Menu
SmartAupairs

SmartAupairs review: Unethical behaviour 6

K
Author of the review
2:01 am EDT
Featured review
This review was chosen algorithmically as the most valued customer feedback.

We are a family from melbourne and in 2012 we engaged an au pair from smart au pairs, her name is birte, a german girl who won the au pair of the year award in 2012. She was really a nice person, kind, patient, punctual and always doing her job the best way she could.
Smart au pairs asked me to complete a form so that my au pair could participate in the contest, we gave our feedback and she happened to win the award of the year. Smart au pairs took advantage of her efforts, they used publicity on their favour to make families believe that they recruited her. Smart au pairs never recruited birte, they just received her application from the german agency who did all the checks, smartau pairs did not do anything else than present her application to me and other families in australia, but they claim to be the winners of the au pair of the year award, and just try to get publicity, they try to use families and au pairs to give publicity to them, that is not something ethical. We were just used by them. Smartaupairs should admit that the recruiting agency was the german au pair agency and not them.

6 comments
Add a comment
D
D
Dili
, US
May 30, 2021 5:41 pm EDT

I worked as an au pair for a week and then quit because I lived somewhere in the middle of nowhere. When I talked to my host mum in the morning she wanted me leave right after. I didn't get the two weeks to find another family or a place to stay. I packed my suitcase in 30 minutes and booked a hostel. My host mum picked me off at the train station without caring about the fact that I had to wait 1, 5hrs for the next train to Sydney (my host family lived in Wallerawang) in a foreign country! Then, I didn't get paid for the week I worked. And I worked! They (smart au pairs and the family) even said I am guilty because I left them. But they didn't mention that the family wasn't honest telling me that they live in a city with 20k population. They should've said that they live 20km away from that city and that I left Germany to stay in the middle of nowher! And they didn't say that I offered them 2 months to stay, so they could find an au pair! Or that I was left at the train station without asking if I am alright! I would never recommend the agency!

D
D
Dili
, US
May 30, 2021 5:40 pm EDT

I worked as an au pair for a week and then quit because I lived somewhere in the middle of nowhere. When I talked to my host mum in the morning she wanted me leave right after. I didn't get the two weeks to find another family or a place to stay. I packed my suitcase in 30 minutes and booked a hostel. My host mum picked me off at the train station without caring about the fact that I had to wait 1, 5hrs for the next train to Sydney (my host family lived in Wallerawang) in a foreign country! Then, I didn't get paid for the week I worked. And I worked! They (smart au pairs and the family) even said I am guilty because I left them. But they didn't mention that the family wasn't honest telling me that they live in a city with 20k population. They should've said that they live 20km away from that city and that I left Germany to stay in the middle of nowher! And they didn't say that I offered them 2 months to stay, so they could find an au pair! Or that I was left at the train station without asking if I am alright! I would never recommend the agency!

M
M
MrsMac82
, AU
Jul 13, 2017 12:27 am EDT

We are a Sydney based family and just completed the interview process with smart Au Pairs 2017 - Im absolutely disgusted at the way in which they conduct business. On two occasions i rang to clarify their costs and was told the only fees and charges involved was a 200.00 fee to get the ball rolling and a police check that my husband and i would have to undertake and a 500.00 bonus paid to the Au Pair at the end of the contract. When we became emotionally invested in a candidate and offered the formal invitation to our candidate, we were presented with 1000.00 placement fee! I admit in part to not understanding the fees, but when i made two inquiries with Smart Aupairs to clarify the fees i feel they deliberately mislead me - and left me in position in where i had to let a lovely candidate down and disappoint my young children - unethical and unacceptable behavior .

Before considering this agency i would suggest everyone review this link as the information you get over the phone was misleading
http://www.smartaupairs.com.au/why-smartaupairs/program-costs/

G
G
Gercy
, AU
Feb 07, 2017 4:19 am EST

Smartaupairs is the worst company you can choose when looking for an aupair. Bad service, lack of communication. They just want to get the placement fee from you and that's it. Call them and nobody will answer your call just an answering machine. If things go wrong with the aupair, Smartaupairs will not provide any support and you have to pay again if you want a replacement. BE CAREFUL with this company as they just want your money. I am not impressed if they did this to get publicity. The business has no ethic whatsoever

P
P
P. Brunner IAPA
, DE
Oct 27, 2016 9:25 pm EDT
Verified customer This comment was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

Whoever wrote this seems certainly not to be the family who hosted Birte.
I happened to be the the board member at the International Au Pair Association handing the award to Birte in 2012. The host family had even sent a lovely video that we showed.
The Au Pair of the Year Award is an award that IAPA hands out every year to an Au Pair representing thousands of other wonderful young people who participate in this cultural experience through an agency. Here the link to our website where you see the winners of the last years with both agencies mentioned https://www.iapa.org/events-2/au-pair-of-the-year/au-pair-of-the-year-winners/
As you can see on our website we hand it over to different Au Pairs who were placed by different agencies. Of course the agencies can also be proud of their work and use this also on their websites/social media. They made the match, bring both sides together and take care of families and aupairs. Generally the receiving agency has more work with the placement altogether as they are in charge for the whole time of the placement. The German agency was invited as well and she could have used the award as well to inform people. If you look at past winners we usually highlight both agencies-sending and receiving. Not always both sides choose to attend the ceremony but they are acknowledged. Placing an au pair is usually a cooperation between sending and receiving agency at least in our understanding. But the receiving agency does a big amount of work and is the matchmaker between family and applicant. It is also the receiving agency handing in the application as the process of application is started from the that side. Host parents write an essay about their wonderful au pair.
Smartaupairs has done nothing unethical or incorrect and it is for sure not the host mother who wrote this.

Patricia Brunner
Managing Director
IAPA International Au Pair Association
www.iapa.org

Wine Is Good
Wine Is Good
, US
Oct 27, 2016 3:41 pm EDT

If she works for them, and she was entered into the contest as their employee, then when she won, so did they. So they are right.

Learn how the rating is calculated

Write a review File a complaint

SmartAupairs contacts

Phone number
Website
www.smartaupairs.com.au
Category