John Ashford shirts / Poor Quality of product

I bought 6 John Ashford long-sleeve shirts at Macy's right after Thanksgiving for a new job. I should have suspected something since they were on sale for $9.99 each. I wore each shirt once and then washed per directions. When I went to wear them a second time each sleeve was almost a 1/4 inch shorter! I thought maybe I washed them improperly and it caused them to shrink. However, in the same washload I washed 2 new Calvin Kline shirts and they came out fine. The sleeves are still at their original length. These Ashford shirts are now garbage or something I can only wear under a sweater. The poor quality of these shirts are an embarassment. I will also be taking this up with Macy's.