America's Test Kitchen
Reviews and Complaints

I watched a couple of episodes of America's Test Kitchen on my local PBS station. They mentioned going to americastestkitchen.com for more information and recipes. I entered my email address and now I am being bombarded by their emails. There is NO workable unsubscribe link, The unsubscribe link takes you to a page where you can sign up for more emails. There is nothing on the page about unsubscribing. You have to login to your account to manage your preferences. I don't have an account with them. This stinks and is likely against the law.

This is still going on in 2022. I came home from vacation and found a package that had been rained on. I opened it up and saw an American Test Kitchen Air Fryer cookbook that I had not ordered, along with an invoice for $25.45. I laughed when I saw invoice #1000 and payment due 22-Jul-22 7:05:15am. Yeah, right.

I googled "American Test Kitchen scam" and found this site.

The good news is I called the number on the back of the invoice, [protected], and said that I did not order the book. The lady took care of it and said I did not have to return the invoice or the book.

I think when they say if you want to get a copy of a recipe at the end of the show just go to americastestkitchens.com what they fail to say you must join them and pay. So much for public TV.

charge was$39.95

I would like a refund please

I would send this unwanted book back be I don't have the address or box.

America's test kitchen is a scam! Do not ever buy anything from them or you to will forever be getting thier unsolicited books and bills!

I have the same problem. I ordered something from them, and now they send me their "annual" issue every year, even though I send them back and say DO NOT SEND ANY MORE but they do it anyway. I just got another one this week. What can I do about this? I won't keep something I didn't pay for, even if I didn't request it -- but I'm really tempted to just give it to Goodwill! Any suggestions?

I had the same experience with ATK - I thought I was supporting a noble public television cause, only to be treated in the same way record clubs of the 70's & 80's treated their members by stealing their money with unethical business practices. It seems that after they hired Jack Bishop as CEO the organization began operating in this unethical manor just as many American corporations do - treat your loyal members like cattle to be milked because they believe they can get away with it - and they did and DO STILL. I just realized I had been being billed $19.95/mo for over a year for a "cooking class" that I didn't even know existed, much less signed up for. They "can only refund 2 months" so Jack Bishop was able to help fund his salary with over $200 stolen from me, and I'm sure thousands, if not hundreds of thousands of people have had this same experience. It seems strange that a car thief goes to jail for stealing a car worth only a few thousand, but Jack Bishop can steal millions and there is no recourse, no punishment, not even a reprimand.

I don't understand why an organization as noble as PBS would allow them to do this to the American public. I will never again support PBS, since they are complacent to this behavior.

Kevin Lewis

Copy of letter I wrote to Americas Test Kitchen regarding what I view as fraudulent/unethical business practices:
Today I received a Cook's Illustrated 2017 recipe book in the mail.  I did not order any merchandise from you, so I called customer service to inquire.  I was told that I received this book because I was placed on automatic renewal from last year's order.

Last year I did receive the 2016 & 2015 cook books from you when I was solicited by phone from ATK's fundraising event to help keep the t.v. show on PBS.  Being a viewer and fan of the show, I made what was a suggested DONATION for the 2016 cook book and by making the DONATION on that day by credit card, I was gifted the 2015 book too.  To reiterated, I did not outright purchase anything and was under no understanding that I would be enrolled on an automatic shipment and payment schedule.

Customer service has rectified this for me and I will be returning the book and getting refunded, however, I want to express my extreme displeasure with your marketing gimmicks that hooked me into this.  Here I was under the impression that I was making a kind gesture of donating to a financially failing t.v. program to help keep running, meanwhile I was fooled into making a subscription purchase.

I didn't mind the $19.95 for ATK and CC when it first came online, or the bump up to $29.95, or even the bigger bump up to $39.95 in the early 2010's. But $69.95! For a great big bundle I don't want! I don't know if they know this, but you can find every recipe online anyway...for free. And I remembered receiving 1st notices, 2nd notices, and the barrage of "last notices"(which was a lie, because they kept on coming for over 8 months!) for a subscription to Cooks Country Magazine that had expired. They couldn't auto-bill me because the credit card's number changed. They hounded me for months! I don't want to do business with them anymore. If I want the magazines and cookbooks...I will go to a clearing house and order them.

This is the second time this company has sent an unordered publication.

About a year ago, I ordered a cookbook from America's Test Kitchen. It arrived and I thought nothing more about it. About two months ago, I received a notice in the mail that I would soon receive another cookbook, although I had not ordered one. I though nothing more about it until a few weeks ago when I received a large package from ATK. Since I did not order it, I took it to the post office and noted "Return to Sender." Although something received which has not been ordered may be treated as a gift, I did not want future hassles. Today I received a "2D NOTICE, " although I did not receive a first notice! I phoned the number on the notice and heard a recording telling me to disregard this notice and that my return was being processed. Although I'm not going to have to pay for that book, this has been a real time waster. ATK is beginning to sound like a real flaky company. and no pun intended. I will also write PBS, which carries their program about this.

I recently received a "Best of...2014" cookbook, with an invoice for $24.85. I knew I had not ordered the book, so I tried to contact ATK. There was no contact info anywhere on the invoice. I went online - no contact info on their website either. I took a guess and sent an email to "support@americastestkitchen.com". I received a quick response - I had "signed up" a year earlier for a cookbook series when I purchased one book. I don't remember seeing this anywhere in the fine print. The information emailed me by ATK stated that they would send out a postcard prior to sending any cookbook (they did not) and that I had a 45 day free review of any cookbook received and that I could return the book and ATK would pay the postage. That was not stated anywhere on the invoice, either. ATK initially told me that I would have to pay to return the cookbook - until I quoted its "terms and conditions". Service rep then agreed to send me a postage-paid return envelope. I did a quick search online and found scores of similar complaints. I then contact ATK support again and told them that I was not going to spend my time and energy returning something I did not order. I quoted postal service regulations that stated I could keep or dispose of items that were mailed that I had not ordered. I then told the rep that I was going to file a complaint with the FTC and BBB of MA. I did both (they are both online and very quick/easy). I had a response from the BBB in less than 24 hours. ATK again quoted the terms and conditions to which I had "agreed", but "generously" offered to waive the payment, remove me from my "cookbook subscription" and allow me to keep the cookbook as a gesture of good faith. Needless to say, I will NEVER order anything from ATK or Cook's Illustrated ever again. These business practices are fraud at worst, gross deception at best.

I posted a complaint here. I like to respond to problems by email. I usually don't call. But none of the email addresses worked. So my wife's caregiver called. A very polite young man said they had some site problems. He closed my account and is refunding the 12.45 I had to paid to return the book because I had opened the package. The label they include in the book is not prepaid. If you just write refused without opening it, then you will not pay postage, but you may still have a problem of them billing you. My payment is pending the return of the book. Who knows what is next. I recommend you call the 800 number. John

John, I called and complained about receiving an unsolicited book, and I insisted on talking with a supervisor. She told me I could print a return label and I insisted that I did not want to go through that trouble and then have to take MY time to return the book to the post office. She finally agreed that I did not have to return the book and I would not be charged with it. I will donate it to my local library and I will NEVER do business with America's Test Kitchen again. Good luck to you.

I received the 2014 version of their book which I did not order. I ordered some years ago but not recently. They included an invoice in the book along with a product return label. I went to the post office to return the book with their label. I was charged 12.45 to return the book. I asked the post office about a law I heard about saying that you don't have return unsolicited merchandise. The clerk said I would have to pay for the book if I kept it. So I returned it. But I'm out $12.45. I tried to email them several different ways including their form. Nothing worked. How do you contact these people? Would I have any chance on getting my money back? John

I ordered some merchandise in 2013 as a Christmas gift and THIS YEAR I received an unsolicited cookbook with a bill attached! This is a TERRIBLE business practice! When I called to complain, I was told that I agreed to this in the "terms and conditions" when I ordered LAST year! They clearly do NOT want MY business again!