I had the same type of check and same Payee for $34.99. I have never been a Mary Kay consultant, but I am a Creative Memories consultant and this is my business account (less than 10-12 transactions per month). I have used Mary Kay, but not with this account. I believe CM and Mary Kay may use the same payment processing (it seems that CM mimics many of the MK business models...including the web sites they use) system, so perhaps this is a hacking/server loss issue. I called the number on the check and they "said" they would reverse the charges, but 8 days later the number is "no longer in service." I will be calling my bank and hopefully they will correct the problem.
Thanks to Complaints Board for allowing me to find out this information!