National Union Fire Insurance review: billing FingerHut account

This company tried to take money out of Wells Fargo account back in 2008. I caught and stopped it. They were sending past due but I called them to tell them I canceled it. Now just recently my Finger Hut account was getting billed for it. I paid no attention to the bills because I knew my balance and had auto pay. I open up this last bill and found out the have been charging my FingerHut account withourt my permission. I called them and told them I want my money back but they say they cant but they can put in a claim so I put in 5 claims and if I dont get money for those claims I will be filling law suit agaisnt this company.