The complaint has been investigated and
resolved to the customer's satisfaction
Resolved
Wasserman RamsayWasserman Ramsay Chartered Accountants Fraud!

Attention Enpar, Dr. Gene S. Shelp - Director, President and C.E.O., Directors, and Shareholders.

It is not enough that McKenley Esnard resigned, the facts in this matter need the light of TRUTH and Esnard needs to be exposed for the FRAUD he is! As a public company you are bound by the rules of good governance and full disclosure, we demand for transparency.

As Tax Payers of Ontario and now an unwittingly participant in your company we demand to know the following:

- The real reason Esnard resigned
- How much was he paid off?
- Are you going to demand that he returns every cent ever earned while acting as a conman and fraud?
- Are you going to ask the fake Doctor to return every share that Enpar gave him as compensation and/or shares he may have purchased at a discount?
- Are you going to demand that he repays any and all bonuses?


Failure to do so is sending a message to the general public, your investors and the Ontario Tax Payer, that Enpar is complicit and part of this fraud.

What actions is Enpar prepared to take against its auditor Wasserman Ramsay? As it is Wasserman Ramsay’s responsibility to assure investors, and we The Tax Payers of Ontario that when McKenley Esnard was appointed CFO was he competent enough to hold such a position. Here’s a thought did anyone verify if Esnard could even read a financial statement?

We demand to know and have full disclosure what you as CEO did to verify McKenley Esnards credentials and his ability to act as a director, CFO, audit chair, chairman of the board.

We the Tax Payers of Ontario also demand full disclosure on what advice Wasserman Ramsay provided in recommendations of their due diligence regarding McKenley Esnards credentials.

We the Tax Payers of Ontario find it appalling and extremely serious that a public company trading on the TSX governed by the OSC having external auditors (Wasserman Ramsay) can allow a fraud like McKenley Esnard to earn hundreds of thousands of dollars since March of 2006 and no one knew.

It is incumbent upon Enpar to protect the interest of Ontario Tax Payers and their investors to pursue Mr. Esnard in a court of law, and lay charges of fraud, misrepresentation, theft of public funds.

It is also incumbent upon Enpar and its executive to pursue in a court of law its external auditors, Wasserman Ramsay for negligence, complicity, and misuse of public funds.

It is inconceivable to those of us who are the Tax Payers of Ontario that Enpar could continue using the services of Wasserman Ramsay seeing as how they allowed a conman such as McKenley Esnard to last as long as he did in the multiple positions he held with Enpar.

We the Tax Payers of Ontario demand and insist on a full accounting for the record to be made straight and that any and all monies not deserved be returned to the public account. Enpar has to restore the public’s trust and we the Tax Payers of Ontario are asking the OAC to put a halt trade on all executives, past and present on trading and cashing their shares until this matter is fully resolved.

Signed,
Tax Payers of Ontario

Wasserman Ramsay Chartered Accountants Fraud!
Wasserman Ramsay Chartered Accountants Fraud!
Wasserman Ramsay Chartered Accountants Fraud!

Responses

  • Vo
    Voter Sep 30, 2011

    UPDATE, the OSC – Ontario Securities Commission – has instigated an investigation.
    URGENT UPDATE

    ONTARIO SECURITIES COMMISSION

    Dear Madam:

    Thank you for contacting us about Enpar Technologies Inc. and McKenley Esnard. John Quinlan, Lead Inquiries Officer, will review your correspondence and respond to you directly.

    Please be assured that all concerns brought before us are subject to a thorough review. Our response times are influenced by various factors, including the scope and complexity of your specific matter.

    Mr. Quinlan can be contacted by e-mail sent to [email protected]; by telephone at [protected] or toll free at [protected]; or by mail addressed to Ontario Securities Commission, P.O. Box 55, 19th Floor, 20 Queen Street West, Toronto, ON M5H 3S8. Please reference your file number: # [protected]-8862, when contacting us about this concern.

    Ontario Securities Commission
    Kevin Collins
    Manager, Inquiries & Contact Centre

    0 Votes
  • Ba
    BadBadMac Sep 23, 2011

    Wasserman Ramsay CA failed to undertake basic due diligence on a TSX listed audit client that received $341, 644 in Ontario Taxpayer money.
    Is Wasserman Ramsay CA Liable?

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    The Ontario Government has just given $341, 644 to ENPAR Technologies. (See release at the end of this document). ENPAR Technologies is a publicly traded company listed in the TSX Venture Exchange. Its auditor is Wasserman, Ramsay, CA. The Board Chairman and Director of ENPAR Technologies is McKenley Esnard
    Who is McKenley Esnard? Well, his biography is attached. It can also be found at the following web links:
    http://www.enpar-tech.com/
    http://www.enpar-tech.com/company_directors.php
    http://www.ecci.ca/mckenley.htm

    Fraudulent Misrepresentation of Professional Credentials - McKenley Esnard
    So what does McKenley Esnard say are his credentials? Well, among other things, he claims to have three (3) PhDs (two from the University of Toronto and one from the University of Vermont) and an MBA from the Harvard School of Business.
    An independent investigation has found that the Office of the Registrar of every one of these schools has no record of degrees earned or attendance by McKenley Esnard. (See Attachment).
    McKenley Esnard also claims to have Committee and Chair positions with the United Nations in Canada. Further, he has used this claim in promoting his consulting services to various communities including First Nations communities. The United Nations Association in Canada confirms McKenley Esnard is not and has never been on any sub-committees for the organization. (See attachment).
    In total, our research has found at least thirteen (14) significant mis-representations in McKenley Esnard’s professional biography.
    ENPAR is a narrowly traded small-cap company with reported 2010 revenues of $275, 133 according to their Q2 2011 interim financial statements. According to its web site, ENPAR has a management team of two (2) and a Board of five (5).

    Wasserman Ramsay failed to undertake basic due diligence on the company’s Board Chair. How could this happen?
    $341, 644 of Ontario Taxpayer money was given to company whose Board Chair is a professional fake.
    How does a TSX Venture Exchange listed company have a Board Chair whose credentials are completely falsified?
    Have taxpayers been ripped off?
    Where is the money going?
    Is investor money safe with this company?
    Is WR professionally liable?

    These are the questions. We want answers.

    McKenley Esnard – Professional biography

    ENPAR Awarded Ontario Government Funding to Establish Demonstration Installation of its Unique Ammonia Treatment System

    Enpar Technologies Inc ENP
    8/25/2011 11:23:00 AM

    GUELPH, ON, Aug. 25, 2011, 2011 (Canada NewsWire via COMTEX News Network) –


    Dr. Gene Shelp, President and CEO of ENPAR Technologies Inc. (TSX:ENP) ("ENPAR" or "the Company"), is very pleased to announce that the Company has been awarded funding in the amount of $341, 644 by the Ontario Ministry of Research and Innovation to conduct final tests of its AmmEL System at the City of Guelph's Waste Water Treatment Plant (WWTP). The City of Guelph Waste Water Services is supporting the project as the official Demonstration Partner. Acknowledged for its leadership through environmental stewardship initiatives, the City is committed to the long term protection of precious water resources.

    "Protecting and managing our water supplies is a key priority for Ontario and countries round the world, " said Glen Murray, Minister of Research and Innovation. "Ontario is proud to help our water technology companies grow and expand, providing clean, reliable water and creating jobs."

    Design, manufacturing, and assembly of the AmmEL System will be conducted at ENPAR's facilities in Guelph and Cambridge, Ontario. Planned to begin in late autumn of this year, the operational and analysis phases of the project will continue until the Spring, 2012. The patented, modular demonstration unit will be designed to treat approximately 100, 000 litres of waste water per day and convert ammonia in municipal wastewater to environmentally friendly nitrogen gas.
    Conventional ammonia treatment methods convert ammonia, an acute toxin, to nitrate. Nitrate, which is categorized as a chronic toxin, is typically discharged into water bodies adjacent to treatment facilities. Contamination by nitrate is implicated in the formation of carcinogenic compounds known as nitrosamines which represent a direct threat to public health and have been identified as toxic to livestock and animals in the wild.

    The cost effective AmmEL System represents a viable, year-round treatment system for ammonia in municipal and industrial waste waters. The technology removes ammonia to levels below those mandated by the provincial and federal governments, thereby fulfilling municipal and industrial waste water treatment requirements. Operating cost reductions are also anticipated.

    A major advantage of the AmmEL System is that its operational efficiency is not affected by low temperature. Therefore, it is especially well suited to water treatment markets in temperate climatic zones where water temperatures typically decline to slightly above freezing during the winter months. In addition, the environmentally friendly AmmEL System does not produce the greenhouse gas, nitrous oxide, as is the case with conventional biological treatment methods.

    "ENPAR is committed to offering high-reliability technologies as immediate solutions for the treatment of ammonia along with responsible conservation of the world's most precious resource, " Dr. Shelp commented. "The technology has the potential to improve the management of nitrogen compounds in waste water, thereby mitigating the detrimental effects of excessive nitrogen loading resulting from conventional treatment practices. We are confident that this demonstration project at the City of Guelph will provide near-term impetus to advance sales of the AmmEL System to domestic and global markets."

    The Ontario Ministry of Research and Innovation at Ontario's Global Water Leadership Summit stated in its news release of May 18, 2011 that the ENPAR "AmmEL System represents a major advance over existing technologies and ENPAR is creating 14 direct jobs to expand its operations to produce and market the new system globally."
    About ENPAR Technologies Inc.

    ENPAR is a "Technology Company" applying its patented and proprietary "Electrochemical Technologies" to the treatment of waste water, desalination water and drinking water contaminated by metals or nutrients, i.e., nitrate/ammonia associated with the mining, metal processing, chemical, agricultural, municipal and waste management sectors. The common shares of the Company trade on Tier ll of the TSX Venture Exchange under the symbol "ENP".

    The TSX Venture Exchange has not reviewed and does not accept responsibility for the adequacy or accuracy of this release.

    Forward Looking Statements

    This news release contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of the "safe harbour" provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These forward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties and other factors that may cause ENPAR Technologies Inc. results to differ materially from expectations. These include risks relating to market fluctuations, property performance and other risks. These forward-looking statements speak only as of the date hereof. Certain statements contained in this press release and in certain documents incorporated by reference into this press release constitute forward-looking statements. The use of any of the words "anticipate", "continue", "estimate", "expect", "may", "will", "project", "should", "believe" and "confident" and similar expressions are intended to identify forward-looking statements. These statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause actual results or events to differ materially from those anticipated in such forward-looking statements. ENPAR believes that the expectations reflected in those forward-looking statements are reasonable but no assurance can be given that these expectations will prove to be correct and such forward-looking statements included in, or incorporated by reference into, this press release should not be unduly relied upon. These statements speak only as of the date of this press release. ENPAR undertakes no obligation to publicly update or revise any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise.

    To view this news release in HTML formatting, please use the following URL:
    http://www.newswire.ca/en/releases/archive/August2011/25/c6224.html

    SOURCE: Enpar Technologies Inc.

    Gene S. Shelp, Ph.D., P.Geo., President and CEO Tel: [protected] Fax: [protected] E-mail:[email protected] Web Site:www.enpar-tech.com


    Summary of Fraudulent misrepresentation of Professional Credentials – McKenley Esnard

    1. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he has a PhD in Mathematics U of T & PhD Computer Science Eng. U of T - Ida Bulat, Graduate Administrator (Tel: [protected]). Department of Mathematics, University of Toronto has no record of Esnard obtaining a PHD. Joan Lewis (Tel: [protected]), oversees Student Records, School of Graduate Studies, University of Toronto could not locate a record of attendance or PHD acknowledgement for McKenley Esnard for either Mathematics or Computer Science Engineering at U of T.

    2. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he has a PhD in Communications, University of Vermont - Ms. Ida RUSSIN (Tel: [protected]) of the Graduate College Dean’s Office verified on 2009-09-08 that Esnard was never the recipient of a PHD from the University of Vermont. She also stated that no-one by the name of McKenley Esnard ever attended the University of Vermont.

    3. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he has an MBA from the Harvard Business School. The Registrar’s Office at the Harvard Business School (Emily Hayden [email protected]) has no record of attendance by McKenley Esnard at the school.

    4. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he was a Professor for master and doctorate levels in Computer Science Engineering at Carleton University - Verified thru Payroll Office Carleton University (Tel: [protected]) that Esnard has never been on the payroll in any capacity.

    5. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is on the United Nation Sub-Committee for Information Management - United Nations Association Canada Executive Director Kate White (Tel: [protected] ext. 223) has confirmed that that Esnard is not on any Sub-Committees for the United Nations and never has been.

    6. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a Software Engineering Institute (SEI) associate Professor CMU - Email sent to '[email protected]'requesting verification of Esnard’s status at SEI. Response stated that they do not have someone with the title “Associate Professor” at the SEI.
    Also: no listing of Esnard as being part of the faculty of Carnegie Mellon University (http://www.cmu.edu/directories/index.shtml) Email seeking verification at CMU sent to [email protected]

    7. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a member of the Records Management Association - To be verified thru: Contact Ottawa Chapter President, Natalie Nadon [protected]; Secretary, Karen Palmer [protected] x223

    8. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a member of the Canadian Database Standards Association - Could not locate any reference to this organization. Canadian Standards Association has no listing of Esnard being a member. http://www.csa.ca/cm/membership/membership-directory

    9. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a ITIL Committee member - ITIL stands for IT Infrastructure Library. Originally, ITIL was developed by the Central Computer and Telecommunications Agency (CCTA) as a set of comprehensive and iter-related codes of practice. CCTA, renamed the Office of Government Commerce (OGC) maintains the library and releases all updated related to ITIL. The OGC is an office of HM Treasury (UK). There is no membership status.

    10. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a member of the Association of System Managers (ASM) - Could not locate any reference to this organization

    11. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a member of the International Standards Organization (ISO) - The ISO is represented in Canada by the Standards Council of Canada (SCC) which is a Crown corporation established by an Act of Parliament in 1970. No individual membership exists.

    12. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a 17779 Standards committee member - The Information Security Organizational Policy or more commonly known as the Enterprise Security Charter is defined in the ISO/IEC 17779 Information Technology – Code of Practice for Information Security Management. The ISO is represented in Canada by the Standards Council of Canada (SCC) which is a Crown corporation established by an Act of Parliament in 1970. No individual membership exists.

    13. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a member of the International Committee on Communication Telephony and Telegraph (CCITT) - This organization does not exist however there is one called the International Committee on Communication Telephone and Telegraph (CCITT). The CCITT, now known as the ITU-T (for Telecommunication Standardization Sector of the International Telecommunications Union), is the primary international body for fostering co-operative standards for telecommunications equipment and systems. It is located in Geneva, Switzerland. Represented in Canada by the Standards Council of Canada (SCC) which is a Crown corporation established by an Act of Parliament in 1970. No individual membership exists.

    14. McKenley Esnard false claim: Claims he is a member of CATA Ottawa-Carleton Artificial Intelligence Research Center - Could not locate any reference to this organization. There is the Artificial Intelligence Group, Department of Computer Science, University of Ottawa, Canada. Also the Ottawa-Carleton Institute for Computer Science does not list Esnard as a member. Cathi Mallette (Tel: [protected]) membership coordinator for CATA confirmed that neither Esnard nor ECCI are members of CATA.

    CONTACT
    McKenley Esnard at The Esnard Group
    331 Castor Street, Russell, ON
    613.445.3869 Wasserman Ramsay CA
    301 Highway 7, Unionville, ON
    905.948.8637

    Comments

    0 Votes

Post your comment

    By clicking Submit you are agreeing to the Complaints Board’s Terms and Conditions

    IN THE NEWS

    Unhappy consumers gather online at Complaintsboard.com and have already logged thousands of complaints.
    If you see dozens of complaints about a certain company on ComplaintsBoard, walk away.
    One of the largest consumer sites online. Posting here your concerns means good exposure for your issues.
    A consumer site aimed at exposing unethical companies and business practices.
    ComplaintsBoard is a good source for product and company gripes from especially dissatisfied people.
    You'll definitely get some directions on how customer service can best solve your problem.
    Do a little research on the seller. Visit consumer complaint websites like ComplaintsBoard.