Menu
Write a review
File a complaint
Neatstuff Collectibles Profile

Neatstuff Collectibles

neatstuffcollectibles.com

Learn how the rating is calculated

3.0 1 Review 1 Complaint
Claim Your Business
Take control of your profile: address complaints and engage with reviews
Write a review File a complaint

Latest Reviews and Complaints

ComplaintsBoard
W
Verified customer This review was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
New review

Neatstuff Collectibles - Fair and honest. Great experience!

When it came time to sell my collection I wasn't sure who to reach out to. I had bought from Neat stuff over the years so I reached out to them as well as 3 other large national dealers. Out of the 3 only 2 responded to me and thankfully Neat Stuff was interested in my collection. We worked out a fair deal and it went through without any problems. Highest recommendation!

Recommendation: I recommend Neat Stuff Collectibles for buying or selling comics

Read full review
Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
R
8:20 am EDT

Neatstuff Collectibles - The good the bad and the ugly of false and misleading advertising

Well the bad is what i got wen i called brian schutzer the owner of neatstuff.com only to find out that him and his partner don’t honor there advertising slogans they are untrue and are misleading and only out to defraud you of your high dollar collection and degrade the rest of it. they state they will buy your whole collection and yet they come and pick only what they want and don’t even pay you accordingly to the over street price guide lines which they are advertised in. they say they want all marvel books and yet only want books they can get cheap and make thousands off of. that’s ok but come on low-ball degrade your collections and at the same time there e-bay transactions actions are in the thousands or maybe in the millions that’s ok for them but wen your unemployed like me and that’s not ok when your trying to sell your family collection for a fair price and you get shot-down.

Read full complaint
Hide full review

Neatstuff Collectibles Reviews and Complaints

Looks like Neatstuff Collectibles has no reviews or complaints yet, which is great!

However, if you have something to share with the others, you can write a complaint or review

Write a review     Leave a complaint
Subscribe to receive notifications of all new customer feedback

Overview of Neatstuff Collectibles complaint handling

Neatstuff Collectibles reviews first appeared on Complaints Board on Jul 17, 2012. The latest review Fair and honest. Great experience! was posted on Jul 26, 2024. Neatstuff Collectibles has an average consumer rating of 1 stars from 2 reviews. Neatstuff Collectibles has resolved 0 complaints.
Trust badge
Collect Your Trust Badge
Be recognized for outstanding customer service
  1. Neatstuff Collectibles Contacts

  2. Neatstuff Collectibles phone numbers
    +1 (800) 326-7064
    +1 (800) 326-7064
    Click up if you have successfully reached Neatstuff Collectibles by calling +1 (800) 326-7064 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached Neatstuff Collectibles by calling +1 (800) 326-7064 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached Neatstuff Collectibles by calling +1 (800) 326-7064 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached Neatstuff Collectibles by calling +1 (800) 326-7064 phone number
  3. Neatstuff Collectibles emails
  4. Neatstuff Collectibles address
    680 Route 211 East, Unit 7, Middletown, New York, 10941, United States
  5. Neatstuff Collectibles social media
  6. Rachel
    Checked and verified by Rachel This contact information is personally checked and verified by the ComplaintsBoard representative. Learn more
    Sep 11, 2025
Neatstuff Collectibles Category
Neatstuff Collectibles is ranked 12 among 13 companies in the Antiques and Collectibles category

Our Commitment

We stand for unbiased reviews

We make sure all complaints and reviews are from real people sharing genuine experiences.

We help resolving issues

We offer easy tools for businesses and reviewers to solve issues together. Learn how it works.

We advocate freedom of speech

We support and promote the right for reviewers to express their opinions and ideas freely without censorship or restrictions, as long as it's respectful and within our Terms and Conditions, of course ;)

We ensure transparent and fair ratings

Our rating system is open and honest, ensuring unbiased evaluations for all businesses on the platform. Learn more.

We care about your privacy

Personal details of reviewers are strictly confidential and hidden from everyone.

We are easy, free and open to everyone

Our website is designed to be user-friendly, accessible, and absolutely free for everyone to use.