accident on 10/21*** policy #INA635805-04- Claim #INA98277. My daughter is a driver on the policy, fully covered for 2 years. On 10//20*** we called to file a claim and we asked about a rental vehicle as well, since it was the weekend they told us to call back on Monday. On Monday 10/24, my daughter spoke to a claims adjuster, *** about a rental. She gave her a coupon code for *** and told her to make a reservation with the claim # and she would be reimbursed. On 10/25*** we were assigned a claims adjuster, *** and she told us an inspector would be contacting us to look at the vehicle. The inspector contacted my daughter on 10/27*** and said he would be out to look at the vehicle by the end of the week but neither my daughter nor I had heard from him; no knock on the door or anything, as far as we know he didnt come. We have been reaching out to *** for a month in regards to our claim because each time we call she says the claim is on her managers desk and is waiting to be reviewed. She also continues to bring up an accident from 2 years ago, which I was never asked about when agreeing to sign with this company. I reached out to the manager and left a voicemail after my call got declined and explained what was going on and if he couldnt help I would take further measures. He immediately called back and basically told me that If I reached out to an attorney, to have them send him a letter. He was completely unbothered by anything I was saying and didnt seem interested in helping me resolve the claim. My daughter has been paying out of pocket on a rental for a month, which we are supposed to be reimbursed for. We have no answers or estimated date on when the claim will be resolved. I'm asking for help because my daughter has to get back and forth to work and we have been paying this insurance company every month for 2 years for nothing in turn. Its 11/20/*** and we have yet to hear anything back.

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
V
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
First Chicago Insurance has left an official reply on this complaint.

First Chicago Insurance Hello. I filed a claim on 12/23, and I have had an extremely difficult time with this insurance company responding to me and issuing

Hello. I filed a claim on 12/23, and I have had an extremely difficult time with this insurance company responding to me and issuing payment to fix my vehicle. They have dragged this claim out for almost four months.First Chicago Insurance Company had my car towed to *** on January 7, 2022, and my car has been there ever since. They are located at *** South Chicago Ave. I finally received an estimate from ***, the adjuster, on February 7, 2022 after filing a complaint with the Complaintsboard.com, which a copy of such estimate was supposed to be sent to Classic Collision. I spoke with *** from Classic Collision, and they hadn't even heard from the insurance company at that point. I received a voicemail from *** on February 24 stating that she had mailed a check to Classic *** Center on February 15 for payment to have my car repaired.I spoke with *** at Classic *** on 3/10/2022 and 3/31/2022, and he said that not only had they not received the check, but they had not even received approval from this company to start the repairs. The adjuster flat out lied about sending the payment, and I would like to see a copy of the check that she "mailed." I had e-mailed *** on March 12, 2022 asking her about the check that she mailed on February 15, 2022, and she still has not responded, and it is now April 1, 2022. Classic *** never received a check as of 4/1/2022.*** from Classic *** also said that he is having a hard time getting this adjuster to respond to his calls and emails. He said that he is now going back and forth with three adjusters fighting to get approval of estimates. How did *** mail a check if the estimates were not approved?This company has been receiving my monthly premium payments while dragging this claim out in an attempt to keep collecting my payments. Can they please issue the payment finally so that my vehicle can be repaired?

Read full review of First Chicago Insurance
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review

About First Chicago Insurance

Screenshot First Chicago Insurance
First Chicago Insurance is a reputable insurance provider specializing in property and casualty coverage. The company was founded in 1920 and has been operating successfully ever since, offering a variety of insurance products including liability, automobile, homeowners, renters, and commercial coverage.

One of the unique aspects of First Chicago Insurance is the company's commitment to providing personalized service to its clients. The company achieves this by employing experienced and knowledgeable agents who are dedicated to helping clients find the best coverage options to fit their individual needs. Additionally, First Chicago Insurance utilizes advanced technology to simplify the insurance process and make it as easy as possible for clients to manage their policies.

First Chicago Insurance also prides itself on offering affordable rates without compromising on quality coverage. The company has partnered with several top-rated insurance carriers, which enables them to provide a wide range of coverage options at competitive prices.

Moreover, First Chicago Insurance places a strong emphasis on community involvement and has been actively involved in numerous charitable initiatives. The company's commitment to social responsibility not only contributes to making a positive impact on local communities but also to promoting awareness of social issues.

In summary, First Chicago Insurance is a trustworthy insurance provider with a long-standing reputation for quality service, competitive rates, and community involvement. If you're in need of insurance coverage, First Chicago Insurance is definitely worth considering.

Overview of First Chicago Insurance complaint handling

First Chicago Insurance reviews first appeared on Complaints Board on Feb 2, 2023. The latest review I was involved in an accident that was clearly a person who was insured by this insurance company's fault was posted on Mar 5, 2023. The latest complaint I was involved in an accident that was clearly a person who was insured by this insurance company's fault was resolved on Mar 05, 2023. First Chicago Insurance has an average consumer rating of 5 stars from 28 reviews. First Chicago Insurance has resolved 13 complaints.
Ratings on other sites
Trustpilot
Trustpilot
1.3
53 reviews
Trust badge
Collect Your Trust Badge
Be recognized for outstanding customer service
  1. First Chicago Insurance contacts

  2. First Chicago Insurance phone numbers
    +1 (888) 262-8864
    +1 (888) 262-8864
    Click up if you have successfully reached First Chicago Insurance by calling +1 (888) 262-8864 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached First Chicago Insurance by calling +1 (888) 262-8864 phone number Click down if you have UNsuccessfully reached First Chicago Insurance by calling +1 (888) 262-8864 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached First Chicago Insurance by calling +1 (888) 262-8864 phone number
  3. First Chicago Insurance address
    6640 S Cicero Ave, Bedford Park, Illinois, 60638-5836, United States
  4. First Chicago Insurance social media
First Chicago Insurance Category
First Chicago Insurance is related to the Insurance Services category.

Our Commitment

We stand for unbiased reviews

We make sure all complaints and reviews are from real people sharing genuine experiences.

We help resolving issues

We offer easy tools for businesses and reviewers to solve issues together. Learn how it works.

We advocate freedom of speech

We support and promote the right for reviewers to express their opinions and ideas freely without censorship or restrictions, as long as it's respectful and within our Terms and Conditions, of course ;)

We ensure transparent and fair ratings

Our rating system is open and honest, ensuring unbiased evaluations for all businesses on the platform. Learn more.

We care about your privacy

Personal details of reviewers are strictly confidential and hidden from everyone.

We are easy, free and open to everyone

Our website is designed to be user-friendly, accessible, and absolutely free for everyone to use.