Banfield, The Pet Hospital of Superior, CObanfield almost killed my cat, then wouldn't pay for associated medical bills

This review was posted by
a verified customer
Verified customer

I was a client of Banfield, the Pet Hospital of Superior in Colorado. The primary vet’s name is Dr. Ken Katz, another vet on the roster is Shelley Raines. There are other vets on staff that are not listed in the directory. Both of my cats were on a Wellness Plan, and they have been for nearly 9 years. I was a loyal customer of Banfield for over 10 years.

On December 23, 2010 I took my cats in for dental prophylaxis. This requires that the cat be intubated and anesthetized. I brought my cats home. One seemed normal and the other, Rahmi, hid under the bed. I contacted Banfield the next day and they said this was normal. I then went on Christmas vacation out of state. I was never given any literature on warning signs to look for following a prophylaxis. On December 26, my cat sitter arrived. She never reported anything out of the ordinary, but again, we didn't know what to look for and she has visual memory issues from a brain injury.

When I returned home on January 3, 2011 I walked in my door to see that Rahmi appeared to be blown up like a balloon. I wondered how much my sitter fed him. I knelt down and poked at him - it seemed to be air. I didn’t understand what was going on and I called the emergency vet. They asked if he had any recent surgeries and I said he had a dental. They said to bring him in. Immediately they suspected that his trachea had been torn during the dental. They took xrays and air had lifted his skin about 4 inches from the rest of his body. He had collapsed lungs and his heart was lifted from his chest wall by several inches and all of his organs had shifted around, which made the situation critical.

The next morning, the surgical team confirmed this and determined that he must have a necrotic tear in his trachea that required surgery. I agreed to the scope and surgery. During the scope, they found nothing. They told my vet at Banfield in Superior, CO what had happened.

Shortly after they relayed the information to Banfield, the vet who performed the dental called me and acted all concerned. She then stated, “Obviously it wasn’t due to the dental because it didn't present immediately, and tears always present immediately. Shucks, if it was due to us, we’d definitely contribute to the costs.” She then tried to get me to say it wasn’t their fault. Even though they couldn't find a tear, my cat was still gravely ill and could die at any time.

I filed a complaint with Banfield and two days later Dr. Katz had one of his assistants call and say it wasn’t their fault, they're not refunding the dental expenses, releasing me from the plans or reimbursing me any of the $2000 costs. They consider the matter closed.

I then complained to the corporate head quarters. They said I could "escalate" it and put my plan on hold while it was researched. I agreed to having my plan put on hold. But, two weeks later I got a call from Banfield telling me that my account was delinquent and if I didn't make payments, I would be sent to collections. As it turns out, there is no such thing as "putting an account on hold." She just stopped the auto payments and didn't tell me I'd be sent to collections if I kept it current.

So far, trying to resolve the dispute in the least costly way isn't working. I have been posting to the corporate facebook wall and posting complaints where I can. I am pretty sure I'll have to escalate it and take legal action. I'm starting a blog to keep track of my actions. Going after vets for malpractice is daunting, to say the least.

banfield almost killed my cat, then wouldn't pay for associated medical bills


  • Banfield Pet Hospital Mar 30, 2011
    This comment was posted by
    a verified customer
    Verified customer

    We are sorry to hear that Rahmi fell ill and we are glad to hear he has recovered. After reviewing Rahmi’s medical records from all the veterinarians who cared for him, we have confirmed that there is no relation between the airway abnormality and the anesthetic procedure performed in our hospital. If you have any specific questions or medical concerns relating to Rahmi’s care at Banfield, please contact your hospital team. If you have additional questions or concerns, you may want to follow-up with the outside specialist who performed the diagnostic scoping procedure.

    We would also like to clear up the apparent confusion regarding your Optimum Wellness Plan account. The remaining monthly payments are for services Rahmi has already received at Banfield. When an account is put on hold, the payment is not automatically debited from a client’s specified banking account (or credit card), but clients are still responsible for making payments during the hold period. If you have additional questions regarding your wellness plan payments, please contact our Wellness Plan Relations Team at [protected] or [email protected]

    0 Votes
  • R0
    R0ckatiel Mar 27, 2011

    I'm sorry that happened to both of you...Tepi, I would take serious legal action for that, hearing that story about made me throw something in anger. God will still punish them for what they did, but you need compensation, at least I think so, because they took your canine angel. Did you take pictures of him and his injuries?

    0 Votes
  • Te
    tepi7734 Mar 21, 2011

    I feel for you. I took my Great Dane to an emergency hospital for pets and Hooch [his name] was quite heavy so my husband and I offered to assist the doctor and nurse lift him up on the table because they were smal petite women and they said we couldnt go in the back. 2 hours later the receptionist didnt know any thing so I thought to hell with it and I walked in the back and the 2 women were setting at a table eating and I asked where was Hooch and the doctor said they couldnt get him on the table and he was in the next room. My darling dog was laying on the floor, in the dark with the kight off and he was whining. The nurse brought me in a paper stating Hooch had an ankle sprain. He walked in the hospital on his own and when we left, another customer had to help us carry him to the car. Long story short, that night he died in agony, from a sprained ankle? The receptionist secretly called me and told me the ### dropped Hooch. I was so devastated i was in shock. Every one said I should have sued but all I want is God to punish them. I believe in Karma. He had after his death I noticed, a huge bruise on his belly and he was ### massive blood and I found out he died of internal injury. I had Hooch cremated and when I die his ashes will be put in with me.

    0 Votes

Post your comment

    By clicking Submit you are agreeing to the Complaints Board’s Terms and Conditions


    Unhappy consumers gather online at and have already logged thousands of complaints.
    If you see dozens of complaints about a certain company on ComplaintsBoard, walk away.
    One of the largest consumer sites online. Posting here your concerns means good exposure for your issues.
    A consumer site aimed at exposing unethical companies and business practices.
    ComplaintsBoard is a good source for product and company gripes from especially dissatisfied people.
    You'll definitely get some directions on how customer service can best solve your problem.
    Do a little research on the seller. Visit consumer complaint websites like ComplaintsBoard.