I too was ripped off by this website and its owner, Joel Simkhai. He is operating several SCAM magazine subscription services from a NY address.
Please consider filing a complaint with the New York Attorney General's office online at:
It only takes about 10 minutes. You will need the following information when making the complaint:
41 W 72nd Street, 10G
New York, NY 10023
There is no guarantee that you will receive your money back by filing this complaint. Nevertheless, it is important that Mr. Cuomo know what type of businesses are operating within his jurisdiction.
Also consider filing a complaint with the FBI's Internet Fraud Division at: www.ic3.gov