Gloria Vanderbilt Amanda Jeans review: Amanda Jeans 1

As others have stated I have been wearing Amanda Jeans for years. I just bought 4 pairs (a size smaller) without trying them on. My problem is that all 4 pairs fit so different. I bought 16w short. 1 pair is perfect so I am comparing the other to this pair. The other three are larger and each different. They are also all 3 different lengths. The legs are baggy. Why does this happen? Of course I removed tags and washed them before trying them on. I purchased them all at the same time from Kohls who sells them for $52 a pair.

My lesson here is try them on at the store! Ugh