Complaints Logo
Complaints Board | Submit Complaint | News & Stories | Recalls | Consumer Tips & Tricks | Videos | Mess-Ups!

Sponsored Links

Last discussed

1. (0 minutes ago)
Sancharnet BSNL
High bills problem!
2. (0 minutes ago)
Bulldogs R US
This is a huge scam
3. (1 minutes ago)
Dri*Symantec Generic
Unauthrized charge
4. (2 minutes ago)
SENSIBLE-HLP.COM
payment
5. (4 minutes ago)
Robert Karacson
Innapropriate actions, phone calls attempted rape.

Consumer tips & tricks

Worst rating

5. 360 Share Pro (-313)

Subjects of wide speculation

1. Novelty ID Factory (1322)
Take your money and run away
2. KmartFeedback.com (1283)
$2500 gift card survey!
3. Castaway Pools and Spas (697)
Never came back to finish the job!
4. Dr. Sydney Coleman (568)
Buyer beware!
5. CIC Triple Advantage (535)
Signed up for service I never received and did not want or need!

Stay away

1. Airtel (992)
3. Sears (309)
4. Direct TV (304)
5. Nokia (296)

VoteAndDate.com

Dr. Sydney Coleman Complaints - Buyer beware!

Review all Dr. Sydney Coleman complaints

Dr. Sydney Coleman

Posted: 2007-07-17 by April Smith [send email]
Buyer beware!
Complaint Rating:  77 % with 57 votes
Dr. Sydney Coleman, founder of Lipostructure has more than 50 complaints against him that have been filed with the DOH in NYC. This doctor has no business calling himself the founder of anything much less fat transfer. His fat grafts do not last at all and he harvests fat from areas without the patients' consent and leaves them with new problem areas. He took an oath to protect the patient, but he destroys their lives. He charges exuberant prices and you end up disfigured. Please do not go to him. You will be making the biggest mistake of your life. I made the mistake and have to live with the consequences daily. He has no conscience nor regard for his actions.

Buyer Beware!
Comments United States Plastic Surgery
Share with others:   Digg it!  Del.ici.ous  Furl  Yahoo My Web
Was the above complaint useful to you?    


Comments

189 days ago by Corey Taylor Clegg [send email]
In the future, I will list as COLEMAN VICTIM #2. Jenny on Masturbation??? There now appears to be..."another Jenny?" In addition to the second April Smith? Now Jenny...who I wonder if you are either...Coleman or a Coleman advocate...and more...why the discussion on masturbation? Is this to trauma further...by reminding us that this is the only option left, now that we are too disfigured to get a date? Not to worry, when you are finally locked away in prison...there will "not" be a need for your own masturbation...as I expect you will have many dates. You are beyond any form of rehabilitation.
188 days ago by Coleman Patient [send email]
I think most Coleman victims want the public to know what's going on in order that he lose his license to practice. That is the only way they feel he will stop hurting people.
I also think he needs to be held accountable and punished for what he has done.

Unless you go through what Coleman patients have gone through, you can't begin to understand the harm he's caused. Even the few of us who manage to escape permanent deformation by restoring their faces and are able to move on-we still lack closure. Something is still amiss because we the experience so transforms us in the core. Closure will come only when justice has been served.
186 days ago by Casey [send email]
If anyone has info and experience with removing large lumpy areas of fat (under and above the eyes), please advise of doctor and technique used. Mesotherapy is a bit too risky there. Is there a way to get an image of the area to see exactly where the fat is. If I were to have my eyes "done" would the fat coleman put in be where the surgeon would expect it to be? Really need to get it out, so advise, opinions, and experiences are appreciated.
185 days ago by Coleman Patient [send email]
He usually puts it in the muscle layer below the eyes. Most plastic surgeons will not graft fat directly under the eyes because the skin is thin and lumps are likely to show. In other words most will not graft beyond the area near the cheek bone.
Mesotherapy can work in those areas but the question is, which substance is least risky. Coleman is legally obligated to inform you of where he grafted the fat. Also, you may be able to get a very high resolution MRI and have another plastic surgeon interpret where he put fat in, since many patients complain Coleman is not forthcoming with this vital information.
185 days ago by Casey [send email]
i will schedule consult with surgeon and speak about the high resolution mri. i was thinking if i had blep, they could then remove or re position over grafted fat. what if it is in the muscle? or in the layers of skin, and it can not be cut out? that would become a huge problem. i just do not understand how a
doctor that do es nothing more than this procedure, day in and day out, for years, makes such huge mistatkes.
185 days ago by Casey [send email]
have been reading this site, and i feel that you are wasting your time here. there seems to be writers with stellar skills. this should be in a book. a book that sells in barnes and nobles, a book for the world to see. is that legal? i think he shoud loose his license to touch another. the law will not answer that wish, the media would be a better option. oprah, the morning show, somewhere that a million of people will watch and listen. your postings are so heart felt, they should be read by all. every dog has its day...someone is always watching.
185 days ago by David [send email]
Agreed...these patients have obviously been injured beyond a subjective perception of harm. Them directly addressing Coleman with such volatile emotions--these are not your average unhappy plastic surgery patients. More reminiscent of the victims of rape or assault, or anything akin to severe psychological trauma.
180 days ago by Jeff T. [send email]
From reading the previous entries as well as the title of this website, I realize that this is a complaint board. However, I have some wonderful things to say about Dr. Coleman. Before I begin I will say that I know how angry some of you feel because I also did not like Dr. Coleman for quite sometime. I felt like I overpaid for the work that he did on me and I felt like he made me look swollen. It was not until I went back to Dr. Coleman’s office eight months after my operation for my second set of pictures that I realized that he had done an amazing job on my face. I will say this again, it was not until I went back to Dr. Coleman’s office eight months after my operation for my second set of pictures that I realized that he had done an AMAZING JOB on my face!!!
Honestly, I felt like crap afterwards for hating him and wanting bad things to happen to him. I cannot put to words how much I hated him. I hope that these kind words will make up for any negative energy that I threw his way (I need as much good karma as possible), this is the least I can do. Before I share my story I will let you know that I have not been paid by Dr. Coleman to write positive things about him nor will I get free or reduced surgery from him in the future. I will definitely be getting more surgery from him and have referred him to my mother (who had her hands done), my sister (who had her breasts corrected) and my best friend, who told me about this complaint board. The name I am using is not my real name but what I am telling you is the absolute truth.
I am a 47 year-old male living in Marin County. Two years ago (after a messy divorce) I decided I wanted to do something about the bags underneath my eyes. I wanted to start dating again and I wanted to look my best to attract attractive women. I looked like I was 55 years old. I went to three different plastic surgeons in the Bay area and the third, Dr. Tim Miller, referred me to Dr. Coleman. He had recently seen Dr. Coleman speak at a conference and was impressed with what he had to say and liked his before and after photos. He said that you shouldn’t cut the bags out of the face, but inject fat around them. He met a plastic surgeon and his wife at the same conference that had absolutely amazing work done on them by Dr. Coleman and that I should think about seeing Dr. Coleman. So I went to his office in New York City.
I was amazed with the before and after photos (and looked at them close up to see if they were the real deal). Other that the light and color being matched up on the photos, I am absolutely certain no other thing had been used to doctor the photos (I should know, I do computer animation for the motion picture industry). I met with Dr. Coleman and he assessed my face. I found out that the area above my eye lids also needed to be filled in and that I needed some filling in my jaw and smile line area. The amount he was going to charge was a lot ($45, 000) and they dropped off some money. I thought about the price over the next week and thought about the prices that the other doctor’s had quoted. I figured that if I could spend $76, 000 on a car, $41, 000 on my face is no big deal. Hey, it is my face and I might as well get one of the best plastic surgeons in the world to make it better since I was going to live with it the rest of my life.
I had the surgery done and when they took off the bandages a few days later, I looked very bad. The people in the office had told me that I was going to look bad, but I didn’t think that I was going to look like someone had beaten me up like that. I looked like I was in a bad fight, got into a car wreck and had and allergic reaction.
Luckily, I was able to do the bulk of my office work at my house over the next few months, but I still had to go into work periodically for meetings. I felt very self-conscious because the first day back at the office a number of colleges stopped me and asked what had happened. I told them that I had an allergic reaction to some medication and it was taking a while for the swelling to go down. Again, I felt very self-conscious. Every time I looked in the mirror all I could focus on was the swelling. In hindsight, I was obsessing too much about what I looked like. I think it would have probably been better to have put sheets over all of the mirrors in the house so I wouldn't look at my face.

I wanted to start going on dates, but I couldn’t because felt I looked freaky. After a while I figured out that I did not look as bad if I wore my ski sunglasses, so I wore them all the time when I was out in public, even at night. I became really upset after 6 months because I still felt like I was freaky (actually I was fine). I will say that I accomplished an incredible amount of work the first 6 months. One good thing to come out of this was that I got a major bonus out of spending all that time working from home and not going out as much. But I was not going on too many dates, which was the whole reason for me getting the plastic surgery done in the first place!

At month 8, I had had enough. I was going to Connecticut to visit my parents, so I decided that I was going to drop by Dr. Coleman’s office and see what he could do to fix my swelling, and on his dime. I called the office and made the appointment. I went into the office in the morning and they said that I had to get a second set of pictures taken. I was really mad because I was going to have to wait, but I was a little happy that the fallow up visit and the pictures were free. While waiting in the waiting room I was getting angrier and angrier. The office patient care woman, Peri, drove me crazy with her whiney voice and I really wanted to put some duct tape on her mouth to make her quiet (I recently found out Peri is not working there any more thank God). Luckily, I didn’t have to tape up Peri’s mouth and I met with Dr. Coleman to go over the photos. He showed me the before and after pictures and he explained what he had done to my face and abdomen (where he took out the fat). It was absolutely amazing. I could totally see how he made me better looking. The only thing I can think as to the reason why I even thought the way I did was that I forgot the way that I used to look –right before the surgery. I think that when I was really swollen, I just started focusing on that I was swollen. He showed me close ups of my face and I have to say he has made my skin younger. I look more like the way I was in my 20’s now, than I did when I was in my mid 30’s!!!

For those of you reading this posting that are unhappy, I would suggest going back to Dr. Coleman’s office, getting your pictures taken and sitting down with Dr. Coleman to look over the pictures. I am certain that if he made an error he would step up to the plate and fix the mistakes that he made. He has integrity and I know this because I am an excellent judge of character. For those of you considering plastic surgery from Dr. Coleman, make sure that you go back for follow up pictures, I can almost guarantee you will be happy with the results when you see those before and after pictures.


PS. I just called the NY State Department of Health and checked the website. Dr. Coleman has no reported violations.
180 days ago by Heather Morgan [send email]
Jeff T,




You are a POOR judge of character. You write like a sixth
grader and if after having read all of the previous posts,






your point is that we should all go back to the wonderful Syd Coleman, the bastion of integrity, because you are sure we are just imagining our physical injuries and experiences you
OBVIOUSLY have an agenda, which is to completely ignore






the gravity of our allegations, ignore the graphic and disturbing photographs on the other website, ignore that a large number of people had filed complaints with the NY Department of Health, ignore that CBS went so far as to film and interview injured patients, ignore that many other plastic surgeons disapprove of what he is doing to patients, ignore that throughout all of my posts I've said over and over











that NO ONE IS DENYING THE MULTITUDE OF OUTCOMES POSSIBLY CREATED BY THIS DOCTOR FROM GOOD TO BAD




BUT THAT REGARDLESS OF HOW MANY "GOODS" IT HAS ZERO BEARING ON THE AMOUNT OF SERIOUS "BADS".








Why would anyone with a positive experience with any plastic surgeon recommend those injured by him to go back to him????
If you're happy with his work, TRUST ME WHEN I SAY THE REST OF HIS VICTIMS ARE RELIEVED.



If you're that happy with him, keep seeing him. NO ONE IS STOPPING YOU. NO ONE IS DISAGREEING YOU'RE HAPPY.
180 days ago by Heather Morgan [send email]
By the way it means very little that Coleman doesn't have "reported violations" on record at the NYS Dept. of Health.



So what? Just because a questionable bureaucracy ( what a word! 3 vowels in a row ) didn't do their job properly doesn't mean the mass complaint in 2006 was insignificant. To the contrary, patients were so serious that they went as far as having a very well-respected malpractice attorney represent
their complaints.






For "people" like Jeff T., I would encourage you to volunteer your testimonial for Coleman's goodfatgrafts.com website and since you feel so strongly about what character and skill he has why not post your pictures on his website? I would think that to be the logical thing to do.






In my opinion however, you're just taking up room here. I'm feeling protective of the other complainants on here, some of whom I've gotten to know, at first hoping that I would be of help somehow when in fact it was the opposite.




We are here to help all Coleman patients, whether or not you simply need to fix small areas or whether you went through the whole ugly 9 yards with this and need to talk to someone. You are definitely not alone, you're not crazy, you're not doomed. And don't let anyone make you feel like it. They don't understand, they can't understand.
179 days ago by Jeff T. [send email]
Dear Ms. Morgan,

I did not post on this complaint board to ridicule you, only to offer a solution to your problem. So yes you are right, I did have an agenda in my previous posting and it was to offer a solution to your problem. I do not think you should ignore the problem, but you should try to find a constructive solution to your problem that does not focus on negativity.

I would like to ask if you would please refrain from mocking my writing abilities or on my judgement of other people's character. Remember, people reading these posts are judging you. Your hateful statements directed at other posters diminish your character in everyone's eyes.

You sound hateful, may I suggest taking up Buddhism? I started taking classes in Buddhism a few months after I had my second consult with Dr. Coleman. They have made me a much better person. Today, I focus on finding constructive solutions to problems that do not utilize negative energy. Please try not to dwell on your negative energy or negative thoughts. I promise that negativity will consume you and ruin your life -I have seen it happen too many times. I have seen people loose their marriages (like myself) because they had too much negativity in their thoughts, actions and emotions.

I have worked with CBS and have friends that still work there. I will find out why CBS would not show your interview. In the meantime, look into Buddhism.

Jeff T.
179 days ago by Jeff T. [send email]
Dear Ms. Morgan,

I just called a friend at CBS and he needs to know the name(s) of the reporter(s) that interviewed you. It will make it easier to find out what happened to you piece.

Jeff T.
179 days ago by Heather Morgan [send email]
Jeff,

You may want to step down from your self-righteous high horse before instructing others about Buddhism and negativity.

Was it you who said you couldn't stand Peri because of her "whiney" voice and wanted to put duct tape over her mouth? I find that sort of aggression towards someone who has NOT mutilated you more negative by leaps and bounds than rightfully and albeit bluntly expressing anger and angst towards someone who seriously and maliciously violated another.

If you haven't intuited from my "mocking" of you that I don't even believe you're a real patient with a sincere agenda to try to help us, well, now you know.

I doubt anyone who has suffered at the hands of Coleman needs your help at all, the least of which is to go back to Coleman because as you stated, he's a doctor of integrity and you can almost GUARANTEE he will fix the problem?

ARE YOU KIDDING ME? For your information many of us did in fact go back to him and he wanted to charge and arm and a leg, no pun intended, to perform yet more Lipostructure to disguise the asymmetry and lumps he created.

Everything I've written on these boards is to share my experience so that people can be informed of how unscrupulous this doctor is, and to support others who have been hurt by him. I find it very interesting you can't shut up about how negative my posts are and how I need Buddhism, yet you CAN completely ignore the very content and reason of this negativity---Coleman's criminal actions against his patients.

Your agenda is to try to paint patients injured by him as hateful, negative irrational. Those who care to read the entire comments section know otherwise because if they care to read and confirm what I'm saying and even investigating on their own, THEY KNOW I'M NOT A LIAR. So nice try, but try again my friend.

By the way, I would suggest you learn about Buddhism yourself before you recommend it to others. Much of the philosophy is based on compassion, ethics and logic.

For you to dismiss patient experiences as percieved injuries is not very compassionate. Neither is your attempt to write his injured patients off as just hateful, negative people. It's not very ethical to enthusiasticlly support a doctor who is the epittamy of amorality and makes a joke out of medical ethics. All of these indicate to me a less than logical thinking process and attempt on your part, which further indicates you would probably fail at understanding Buddhism. Hateful, violent urges to want to duct tape women are characteristic of misogynistic sociopaths, so funny you should mention that.
That sort of hatefulness, according to Buddhism, comes from fear, greed and ignorance.

One thing strikes me as logical for someone to try to repair their reputation:

1) First try to drown out the truth by posting your good testimonials over and over, hoping to plant some doubt as to what we're saying.

That doesn't work

2) Post a confusing, offensive piece on "girls and masturbation" to make readers think this complaints board is nothing but a random hodge podge of crazy patients, patients defending Coleman, and anonymous lunatics to further discredit the truth.

That doesn't work

3) Get someone to post a very smarmy, lengthy account of how yes, he agrees he went through a similar ordeal during the swelling phase and "hated" Coleman, but that eventually he loved it and recognized his folly in questioning such a man of integrity-------------------Promotion of Coleman by partially acknowledging what his injured patients have been writing about him so as to get a stamp of legitimacy and not alienate readers, most of whom at this point, I would surmise don't believe Coleman's not up to it again.

Ah, very sneaky indeed, but like I said, try again.

What's the step 4 going to be?

A reminder of where you're at now remember? You are posting as this sincere person who is calling his friends at CBS---WOW! What a striking coincidence!! You have friends working for them and just HAPPEN to be so interested that you want me to give out their names...and you're just a lil ole patient from Marin County who had a good result?

So then why don't YOU go investigate and see what you come up with because we're already doing our own "thing" and don't need to prove it to an anonymous writer.

Anyone can write anything, and I've emphasized DON'T BELIEVE ME...GOOGLE IT, GO TO THE COURTS, VERIFY FOR YOURSELF.

To be continued...
179 days ago by Jeff T. [send email]
Ms. Morgan,

It is obvious you are an angry person, I was an angry person as well. Controlling my anger is something that I constantly have to work on. I can honestly say that if you were to study the way of Buddha and make a conscious effort to control your anger, you will find inner-peace. It is hard at first, but it really works.

Am I proud to that my old-self wanted to tape up some one's mouth? Not at all. That was my old self and I can not change the past -but I can be living in the present and working on reshaping my future.

The offer still stands. I have done work for CBS, I still have contacts there and I can find out the reason why your piece did not air.

JT
179 days ago by Sandy Hanna [send email]
I disagree with all of your comments, I am sorry that "Some" of you had a horrible experience, but to me i feel he is A very good doctor and he is Very highly recommended!..I have done my cheeks my eyes, my lips with dr coleman and i will say that I get nothing but compliments, very naturel..again every doctor has unhappy customers, and I am sure if you are not happy, dr coleman will help you..But very mean to come on here and degrade a doctor that is Wonderful!!..thank you
178 days ago by Heather Morgan [send email]
Jeff,



Your patronizing attempt to contiously peg me as nothing but an angry hateful person is so transparent it's boring.


Jeff, what about more important points I've brought up, which you are not even commenting on at all.

Strange...What do you think of what Coleman did to Maureen ( Patient AA on www.fatgraft-support-group.com )? Would you like to contact her and tell her yourself that all she needs to do is go back to Coleman and you're sure that this man of integrity will do his best to fix her grossly deformed body and face?


As I said, try again. The information in my posts are really not about me. They are about what Coleman has been doing to his patients, which I find very telling that you keep ignoring again and again but you can't stop talking about me.




What about Patient DD on that website? Would you like to contact her and tell her Sydney Coleman is a man of integrity?
After all, we all know that plastic surgeons of integrity commonly draw genitalia on their patients and photograph them naked, then sedate them completely against their will. Why don't you tell her all she needs to do is go back to Coleman? She went to the SEX CRIMES UNIT of the DISTRICT ATTORNEY to complain about Dr. Coleman. Silly woman, why would she do that when Dr. Coleman is such a nice man?



Really, your personal attacks don't deserve a response because it's intended to detract away from Coleman's actions.



What offer? You said you used to work at CBS? Wow, and you still have friends who work there? If this were true you wouldn't need to ask me would you? Please stop insulting the intelligence of the readers.
178 days ago by Corey Taylor Clegg [send email]
Heather, These patients with "great experiences"...have not thanked anyone here...for having endured the experiments Coleman did on everyone... to gain the experience to make them look so fine. Ingrates I say, self-centered ingrates.

Let it go, forget them. Personally? if I were to have read such horrific testimonials on Coleman...even if I felt pleased with my own results? I would step back and stay out of it. I would never meddle in this mess. There is something amiss here. The devotion is a little twisted...considering there are pictures posted...of Coleman mutilations.

Not to worry, the average reader gets it...and "The Coleman Devotees" do not get it...that everyone gets it, nor does Coleman. It's like a sadistic little tea cup doggie, going after a German Shepard under sedation and too stupid to know...he is now out matched...because the Shepard has come out of being anesthetized and gained the strength to stand up and defend itself.

Heather, you are brilliant...in mind and heart! :)
178 days ago by Sandy Hanna [send email]
There are so many clients that fly from different cities and countries!!..IF it wasnt for Dr coleman i would never be able to look in the mirror, after a doctor in michigan performed surgery on me, I searched and searched for a doctor, but Dr coleman came highly recommended, he changed my life!!!. he is the best in my eyes and many others.. My last comment is I am sorry that you are upset, I have never had a Bad result, i have had 4 procedures with him, HE IS THE BEST DOCTOR ..my last comment is, Sit with him, talk with him, I am sorry you are upset..take care
178 days ago by Heather Morgan [send email]
Victims of Sydney Reese Coleman can be seen at



WWW. fatgraft-support-group.com


Patient AA : Maureen, who had NOT consented to
what was done to her

Patient DD: Penis Marking made by Sydney Coleman


NO ONE IS DENYING THE MULTITUDE OF OUTCOMES POSSIBLY CREATED BY THIS DOCTOR FROM GOOD TO BAD




BUT THAT REGARDLESS OF HOW MANY "GOODS" IT HAS ZERO BEARING ON THE AMOUNT OF SERIOUS "BADS".




1) First try to drown out the truth by posting your good testimonials over and over, hoping to plant some doubt as to what we're saying.

That doesn't work

2) Post a confusing, offensive piece on "girls and masturbation" to make readers think this complaints board is nothing but a random hodge podge of crazy patients, patients defending Coleman, and anonymous lunatics to further discredit the truth.

That doesn't work

3) Get someone to post a very smarmy, lengthy account of how yes, he agrees he went through a similar ordeal during the swelling phase and "hated" Coleman, but that eventually he loved it and recognized his folly in questioning such a man of integrity-------------------Promotion of Coleman by partially acknowledging what his injured patients have been writing about him so as to get a stamp of legitimacy and not alienate readers, most of whom at this point, I would surmise don't believe Coleman's not up to it again.

4) Try to discredit patients by ranting on and on about their unwarranted anger towards Coleman and angrily insisting they need Buddhism.

That doesn't work...

Let me see what other cards left, that will try to be played. Left with fewer and fewer options here. There will be more and more positive posts praising Coleman, yet with not one mention of the questions I've already posed to Jeff.


And, it wouldn't surprise me if outright unfactual information will be posted as well, information that CANNOT be verified by neutral sources. Coleman already did that last year by stating a LIE on his website, "The picture of Patient DD (penis picture) is unsubstantiated and is not part of public record"...Yeah it is.

This is getting quite redundant and I think I've said my piece.
Readers aren't stupid so be my guest to fill the rest of these pages with "good testimonials", non-sensical psychotic promoting of Buddhism, and whatever else. Insignificant, really.


Patients can contact me still by email.

Corey, I'm blessed to have met you, you have my support, and I look forward to the next chapter. Smiling.
178 days ago by Ellenbogen Victim [send email]
I was mutilated and deformed by Richard Ellenbogen of Beverly Hills Body. I believe that many plastic surgeons are greedy, unethical, skilless sociopaths who enjoy ruining people's bodies' faces and lives.
It's just a disgrace that America has such low standards for doctors.

Previous | 1...4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12...29 | Next

Post your Comment

Please check text spelling before submitting comment
Your Name
Your E-Mail Address
Your E-mail is invisible to others
Your attitude towards ComplaintAgree Neutral Disagree
Comment text
Confirmation code

Search

Videos

Fireworks and Kids Safety

Categories

   - Roofing
   - Banks
   - Loans
   - Car Rental
   - Mattresses
   - Cosmetics
   - Appliances
   - Ebay Scams
   - Phishing
   - Timeshares

Smile upon Life :)


RSS Feed
 
India Consumer Complaints Forum
Pateretaju sudzibas
Caller Information, Unsoliceted Phone Calls