Menu
Write a review
File a complaint
ComplaintsBoard Animals and Pets Foremost Homeowners Insurance Tay away: abusive conduct, lowball tactics, and blatant statutory violations
Foremost Homeowners Insurance

Foremost Homeowners Insurance review: Tay away: abusive conduct, lowball tactics, and blatant statutory violations

B
Author of the review
6:25 pm UTC
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Featured review
This review was chosen algorithmically as the most valued customer feedback.

Do not under any circumstances trust Foremost Insurance with your home or your peace of mind. No human being should ever do business with this company. From the moment a severe hail storm damaged our manufactured home in July 2026, Foremost has treated us not as valued policyholders who pay our premiums on time, but as mindless bottom-feeders they can bully, gaslight, and ignore into submission.

If you actually have to file a legitimate property claim, prepare for war. Foremost’s entire claims strategy relies on banking on the hope that you don't have a brain, don't know your state's insurance laws, and will simply roll over and accept pennies on the dollar. Here is the reality of how Foremost operates:

Blatant Disregard for State Law: Despite clear Connecticut matching statutes requiring a reasonably uniform appearance, Foremost initially tried to force a patchwork repair job on discontinued siding. It took formal intervention from the Connecticut Insurance Department just to force Foremost to admit that matching siding does not exist—something they knew from day one.

Deliberate Scope Omissions & Lowballing: While actual restoration costs are roughly $22,000 to properly repair the damage and make our home whole again, Foremost threw out an insulting initial estimate of around $11,600. Even after getting caught violating matching laws on the main elevations, they continue to play games by omitting the rear siding elevation, refusing to cover all 10 damaged shutters and 12 damaged window screens, and improperly applying depreciation to labor and taxes.

Hostile and Abusive Customer Service: The conduct from their claims department has been so hostile, dismissive, and abusive on the phone that we were forced to demand that all further communication be conducted strictly in writing. They have even prematurely closed the claim while major disputes were still completely unresolved, and they routinely ignore formal written escalations and supplemental documentation.

Foremost Insurance is an absolute disgrace to the industry. They gladly take your premium dollars, but the second catastrophic weather strikes your home, they treat you like garbage and fight tooth and nail to avoid paying what they legally and contractually owe. Save yourself months of agony, regulatory complaints, and endless stress—take your business anywhere else.

0 comments

Add a comment