Choice Home Warranty
reviews and complaints

Worst warranty company ever. Run away from them. Won’t honor high dollar item repairs. This the second time they are trying to get out of repairs. And in each case there was issues with the tech they sent out, when it’s in your favor. Supposedly the tech didn’t submit claim correctly, yet I called the tech back and I’m given a different story how Choice drag their feet to prolong agony in hopes the client gives in to fixing it themselves. Watch out this is a dishonest company. I been without hot water for nearly 7 days because they needed tech to resubmit pictures, which he clearly said he sent showing a pan full of water indicating a broken unit. How petty sad part is I’m a retired military vet. Sad but true. Evertime I call and ask for manager, I’m placed on hold and mysteriously the phone hangs up, also I’m always conversing with a person with foreign accent and other agents in the background. What a scam. Place call on 10 May 2022 and today May 16th. Wow! Can’t shower, wash dishes, or clothes.

I wish to cancel this policy it does not fit my needs I have no use for your service drop me immediately don't need nothing else but cancelation of the service.

Thank you

William C Jenkins

On Monday, May 9, 2022, we submitted a service request to have A/C repaired. The A/C technician was available the next day. He explained the problem and that it was fixable and reported this to the company. They denied the claim because they said there was dirt in the fan and motor because 1) we didn't have a filter or 2) the filter was dirty, causing the fan to break. They also said the motor was seized, but it wasn't. Our claim was denied via email late in the evening. All of this happened on Tuesday.

On Wednesday, I initiated the appeal process described in the email to get someone to look at the claim again. We were assigned a Case Manager, provided a phone number and a link to a webpage to schedule an appointment with the Case Manager. I could also call the Case Manager (which I did) and leave a message. No one returned my call. I called Customer Service to find out if there was an update to my service request. No update. I repeated all of these steps again on Thursday. Still no change.

When I indicated I wanted to cancel the contract, I was transferred to a mitigation specialist. His tone and approach felt like he was bullying me into retaining the contract. After 45 minutes of listening to him tell me I was making an emotional decision, he finally cancelled my contract and hurriedly told me the reimbursement details in 20 seconds. I had him repeat the details slower for my benefit. Why was he angry that I was canceling the contract?!?!

We paid for the repair and chose a different Home Warranty Company. We will never recommend or use Choice Home Warranty again.

In March 2022, I filed a claim for a leaking water heater with Choice Home Warranty. Within hours, ON THEIR WEBSITE, the name of one contractor to

do the repair showed up. Only One! I explained the leaking issue and sent pictures to the replying contractor. The contractor gave me a quote and that they could be at my residence the next day. However, they told me that Choice was a very slow payer for contractors and they requested that I pay upfront. I called Choice and the agent that I spoke to told me that I had to go with them or no one since they were the only contractors that replied in a timely manner for my water issue. I paid the fee and the water heater was installed. Now Choice is telling me that they will reimburse me a partial amount (their Good Will) as I wasn't supposed to pay. On my call, I asked what alternative did I have? A wet and moldy laundry room if the heater burst? Why list a contractor on your site that a customer would think you stand behind? I am now out $850.

I have had contracted with multiple home warranty companies over the last 35 years and choice home warranty is by far the absolute worst one we have contracted with. They rarely have somebody available and when they do the issue is either not covered, nor fixed properly. We own rental property and need to have a home warranty company that we can count on. That company is not choice home warranty. If they don't have anybody available, they say you can hire somebody else to fix it as long as they are licensed and submit an estimate of the repairs, but the multiple times we have been forced to take this route, chw has found some excuse to deny the claim because not all of the i's were dotted or t's crossed. I can count on less than one hand the times that chw has actually resolved an issue for us in over a year or more.

This latest issue was the final straw. We had an issue with a leaky toilet that we submitted a claim and service request for. I was pleasantly surprised that I received notice that chw schedule a repair company, only to find out after sitting around for 6 hours and calling the repair company chw dispatched, that the company d0es not do any business with chw. After talking to multiple persons at chw, I ws finally able to cancel my service and get a partial refund of services we had paid for and never received. Stay as far away from chw as you can.

I filed my first claim for a/c service during the summer of 2020 - the technician stated the unit need to be replaced and sent photos to the company. I received a notification that the necessary repairs would be made but I would be required to pay at least $1400 out of pocket and possibly more. I was on a fixed income and could not afford this sudden expense. I complained to the resolutions department to no avail, so I let the contract lapse. I was contacted repeatedly to renew my contract. I finally spoke with a representative in January of 2021 who assured me that there were new policies in place and that my claim would be covered 100%, so I agreed to a new contract. I was advised to wait until the weather was warmer to re-file the claim and did so in May 2021. While the previous year's approved claim stated the unit was to be replaced, the new technician stated the problem was electrical so I filed a claim for that and the circuit breaker was changed by another technician. When the problem was not corrected, another technician was sent to re-evaluate the unit. After dismantling the unit, he also stated to me that it needed to be replaced and submitted his report for approval. The claim was was then declined for "pre-existing conditions" and also because the photos sent this time showed vegetation growth on the unit, which the company deemed was the cause of the breakdown of the unit. After expediting my complaint this time, I was told I had no recourse. I let the contract lapse again.

Put a claim om an applanice april 2022 contactor came out order parts then canceled the next appt because the parts cant not be found its been 6 weeks and the claim has not been taken care of! 6 week need refridertor! Can not get anywhere with calling the office. Want it taken car of right now!

What it is that you people dont understand about needing a refridgetor! You need to repect your customers and take care of the problem

submitted a claim concerning my dishwasher not working 4/5/22. A technician came and said he had to order parts. Your company scheduled an appointment for technician to come back. By the end of the day, I called and he said parts haven't come in yet. Now, technician will not answer calls. His mailbox is full. You have said for 3 weeks now that a supervisor would call back. And no one will call back or resolve this matter. I will go to small claims court as it only costs 60.00 to file. Also we are senior citizens and this is fraud against a senior which is a very serious claim. Please have someone with authority call me back ASAP.

[protected]. Looking at 938 complaints against your company, it is apparent that you do not care.

I paid up front for a 6 year "total" plan, thought I got a good deal back in April 2019. I couldn't be more wrong after 3 years. The exclusion list is long and wide, few issues are due to normal wear and tear and are covered. If you're considering home warranty, definitely do NOT use Choice Home Warranty.

Before I switched to Choice Home Warranty, I had no issues to have compressor replaced by another home warranty company (the price kept going up fast so I switched company) or had my water heater replaced.

Also, if you decide to cancel after the 1st 30 days, you need to pay ALL repair cost you incurred, plus premium and transaction fee for cancellation.

Placed a claim for my Home Warranty to Choice for an inoperative A/C unit. Technician came out four days later an informed me it was a thermostat wire that needed to be replaced. The wire would need to be run from the condenser to the unit in the attic. Choice immediately denied my claim stating that the cause was not normal wear and tear. I have been in my home since 2008 and have had Choice at $40 and ultimately $53 a month since 2017. How would they know? I had another technician (non Choice affiliated) look at the issue and he stated I needed to replace the system at a cost of $7200.00. This has to stop. It has to be pretty close to white collar crime and it time Congress does something. I will draft a letter to my Congressman and the Attorney General in my State and have my peers in the Federal Government do the same. This company should be placed on a barment list for military and government personnel. I will also place an article on consumer affairs and any other platform that will let folks know that this is a scam. Claim #[protected]. I learned the company is run out of a hotel room and really is not interested in resolving complaints. I have had success with another Home Warranty Service my using the Consumer Affairs complaint process. I will seek redress with them as well. I have checked with BBB and they have thousands of complaints with them as well.

My contract ends 7/9/23.

Account [protected]

I put in a service call on 4/15/22 to repair my broken toilet and leaking toilet. A technician came on 4/25/22 around 2:45pm. I had not received an approval so I called 4/27/22 to find out why and they say he no longer works here. Nevertheless; someone should have call me and explained they were assigning another technician.

A technician comes out on Monday, 5/2/22; now I get approval but I have to pay almost $700.00 because I only have $500.00 left on my plan. I don't understand this. I paid the first technician the agreed contract amount for coming out. I shouldn't have to pay anything more. This is the purpose of having the maintenance agreement.

I purchased a 5year plan; I have only had a few minor repairs over this span. My repairs surely did not add up to the cost I paid for this plan.

I would like someone to call me and explain this and why it's taken almost 2 weeks to get the toilets on a list for repair.

Unsatisfied customer

I have an 8-year-old Kitchenaid dishwasher cost around $1200 --service tech came out and needs a new motherboard --next thing I get an email from Choice Home Warranty saying congratulations were going to replace your dishwasher and we will send you a lowes gift card to cover the cost -- i opened it up and i saw their replacement amount --$246-- i could not even replace the door for that amount ---now a case manager has been assigned and she won't take calls or return emails and you are forced to make an appointment for a phone call --(may 9th) This is the way the company operates hoping you will get frustrated enough to just accept their lousy offer

Contract #[protected]

The salesman who renewed my warranty should be disciplined, retrained, or fired.

On his call, he rudely kept pitching alternate plans. I've been a customer for a year not, and have never used the service. So, I really don't know the quality of Choice Customer Service, why would I pay for 3 years. He finally just hung up on me, when I said I only wanted one year. No thank you, or other acknowledgement of the order.

At that point, I didn't know if the sale even went through. I had to check my credit card to see how much, or, if I was even charged. I was charged for one year.

Bottom line, your sales approach is highly irritating, and the salesman was extremely rude.

Steve Bougon

I was a service provider for Choice Home Warranty and I went to service calls for this company at my expenses I provided parts and labor along with using gas to travel to the customers locations for six months or more and never received payment for not one service call. I called the accounting department and they told me that it was being paid but I never received payment for my service. I preformed over 20 service calls still no payment for service

We are a service provider for Choice Home Warranty company . Since January 2022 till March 2022 we have over 62 jobs/invoices that are unpaid or partially paid, plus a number of invoices they deliberately deleted from their system completely . Choice Home Warranty authorized to complete repair for a certain amount, gave authorization codes to proceed , we would go and complete repair / install parts in customer’s residence , and then weeks after job is completed and we are awaiting on the payment as per amount they initially authorized , they would “adjust” amount without notifying , or sometimes completely remove invoice from their portal as if it never existed ( when repair was completed weeks prior); deduct some made up deductions (f.i $65 for being late to customer , which was never part of contract ) ; or simply state on their portal “repair unsuccessful” and mark it $0 weeks after job was completed . Without any proof - they just state that not to pay . They adjust every single invoice and refuse to honor their own prior authorized amounts. Extent of such adjusting is one of the invoices got adjusted to $5 from $360 and they only paid $5 .

As of April 1 , 2022 they put our account on hold for 180 days and said no payments would be released . Advised to get back after 180 days wait is over and then ask for payment . Their payment terms are 30-45 business days . But they state our account was disabled for “poor performance” and 180 days wait isn’t negotiable . When they kept sending us to about 70 of their clients our performance was not poor and was perfectly acceptable. But once we started complaining and asking for full payments on the invoices , Choice came up with “poor performance and stats “ excuse! They keep transferring from department to department , each agent says different story , but in the end nothing gets resolved. One of them said he was a manager and assured once they receive updated license and insurance they would remove the hold . Turned out to be a lie , same agent two days after said payment won’t be released ! At this point they said we have to wait 180 days and then ask for payment again.

We reached back to customers and told them Choice didn’t pay invoices and they would have to pay instead or liens will be put on their houses . Customers would reach out to Choice and choice would tell them not to pay us and Choice would take care of balances and while they are lying to customers and assuring them they will take care of the issue , they are simultaneously putting our account on hold and freezing all payments due for 180 days ! Fraud and dishonesty.

CHW owes us over $19000 as per their authorized amounts . Their authorizations mean nothing . Once service call is completed and part is installed in customers’ residences, they wait several weeks and then slash previously authorized amount in more than half or just mark it “unsuccessful” and turn your invoice into $0 .

I was sold a Choice home warranty which covered 4 years of service, from 2020 to 2024. Since starting this contract, I have made 3 claims, all plumbing related, and all claims denied. In the first case, the plumber came in, tore up my drywall, found that it was a leak in the tub, and the claim was denied, and my drywall was NOT repaired. the second time, was for a hot water heater, which they denied because my heater is 80 gallons, and they have a limit of 75 gallons. I even tried to negotiate to replace mine with a 75 gallon, and denied. the third was a clogged drain for my washer. The cleanout is on the roof, so they denied that claim. In all three cases, I had to pay $65 service fee to be told i was denied. So, in summary, I paid $1350 for 4 years of service, plus 3 service fees of $65, and they have paid $0 toward any of my repairs, which they claim they cover when they sell you this warranty. I called to get a refund, and even though I am just at the 2 year mark, they are only offering to refund me 27% of my original payment.

4/19/2022, 11:05 am

I made a claim about my front load washer few weeks ago and after 3 weeks of waiting the claim person stated that she is offering me a whole sale value to replace my broken washer because no parts for this washer. She was not very nice and arrogant, and acted smart by reading me what is in the contract which In the contract it states less than retail not whole sale. With inflation as high now it is very expensive to buy a washer with the price they offered.

We are a small handyman and home repair company that is just starting out. We have been actively advertising and getting our name out there, which so far has served us well. We received a call from someone at Choice Home Warranty asking if we could handle a service call. They asked a few basic questions about our company and we did the same. It seemed like the start to what would be a great business relationship. NOT! We have done several jobs and have yet to get paid. We have been told repeatedly that our payments were held because they hadn't received our signed application. We sent everything to them, repeatedly. We have paid several thousand dollars out of pocket for equipment and materials to repair or replace items for their customers and have all of the authorization numbers and WO #s to match. Still no payments. We were even told over the phone that they were sending a payment right then for an after hours approval. Still no payments. Now we are being told that there is a licensing issue and cannot get paid. At no point was this explained or sent to us. It wasn't until I went to their website like a new vendor signing up did I find their terms and conditions. I wonder how upset the customers will be when we repo hot water heaters since Choice Home Warranty won't pay their bills?

At the beginning of our third year with Choice in Sept 2021 the a/c went out. We were told no one could come out for a week. With 90+ degree temp we contacted another contractor. They replaced the capasitor and a switch. It was $160. We submitted a claim for reimbursement which was denied because we didn't obtain prior approval. We then sent email to cancel the policy and refund the premium. We received an email reply that the cancellation request was being sent to the appropriate dept., etc. A few weeks later my disabled sister, Lisa fell and broke her hip and was in rehab until Oct 30th. This refund fell off our radar until Dec/Jan. We paid out of pocket for other repairs. I resent Sept email for refund with all attachments and received the same reply. In March, Lisa called to get the status of the refund and was told they needed a copy of the invoice we paid for the a/c repair. We did not send it again since it had been denied. Then Choice sent a check for $100 to my home address. It has not be cashed as we expect a refund of the annual premium of about $600. 4/12/22, I called to inquire about the refund and was told Lisa had verbally accepted settlement of the a/c claim for $100 which she denied. They said they had a verbal recording but couldnt play it for us. I have documentation of our written cancellation from Sept 2021.

I was a Plumbing service vendor for Choice Home Warranty in central Ohio for the Months of Jan 2021 to March 2022 . The first few small jobs were invoiced and paid in 30+ days. But , after that my work order volume increased and I did about 6 water heater replacements and a large volume of work orders, one including a 75 gallon power vented unit that I provided. Long story short a total of $11,000 was invoiced and I woke up to a frozen account showing all payments on hold for a undisclosed amount of time. Im still in shock and looking into options for payment. I would never recommend doing service for this company.