Menu

The good, the bad, and the ugly - discover what customers are saying about GoldFellow.com

Welcome to our customer reviews and complaints page for GoldFellow.com. We understand that making informed decisions about where to invest your time and money can be challenging, which is why we've created this platform for our community to share their honest feedback about their experiences with GoldFellow.com.

On this page, you'll find a comprehensive collection of reviews and complaints from real customers who have used GoldFellow.com's products or services. Our reviews are authentic and unbiased, providing you with a complete picture of the company, its products or services, and their customer service.

Whether you're considering doing business with GoldFellow.com, or you've already had an experience with them, our community's reviews and complaints will give you a valuable perspective on what to expect. Our goal is to help you make informed decisions about where to invest your time and money, and we hope that our platform will be a valuable resource for you.

Please feel free to browse our reviews and complaints and share your own experience with GoldFellow.com. Your feedback is an important part of our community and will help others make informed decisions.

ComplaintsBoard
J
11:58 am EST
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

GoldFellow.com Low Pricing

As someone who has done gold parties, and used goldfellow in the begining- while they didn't ever scam me or steal from me- their pricing is very low. They post on their website today that they are paying $14.69 per pennyweight for 14K. MANY websites are paying lower, but MANY legitimate websites are paying more in the $17.00-$18.00 range. On top of that- most top level jewelry stores- if you do your homework will pay you more in your local area. I just sold some 14K to a local jeweler for $22 a pennyweight! I have learned, sending Gold over the internet to anyone doesn't make a whole lot of sense because, if you call around locally, you can get more- quite quickly. Goodfellow is better than cash4gold who are absolutely ripping people with their pricing, but it makes no sense to sell to goldfellow as they are paying less than you can get elsewhere. That's the bottom line I would think- how much can you get payed for your gold. Do a little research, wherever you are, and you can get much more selling it locally or to other places...

My other complaint about this website and others though- is everyone claims to be the highest paying buyer in the country-- none of them are...

Read full review of GoldFellow.com
Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
M
8:47 am EST

GoldFellow.com Responding to False charge

My complaint refers to a post on your site regarding our company, GoldFellow.com. Below is my response to Amy, who made these false accusations.

Hello Amy,

I am the founder of GoldFellow and would like to respond to your malicious post. I found your comments to be interesting to say the least. Please provide me your customer number to identify who you are.

Regarding your charges:
1) GoldFellow provides real time tracking, something you would know if you tracked your package
2)EVERY package received is graded and settlement posted the same day as it arrives.
3) There are no "Male Supervisors" employeed at GoldFellow or any other supervisors.
4)If a customer declines our offer we return their valuables via Fedex immediately, therfore providing tracking.

I certainly could be mistaking, but my guess is you are likely one of our competitors attempting to discredit us rather than provide the quality service and honest pricing that GoldFellow prides itself.

You are welcome to contact me directly to discuss this further.

Sincerely,

Michael H Gusky
President
GoldFellow

Read full review of GoldFellow.com and 2 comments
Hide full review
2 comments
Add a comment
M
M
Ms. Ali
Lockport, US
May 09, 2009 9:25 am EDT

Hello once again,
I have to make a correction on my first comment! I WAS NOT AWARE THAT DIAMONDS DID NOT INCREASE THE VALUE OF CASH OFFERED! I had stated that I was aware of it in my prior comments. I feel it is important to make that clear. Actually, I should have prove read it better than I did. Thank you for your patience and understanding. Everyone have a Blessed day!
Sincerely,
Ms. Ali

M
M
Ms. Ali
Lockport, US
May 09, 2009 9:18 am EDT

Hello to all,
I did not find anything bad about GoldFellow during my search for the reliability of this company. I have sent my gold and diamonds off to them. I was aware that diamonds did not increase the value of the cash offered. I found out after I sent them off; Yet I do have full faith in the honesty of the founder. I like the fact, he responded to the claim that was made by Amy! That in itself tells me alot. I have tracked my package with information that was provided by GoldFellow. I have not found a flaw in what they said they would do for me as the customer yet! If the BBB can give them an A-, they are not easy to give a thumb up, let alone such a high score to a company that is scamming people. As for now, I will say that I am pleased with the service. But there is one problem I do have: The program GoldView, it is a site that I think has some program problems within itself. I do hope that is working fine when my package is recieved by the merchant on the 12th of May. Even though I have the option to view what GoldFellow is offering me through a detailed breakdown, I hope Goldview doesn't breakdown! LOL
I will definitly post another comment once the transaction has been completed, which ever direction it goes! Thank you for the opportunity to vioce my opinion on your company. We do need more companies that will make the consumer as reassured as you do Mr. Gusky.
Sinceely,
Ms. Ali

ComplaintsBoard
A
7:32 pm EST
Featured review
This review was chosen algorithmically as the most valued customer feedback.

Goldfellow.com - STAY AWAY!!! I had originally sent my items in to them with the intention to get some extra cash for the holidays to buy my kids some presents. I printed my free FedEx label and immediately sent my jewelry in. Their tracking system was not real time! When I first called about my jewelry they did not have an answer to even where it was, let...

Read full review of GoldFellow.com and 21 comments

Elevating the Voice of the Consumer

Empowering Real Complaints

At ComplaintsBoard, we understand the impact of genuine consumer grievances. Our platform is a dedicated space for authentic voices, where complaints, both positive and negative, are shared with honesty and transparency.

Dedicated to Validating Complaints

We are committed to ensuring the authenticity of every complaint. Our team uses rigorous verification methods to confirm that each complaint stems from a real customer experience, maintaining the integrity of our platform.

Encouraging Detailed Complaint Narratives

We value complaints accompanied by concrete evidence. Be it a photo, a detailed narrative, or additional documentation, such substantiation lends credibility to your complaint, aiding others in making informed decisions.

Balanced and Constructive Dialogue

ComplaintsBoard is more than a platform for airing grievances; it's a community where balanced dialogue is encouraged. We welcome complaints that not only point out issues but also recognize any positive interactions, promoting a fair and comprehensive perspective.

A Free and Impartial Platform for Complaints

Our unwavering commitment is to provide a free and unbiased platform for all complaints. Every complaint is given equal importance, ensuring your concerns are heard and respected, irrespective of their nature.