The complaint has been investigated and
resolved to the customer's satisfaction


My name is David N. Waldrop. Perhaps you know me or have seen me in recent news stories. I was told to not talk to the press but I feel it may be the only way I am herd. I was arrested a few months ago for "Ebay Theft." In my local paper they made it seem as if this IS what happened, not this is what he is accused of. The Detective who arrested me, (Dave Edwards) The D.A. office (Chad Hendee) as well as my local paper has twisted this story and made it as juicy as possible for their own gain and entertainment. So, here I am not being "physically forced" but in a round about way giving me no other choice but to plead guilty for a crime that was really just a misunderstanding. I am 29 years old this year and as of next week I will have 4 felonies on my record I have to live with for the rest of my life, some probation and some jail time and over $12, 000 "restitution."(some goes to the county of course) I am going to just give a brief summary of what is really going on and why I am feeling bullied but not legally "forced" into signing an agreement, if you have questions or want more details, just ask I will be happy to answer your inquiries. My trial date is set for June 13, 2009. I’m sure I will have to enter my plea agreement before that probably next week sometime.

Back in October of last year, I decided to sell 2 guitars I came in possession of some time ago. I was not sure of their actual worth so I asked someone. I was told they were probably 61 Gibson es 355's. (They turned out not to be) With wishful thinking backing me up, I admit I ran with the idea no questions asked. My digital camera was no more so I Googled for a decent picture of one and used it for the ad as MANY MANY people do on Ebay. I did state right in the ad "I don't know anything about guitars. I’m going on what a buddy of mine said" I also never accept returns on my items I list. This being 2 items I was unfamiliar with, I also attached a 7 day return option for the buyers in the event they were unhappy or worse they weren't as I was told. I listed them ( 2 separate guitars, 2 separate ads, but it was the same guitar so it was the same ads) Almost immediately, two separate gentleman wanted to buy the guitars but wanted to conduct the sale in person outside of Ebay. This is dangerous and against Ebay policy and results in your seller account being closed on Ebay. I refused and told them we would have to use Paypal and do it by the rules. They refused to follow through the rules, so I refused to sell to them. This was later considered 2 attempted Felony thefts. (Punishable 7 years in prison)

So I than resubmitted the ads to give it another shot. I than had 2 more men who purchased them properly. I sent out both guitars. One of the men I never herd from again. The other man is how this all started.

Not even 72 hours after the sale he filed a claim he had not received the guitar. However I have proof it was in the mail. I did have contact with him I notified him that it was mailed; I even personally went to the post office who told me it takes 7 to 9 days to get there the way it was shipped. I don't know what he was expecting but he lives all the way in Pennsylvania!

The day arrived; he had received the guitar as promised. I know because my fiancé my 5 year old little boy and I came home to three 4 minute messages from him. Stating “You better be looking over your shoulder I am coming to get you. Be scared" "I'm sure you have family and a job, this is going to affect everything you do big boy" ETC. Demanding I send him the money back without my item in hand. So we did what any normal couple would do when a lunatic from the internet is calling your home, we called the local police and contacted Paypal and Ebay.

The Police listened to the messages and said "do not contact him” and to let Paypal and Ebay handle it and they would contact him and tell him to not have direct contact with us. He didn't listen. I was handling the situation through the proper way and following the Ebay/Paypal rules. The end result was Payapl found in favor of me and said "if he returns the merchandise please provide him with a refund as according to your return policy if any" Well, I waited for him to return it long after my 7 day policy was up, I knew he had received the same notice I did. I wasn't about to hold this crazy mans hand and show him how to return an item, that was his responsibility not mine.

Well, over 2 months go by. No guitar showed up, so no refund for him. After all the other man received his guitar and had no complaints so this guy from Pennsylvania must have been really nuts threatening my family and myself instead of just doing a return like a mature adult.

Then one morning (over 4 months later) I get a knock at the door, it was Detective Dave Edwards who demanded I come speak with him. I told him I needed to open our store. He said, "You have 15 minutes to meet me at the Baraboo Police Department" So I did. He took me into a little room and told me what the situation concerned. He also told me it was my right to have a lawyer which was followed by, "But I wouldn't suggest it" After talking about it for several minutes I was confused. I just agreed and signed the waiver to a lawyer because I honestly believed I would explain and he would understand the situation. I told him it was a civil matter and I would explain everything to him just as I did here. He asked me about the man in Pennsylvania, so I explained it to him. Than he asked “If there was another guitar?” I responded, "Yea why?" He said that the man I never herd from again (who purchased the other guitar) was included in his "investigation" As far as I knew he was a happy customer. He than let me know that the reason I never herd from that man again was because the detective called him and told him not to contact me before he even received the guitar!! I asked the detective why he would do that. I told him if he wasn't happy he had a right to a refund and that because of that he prevented him from receiving one. (I later found out from the police report that when Paypal told the man in Pennsylvania to send it back in order to receive his refund the detective told him not to, because than I would be in possession of the "evidence" and he couldn't charge me!) Appears to me like I was being setup.

He than arrested me for 2 counts of Felony Theft. I was shocked I just kept telling him he has no right what so ever to arrest me. He was also harassing my fiancé and trying to drag her into it too. He was telling me on the way to get booked how he was going to talk to her and threatening to lock her up too! When I finally went to my bond hearing 2 days later, (Someone forgot paperwork, which I was told 10 minutes before my hearing after the first 24 hours I was in jail. So I had to sit an extra day in my 6X9 cell) Anyways, they changed the charges to 2 felony attempted thefts and 2 felony thefts for a grand total of 4 felony's! And a possible conviction over 20 years!!! OVER SOMETHING I WOULD HAVE GLADLY RETURNED AND WAS IN THE PROCESS OF DOING SO, HAD THE DETECTIVE NOT INTERFERRED WITH THIS CIVIL MATTER.

I've never even been arrested for stealing anything. And now at almost 30, owning our own business, having custody of my son, just bought our first home and doing pretty well, I just decided to become a mastermind Felon? I never told these men a fake name or address or phone number or even not talked to them after the fact of receiving their money. That would be pretty dumb as a criminal to give your home address where your child sleeps. And if I thought I "got away with it" don't you think I would have kept going? Why not make 2 or 3 hundred thousand off it and why did I even bother sending them an item at all? I looked all over the internet there are tons of similar cases except for a couple details... they did it hundreds of times, used aliases, and didn't send them anything! I was trying to make good with the man from Pennsylvania’s refund, but the detective told him not to send it back. (There is a copy of that e-mail in the police report) So what was I supposed to do?

So far my case has been flying by unusually lightning fast. No one listens to my side of the story and they don't care.

What do you do when your arrested for some ridiculous charge by a man who works for Sauk county than are being prosecuted by another man who works for Sauk county and than not have a $10, 000 cash retainer to hire a private lawyer but make to much for a public defender and they give you a "court appointed attorney" who was hired by who? Sauk County.

My first lawyer they gave me didn't listen to a word I said; I never even got the chance to see the inside of his office! He would literally come in our store and yell and cuss at me and tell me to take a deal without even listening to my side. It almost seemed as if he worked for the D.A. instead of me. At this point my lawyer told me it was a normal thing and to wave my right to a preliminary hearing he also said that I was "pissing off" the D.A. and himself as well. I was also told if I were to go through with a preliminary hearing they would take away the plea agreement they had offered me. So I waived my right. So, I asked for a second lawyer to be appointed to me and they did so as I asked. They assigned me to a lawyer as nice as he is, that when you Google his name and office it says his practice areas are: Car Accidents, Divorce, Family Law, Injury Law and Workers Compensation….. Is it just me or are we missing an important attribute? Like Criminal Law or Business Law? Thank you for appointing me fair representation Sauk County.

So this is where I stand now. I have 3 choices.

Option 1: Sign a plea agreement for $12, 000 to be paid in the next 90 days and I get 2 petty misdemeanors ( I don't have the money so its not even an option for us)

Option 2: is sign a plea for 30 days jail 18 months probation and no criminal activities for 5 years or will I be sentenced. Still pay the $12, 000 I just have a longer time frame to do it, and I take 4 FELONY's on my record that will haunt my life forever!

Or option 3: takes a chance in court. I want to take that option but with the way they have been twisting this case in their favor, even if it’s just a 1% chance I was found guilty. There would be a possibility of me sitting in a Jail cell for over 20 YEARS!!! Losing my fiancé, my son, my family. And all for what exactly?????

Since this has happened I have been all over the front page of our paper and on news channels and the internet a few times. The story is one sided, we lost 75% of our business because everyone looked at us as criminals. (it’s a small town and word travels fast here) and we recently had to shut it down. The people who once waved and smiled have outcast us. It's embarrassing to show up at your son's school and everyone is whispering about you. I feel bad for my son and my fiancé as well. We have lost everything we have worked for because of this. And they originally told the man from Pennsylvania it was a civil matter until he wrote a long letter and faxed it to our DA. Most of it was just personal information on me (or what he thought was me, he had me confused with a different David Waldrop that was divorced and on probation among other things, not that any of that information had to do with this situation anyways) And he made sure to throw into his letter "you can't say I didn't try to get help from Sauk County on this" All of the sudden it wasn't Civil anymore? Strange.

Just about everything I have told you is in the 400 page police report. There are Copies of the emails between the detective and the customers my emails Paypal’s investigation results etc. This is one of the most unjust things I have ever seen or experienced. Well, there you have it. It's my side of the story and it can all be found right in the police report they wrote.

We have no more money, no more store, and no more fight left in us. We have been embarrassed, shocked and outraged; But like I said who do you complain to when this happens?

I am going to sign the plea for guilty to 4 felony’s probation and restitution that will follow me forever until I am buried. I refuse to chance losing my son, fiancé, or my family trying to defend myself for something I should have never been arrested for in the first place. Can you imagine sitting in a jail cell for 10 to 20 years away from your life and people who know and love you, thinking to yourself, “I should have taking the agreement” My life has been reset, against my will. I have to start all over from nothing and it will be a little harder this time with this following me. I am a good father a good boyfriend, a good neighbor. But now, because one man cried wolf and a few others helped him, those things mean nothing. It is sad when you are forced to do something against your will and there is no one to help you. It is unfair and unjust that my life is going to be punished this badly over this, and if I just had $12, 000 to give Sauk County they would just slap me on the hand and send me on my way. (Not that I even deserve that) I hope you all understand a little better the story of the "Ebay guitar guy in Baraboo" Thank you for giving me this opportunity to tell my story and thank you for listening. It is safe to say that when this is over, I will be transferring my probation and moving as far away from this county as I can.

Written by David Waldrop



  • Ja
    jamaican lifeguard May 26, 2013
    This comment was posted by
    a verified customer
    Verified customer

    Hey David i cant believe they are doing this to you, just keep your chin up, jamaica lifeguard.

    0 Votes
  • Ar
    a reedsburg male May 06, 2011

    Yep its almost Mafia like huh.

    0 Votes
  • Mo
    montoman51 Feb 06, 2011

    You are wasting your time on the legal system of Wis. This state is RUN by the Closed Bar [censor]. of Wis. The man was correct in that you will have to BUY JUSTICE here in the Wis judicial system. The County Gov. wants money out of everyone that IT can nab. Drunk driving, disorderly conduct, battery, domistic abuse are just some of the MONEY MAKING SCEAMS being used to finanually explot their communities for REVENUE. Sounds like someone with money or influance got to this Goon(cop) and he went to the Pig(D.A., all lawyers are the Pigs, dude). You very well should have had those guitars properly authenticated. I also have some questions about your conduct and the camera matter. This should have been a civil matter on the return issue, but why did this Cop interfer with this is a good question, unless he was in the course of investigating your transactions on some un-related reported fraud you were being accused of by another of your customers? Only a FOOL (or someone trying to set one UP) would spend $5, 000 on anything through E-Bay with out fist authenticating the source and quality of the product lol. Stand your ground! There is no-were to run from the "system". I live in Outigamie County, and have lived and served time in your county...there is no dif kid. As long as you have the kind of Bar [censor]. and Judicial System that thrives on LAW-ENFORCEMENT (fines, penalties and ASSESSMENTS!), you will NOT have JUSTICE in Wisconsin! If you really want to get away from this crap, get a raft and floot around in the ocean(try to avoid any human contact what-so-ever! Oh, and stay away from E-Bay.

    0 Votes
  • Sa
    SafetyPro Jul 02, 2010
    This comment was posted by
    a verified customer
    Verified customer

    I do not live in Sauk Co. but this situation is a tragedy for Mr. Waldrop if the story he tells is accurate and honest. I'm your side David. Keep your chin up. Try to find a good lawyer for Pro Bono and sue Sauk County.

    0 Votes
  • Ic
    icetohot Jan 20, 2010

    You got screwed by the system. I think you need to buy your own lawyer and simply prove the Epiphone and Gibson were the same guitars. The two companies merged in 1957. Your only mistake was selling an item on ebay that you knew very little about. The fine for restitution you have to pay is fair because you already took their money. You should get the guitars back though.

    2 Votes
  • Dw
    D. Waldrop Jan 20, 2010

    To Master Complainer,

    First of all I DO NOT have a "lengthy criminal record" You obviously have me confused with a different David by the last name. Please don't feel stupid it happens to me all the time. I recently contacted the courts and im in the process of having the records corrected so people who assume things and jump to conclusions on a daily basis (like yourself )do not get me confused with the other one. For example, it says I have a divorce from Sara Waldrop and yes it say I DO however that is my mother and I would not be married to my mother obviously. Unless you are referring to my driving record in which case I am guilty of needing a higher insurance rate. Actually it's been so long since I've had a speeding ticket it dosn't even count on my insurance anymore. Furthermore I would actually be going on over 4 years with not even a parking ticket if it wasn't for this. I admitted I was not positive on thier authenticity... It was in the ad for them when they decided to buy them. Also I did have a return policy attatched (which I never do) but just because of my uncertainties I added one for the customers. After finding out they were not authentic and even before I didn't know both buyers were MORE than welcome to take full advantage of the refund policy and I do not blame them one bit given the later facts of the matter... I even was working with paypal on the issue to give the crazed answering machine man a refund... Truth is it never showed up. So I never refunded him. Why did it never show up? Cause the officer told him not to send it and get his money back! I have the emails and the paperwork and police report to prove it! I also never herd from the second man who purchased the other guitar until the officer asked me about him when he arrested me! So like I said before. That fact just made the guy leaving messages threatening to harm my family just seem that much more crazy to us. It wasn't even like his first call was hey we have a problem here call me back or anything even remotely adult. Just 4 messages all at once ranting, raving and threatening us. Than I here nothing for over 4 months when I'm even working with paypal to make the lunatic man happy. Let me ask you this, you order something from Walmart online you get the wrong product sent in the mail or its not as described... what do you think would happen if you went into Walmart yelling and threatening everyone and demanding they give you money NOW and you didn't even bring the product with you... Do you think they are gonna hand you money without the product in hand smiling away? What if they said no? Does the Walmart employee get charged with a felony? Just because I'm not a multi-million dollar corporation does not mean that I am not still a business and it also means I should be treated as such. The fact of the matter is if the man would have called and talked to me in an appropriate manner and didn't follow the advice of the officer as well as the other man. They would have been promptly refunded with a full apology. But unfortunetly it didn't happen that way. Also, if given I was in a more populated area that has a little more knowledge and expierence in business and laws than an area of this size of a whole 12, 000 people who mainly just assume they do, this would have also been properly handled and resolved originally. As far as the pictures yeah, sure call it what you like I was lazy, or doing what half the ebay population does. (go punch in something... try it... you will get 500 different listings with the same picture. It's actually a pretty common practice for people who do alot of business. But I guess lesson learned trust me. The person who told me was clear down by Chicago and I was feeding him the details verbally. Looking back I should have done a better job on the research but I was blinded but the adventure and excitment of antiquing and I'm sorry for that. I noticed your screen name "Master_complainer" was just registered 2 months ago or so and this seems to be the one and ONLY SINGLE COMMENT you have made... I don't know maybe it's the paranoia that I'm being picked on or targeted by this small "community" that I didn't grow up in like everyone else who works and has a family here. (which kinda seems to be the click here to us but were from near Chicago its a whole different place there... Hey maybe thats why.. hmmm) But anyways your obviously someone who had something to do with my case I could also tell by the comment you made about "Were you able to name that someone to the detectives?" That kind of gave you away. Point is you will be happy to know. We have been outcasted horribly even my 6 year old son catches grief. We lost the business we worked very hard for. We are also expierenceing finacial problems I wouldn't wish upon my worst enemy. So everyone should be ecstatic. I am doing everything I have agreed to that I wouldn't have agreed to in a million years if I was anywhere that didn't have a small local questionable justice system. I even asked for it to be transfered out of the county so I could get a fair and unbiased look at my case. Of course the answer was no. So alls thats left is for us to move forward from this and keep struggling to survive with the outcome of this hanging over my head. Have a good day. Leave us alone.

    David Waldrop

    2 Votes
  • Sa
    saramichellew Nov 24, 2009

    I believe you

    3 Votes
  • Ma
    master_complainer Oct 26, 2009
    This comment was posted by
    a verified customer
    Verified customer

    No offense, but your claim that 'this is all a big misunderstanding' would be much easier to digest if you didn't have a lengthy string of court records stretching back 9 years where you still owe hundreds of dollars to Sauk county and 2 of its neighboring counties for both criminal and civil judgments. I find it funny that this is a complaint against Sauk county and you actually owe money to two other counties for both criminal and civil charges. Sorry to be so harsh, but these are facts. If you had no criminal convictions or active civil judgments before this happened you would be amazed at how much more benefit of the doubt and sympathy you would have received. In your complaint you make it sound like you had an ideal life and that having 4 felonies on your record would ruin that life, as if it was to be your first criminal record. So apparently having 5 misdemeanors on your record hasn't ruined absolutely anything? Also regarding your actual complaint, you said your camera was 'no more', so you googled a picture. So neither you nor your girlfriend has a camera on your cellphone? Even a low quality photo is better than a stock photo on an ebay ad. What about that someone who told you about the guitars? Didn't he/she have either a camera phone or a digital camera? Were you able to name that someone to the detectives? Was there absolutely nobody you could have asked to photograph the guitars for you? It's either laziness or deception picking a picture from google images. If you weren't trying to deceive the buyers, then at least admit to being lazy.

    In life you have to own up to mistakes, make them right, and move on. Everyone makes mistakes, the only question is what you do with them afterwords. You have about 9 years worth, but it's never too late to start.

    0 Votes
  • al venden Sep 01, 2009

    “Epiphone” and “Gibson” are the same company! In the 1960's both models were made in the same factory by the same workers using the same materials. These early Gibson/Epiphones now sell for $5000-$10, 000 dollars.

    Eventually Gibson moved Epiphone to Japan where they began mass producing reissues of classic Gibson models, to be sold “only in Japan”! These 'made in Japan' or MIJ models quickly became popular world wide, although mass produced, these MIJ reissues are still made to Gibson specks but cost about one forth the price.

    These reissues are technically still “Gibson/Epiphones” and are identical to the originals, except that they have upgraded modern electronics, many models even have both Gibson and Epiphone logos on them. It would be nearly impossible for someone who didn't know anything about guitars to tell the difference.

    Given this, I believe Mr. Waldrop simply made an honest mistake, I looked it up, and this model does say Gibson on it. It's unfortunate the Sauk Co. authorities chose to interfere with this misunderstanding, it was already well on its way to being resolved through Ebay/Paypal. My heart goes out to Mr. Waldrop and his family. I hope soon they can all put this regrettable mis-justice behind them.


    2 Votes
  • Xe
    XenoMiang Aug 27, 2009

    This was an interesting story to me although it's a couple months old and this guys is serving out his 30day jail sentence.

    I read a report done on this story and it said the guitars were cheap Epiphone guitars, now my question would be why this man decided to "go by his buddy's word" and post stock photos of guitars that he wasn't even sure if they were the right ones? Isn't there ANY distinguishing factors between a cheap ### guitar and a Gibson? Also for the amount of money he sold them for (between 4 and 5k) wouldn't you check to make sure you were selling the right thing instead of going by a photo that looks "similar" ??

    Anyways, my point being to this story is that yes, there are two sides to every story but I think this guy knew what he was doing selling those guitars. Someone who sells things frequently would not have made those serious errors in both judgement general selling technique.

    And yes, there are lots of stock photo scam auctions on ebay now ... this guy just happen to get caught and I think it was deserved. That's a lot of money, even with the 7 day return policy, it was a bad business practice.

    -1 Votes
  • Ok I am sorry but this guy has reason to be upset... hun it may work in your favor to find away to get a lawyer... bring all your evidence and sue the crap out of them...its sad and hun I am sorry u guys r going through that... keep us posted...ebay stinks ne way I see tons of fake pics on there all the time...

    1 Votes
  • Ex
    exie Jun 18, 2009

    I seached for your story and got a phishing warning. is that another of your tricks?

    what did you do with the money the buyers paid? and why would you post a fake pic? that was just ignorant. to pawn something off that you knew was not the same thing is illegal.

    hey, the chick in the photo is kinda hawt. she still with you?

    0 Votes

Post your comment

    By clicking Submit you are agreeing to the Complaints Board’s Terms and Conditions


    Unhappy consumers gather online at and have already logged thousands of complaints.
    If you see dozens of complaints about a certain company on ComplaintsBoard, walk away.
    One of the largest consumer sites online. Posting here your concerns means good exposure for your issues.
    A consumer site aimed at exposing unethical companies and business practices.
    ComplaintsBoard is a good source for product and company gripes from especially dissatisfied people.
    You'll definitely get some directions on how customer service can best solve your problem.
    Do a little research on the seller. Visit consumer complaint websites like ComplaintsBoard.