The Locksmith 'Mafia': Making an Estimate You Can't Refuse
Share July 18, 2007 8:51 AM
Mike Mitchell Reports:
A New York City-based locksmith business has been squeezing out competitors and fleecing customers across the country, drawing nationwide outrage from consumers and professionals alike, according to the Council of Better Business Bureaus (CBBB).
The CBBB, a non-profit organization that provides information on businesses to the public, told the Blotter on ABCNews.com that Dependable Locksmith is the most notorious of a number of "bully" locksmith companies known by some as "the locksmith mafia."
A CBBB reliability report about Dependable Locksmith asserts the company advertises in cities across the U.S., using addresses that appear local but are often non-existent. According to the CBBB, dispatchers in these areas pose as independently-run neighborhood locksmiths, and their late arrivals, unmarked vans, excessive fees and insistence on cash-only payments mark the modus operandi of the organization.
Locksmiths as far as Denver "are literally afraid" to speak out against these companies because of their tactics, said Susan Liehe, spokesperson for the Denver BBB.
Liehe added, "These sole-proprietor locksmiths are introverted, insanely ethical people who regard this whole operation with apprehension, resentment and fear. When I spoke with them, they couldn't get off the phone quickly enough."
The attorneys general of Illinois and Ohio sued Dependable Locksmith in December 2005 and June 2006, respectively, for repeated alleged violations of laws concerning consumer protection and deceptive business practices.
The Ohio attorney general's case is currently pending. The company was ordered to pay $2,875 in fines and cease its false advertising as a result of the Illinois attorney general's case, according to the CBBB.
"On the phone, they said it would cost $35 to unlock my car," said Carol Pintar of Oak Creek, Wis. "The guy showed up wanting to get paid first, but said $35 was just for coming out. He wanted another $95 to open the door."
According to Pintar, when she came up short, the locksmith offered her a ride in his car to find an ATM. She declined, and the locksmith ultimately accepted a cash payment of $95 total -- all the money Pintar had with her.
As of today, the CBBB reliability report for Dependable Locksmith shows more than 100 complaints filed within the last year. Only 12 have been fully resolved.
Dependable Locksmith did not return repeated phone calls from ABC News seeking comment.
Click Here for Full Blotter Coverage.
July 18, 2007 | Permalink | User Comments (11)
User Comments
Extortion, what's the FBI doing, it crosses State line.
Posted by: marc | Jul 18, 2007 9:24:50 AM
I've seen an operation like this in action before. I locked my keys in my car out near a motocross track. The phone book had several listings and I began calling them. Spoke to the first one, the operator told me a guy would be on his way in a little while. Called the second listing. Different number, different address. THE SAME WOMAN ANSWERED THE PHONE THAT I HAD JUST SPOKEN TO!!! I tried another listing. again, different number, different address. SAME WOMAN ANSWERED AGAIN!!!!!
Posted by: Matt | Jul 18, 2007 10:15:43 AM
How is this newsworthy?
Typical ABC reported nonsense.
Posted by: NYC-er | Jul 18, 2007 3:16:20 PM
I'm a locksmith in southern Arizona & I find this article very depressing! 99% of Locksmiths take great pride in their work and often we open cars, homes and offices for free. You're there to help someone out of a jam and often times when you do it for free or half price folks will call you up later for other work. All good Locksmiths NEVER charge to open a car with a pet or child locked in, it's part of the code. Most of us charge a "trip charge" (most times under $40) to show up and figure out what the cost will be to complete the service. If someone doesn't like the price at that point we smile and wave the trip charge. Bottom line, speak with your locksmith on the phone to get an understanding of the fees we charge...most times we'll be happy to come out and give a quote for free. I hope the 1% of bad apples don't sour the rest of us. Thanks :)
Posted by: Jeffery | Jul 18, 2007 5:22:42 PM
hey jeffery... this article **sticks up** for you and your fellow "proud" locksmiths, and it **separates** you from the "bad apples" ... its doin you a favor. you serious?
Posted by: literate | Jul 18, 2007 5:50:17 PM
Dear NYC-er,
With all due respect, you couldn't be more wrong. This is one nationwide scam that definitely deserves attention. I learned one basic thing from this article: if I get locked out of my car, I'm calling someone I trust--not these hooligans.
Posted by: News | Jul 18, 2007 5:51:38 PM
Dear nyc-er. I would like to say that this is a very news worthy story. I would bet that you are probably involved with one of these companies.
Thank you Mike Mitchell for a well done story. I hope you do followups on this one. It is much more sinister than most people know.
67 year old Ray Miller of streamwood IL was physically pushed and forced to pay 1710.00 to have his lock drilled open when he was locked out from a dependable locksmith employee. He was arressted and pled guilty.
These people are mostly Israeli nationals here on tourist visas and are not even supposed to be working. They have shown much disregard for the laws and authoritys her in Illinois.
Posted by: Mike Bronzell | Jul 21, 2007 2:08:00 AM
Matt, You haven't got a clue or at Mike said, you are one of them. These people rip-off hundreds, if not thousands of people and ruin locks to open them. They then charge many times the retail price for a junk lock to replace the ones they ruin. If you are not one of them, I hope you don't become one of their victims.
As for the fines they are charged when they are caught, they are a joke. One of their rip-off jobs will pay any fine.
Posted by: Autolockman | Jul 21, 2007 11:34:19 AM
These people are not LOCKSMITHS.. QUIT calling them locksmiths. They are imposters. If and when you see a man impersonating a police officer do you call him a cop. NO!!! So QUIT calling this scam artist locksmiths
Posted by: G.W. NULL | Jul 21, 2007 11:51:42 AM
I agree with Autolockman. These guys sure are as hell not locksmiths. Around my area, we refer to them as "drillsmiths". I'm a locksmith myself, and people like this are an embarassment to us all. If a "locksmith" shows up to a job in a car, then he's not a locksmith. If a "locksmith" shows up to a job with no equipment in his van, then he's not a locksmith. I can blame comsumers for these guys too. If the consumer refuses to pay these outrageous "fees", and call the authorities when these so called "locksmiths" try to extort them, they might already be out of business. If it's an emrtgency, contact the authorties. They will point you in the direction of a reliable locksmith.
Posted by: Shaolin912 | Jul 21, 2007 7:38:03 PM
Shaolin912,
I agree with you that a locksmith should show up with necessary tools and equipment, but how does the body style of his vehicle determine whether or not he is a locksmith? Please explain.
Posted by: Paul Leys | Jul 21, 2007 9:13:17 PM
Feedback| Wireless| E-mails & News Alerts| Message Boards| RSS Headlines| Podcasts| ABC News Store
Contact Us| ABC.com| Site Map| Advertising Info| Terms of Use| UPDATED Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights
External links are provided for reference purposes. ABC News is not responsible for the content of external internet sites. Copyright © 2007 ABCNews Internet Ventures |